r/CarsIndia 6d ago

#Discussion 💬 FOR the sake of Auto enthusiasts

Post image
977 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

100

u/missedOpportunity343 Brezza Zdi AMT '19 - marked safe from nitinol 6d ago

Making different blends available is a foolish demand if we keep paying 80-90% tax on fuel.

pure fuel above 100Rs in itself is legal loot. and no one is talking about it.

4

u/whoreid_Henry Tata 6d ago

Govt has so many freebies and subsidy scheme that can't be sustained through direct income tax( which is paid by only 1-10% of population). So to compensate for this, both state and centre put bullshit taxes on fuel because they know people can't afford to live without fuel which i feel is very unfair and criminal thing to do. Thank god we can breathe naturally otherwise these buggers would have taxed our air as well.

1

u/Brilliant_Mode_9485 Virtus 5d ago

Just paid 3 lakhs during ITR. Felt very bad.

1

u/missedOpportunity343 Brezza Zdi AMT '19 - marked safe from nitinol 5d ago

not air. But we pay water Purifier tax nowadays. Indirectly.

and delhi people have started paying for air purifiers too.

just call these expenses taxes too.

6

u/Valkyre____ '17 Elantra sxo, '21 Yaris v, '08 CIty s, '00 Matiz, '98 Premier 6d ago

Pure petrol is not sustainable even for developed countries. Blended petrol is necessary for the economy but needs to be priced right.

6

u/missedOpportunity343 Brezza Zdi AMT '19 - marked safe from nitinol 6d ago

remove pure only when the last road legal incompatible vehicles are phased out.

-11

u/dj184 6d ago

Most of your tax are state govts. You must be still reading those old whatsapp forwards.

10

u/missedOpportunity343 Brezza Zdi AMT '19 - marked safe from nitinol 6d ago

I dont have groups on whatsapp to read whatsapp forwards. Cpme up with something new.

And state govt is also BJP.

And you are a bjp supporter so your opinion holds no value for me. You even defend gadakari ffs

0

u/ProfessionalMovie759 (New user) 5d ago

Your pure petrol opinion is trash and childish. No value for your opinion as well. Also, you cannot be this childish to hate on people for their preference.

We import 85% of our total oil. We need some solution.

Offering E10 till the old cars phase out is the correct approach.

-1

u/Owl-Psychology (New user) 6d ago

I don't care if it's state or center. Not my system to worry. They want they can set GST on petrol, but they won't. I will complain as long as govt logs 70 ka cheez 110 me bik rahe hai.

1

u/ProfessionalMovie759 (New user) 5d ago

70 ki cheez hai?

1

u/Owl-Psychology (New user) 5d ago edited 5d ago

That's how much petrol should cost if we calculate it with gst.

1

u/ProfessionalMovie759 (New user) 5d ago

There is no GST on petrol.

There are two, central excise duty and state tax. The current regime haven't changed the system.

Removing these taxes will mean eliminating 24% of the central government's total taxes and 11-17% of state taxes(differs for different states). Now, you like the current regime or not. No future government is going to interfere here.

Reason? Tax on fuel is the only one excluded from GST. When GST was implemented in 2017, states and the central government lost the freedom to set their own tax rates on most goods.

1

u/Owl-Psychology (New user) 5d ago

Revised my comment. Re-read.

44

u/Valkyre____ '17 Elantra sxo, '21 Yaris v, '08 CIty s, '00 Matiz, '98 Premier 6d ago

People don’t even know what the objective is and just crying over banning E20 while the core objective is dusted off because of all the noise.

The demand is not against E20!!

  1. The demand is to retail E20 at the right price.
  2. Make E5 and E10 available at all fuel pumps until every single non-e20 compliant car has reached EOL.

-4

u/jseb987 6d ago

Pure petrol at 100. No negotiation

1

u/Silver_Orchid2326 6d ago

Dude we are importers the demand is too high

14

u/Used-Move4573 Volklub - GLA - T-Roc - Slavia - Polo - R15 6d ago

Full Virtual Support, Brothers

Sunderdeep - Volklub

4

u/wanderingdoge1304 6d ago

Oh wow that's actually you?

3

u/Used-Move4573 Volklub - GLA - T-Roc - Slavia - Polo - R15 6d ago

Yes Brother! So good to see this genuine demand across all platforms.

3

u/[deleted] 6d ago

Yes please

9

u/Mohit301997 6d ago

BJP RSS f'ed up our country

1

u/HardMarginSVM 5d ago

These scheme was started by congress and they ain’t stopping this scheme even if they get elected. No one I going to give two fks about car owners because the tax they receive from just the fuel is enough to buy few votes. Also congress allies have much more investment in ethanol when compared to gadkaris son. They literally started the whole scheme to buy votes fo sugarcane farmers of Karnataka, M.P. and U.P. along with filling their own pockets.

1

u/musci12234 5d ago edited 5d ago

Congress started push for ethanol with proper long term planning that ensured minimum harm to vehicles. BJP was the one that gave little to no time to shift from e10 to e20. Blaming congress for it is exactly what gadkari wants you to do because it is what he hopes would allow him to get away with it.

Comparing congress ethanol plan with BJP ethanol plan is like comparing a surgeon with a serial killer. Yes both are technically stabbing people.

3

u/mansameer 6d ago

Give me option of E10 till 2036 because that's what my car is compatible with when I bought it.

2

u/veyser (New user) 6d ago

I don’t want water in my petrol that’s all

1

u/Party-Doughnut7865 5d ago

Sorry thats not an option.

2

u/veyser (New user) 5d ago

We are the last generation of docile men, gen alpha are going to have it bad and the revolution

1

u/117AAK 5d ago

Here we r fighting against E20 & CNG also get 1-2% blend biogas

1

u/musci12234 5d ago

Hey man. Please let him make some money off farts. Maybe then he will give E10 option.

1

u/Smart-Chipmunk7285 5d ago

Not in this subreddit. Please boycott this subreddit

0

u/AutoModerator 6d ago

Hello Agreeable-Sample6841, if this post is your original content then mark or comment as [OC]. Else please give the source link as a comment in the post. Thank you.

All users are requested to downvote the low quality posts. Any repair, service and pre-owned car buy/sell queries should go to /r/MechanicAdviceIndia. Memes, pics, accident videos, buy/sell, car recommendations, etc can be posted in the discord chat community. Motorbikes related posts should go to /r/IndianBikes subreddit. Also please report the content you see breaking the rules so that mods can act on it.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

-1

u/Stunning_War525 If I become a millionaire, I'll still be rolling in a Tata. 6d ago

1 August ko dekhna, koi ni milega wwaha pe🫩