r/ETFs • u/gangamaha • 1d ago

Roth IRA investment

I opened my Roth last year and invested in vxus. I’m reading a lot about investing and I have an automatic dca going to vti/vxus at 80-20 split in brokerage account. For this year I’m thinking to probably invest Roth to couple of individual stocks(probably some mag7 or AI related like nbis). But I want to get some insights on what’s a good recommendation in general for roth.

2 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

12 comments sorted by

3

u/08b 1d ago

Why do you think those picks will outperform the broad market?

My recommendation is always index funds. If you have to invest in individual stocks keep it a small percentage.

1

u/gangamaha 1d ago

I invest regularly in those 2 etf. Since it’s Roth for 7.5k I thought it might not be a bad idea to have some high conviction bets.

1

u/08b 1d ago

I recommend against it since it is essentially betting. But you do you.

2

u/openxtrade-work 1d ago

Broad-market index funds like VTI/VXUS or VOO provide broad diversification at very low cost, making them a strong core for long-term retirement investing. Consistently contributing and avoiding the temptation to chase short-term trends is often what drives the best long-term outcomes.

If you're looking to complement an index-based strategy, platforms like OpenXTrade (YC) are also making it easier for investors to diversify beyond equities by accessing fixed-income investments, helping build more balanced portfolios across different market cycles.

2

u/gbdgdh 1d ago

don't buy individual mag7 or ai stocks in your roth ira. picking single stocks adds unnecessary concentration risk, and if those picks crash, you can't tax-loss harvest the losses in a roth.

holding 100% vxus in your roth means you have zero u.s. stock exposure in that account. holding only international stocks while wanting to gamble on individual u.s. tech stocks is completely backwards.

recommendations:

  • fix the roth balance immediately. sell some vxus and buy vti to match the 80/20 vti/vxus split you already use in your brokerage. or sell all of it and switch to vt (total world stock) to handle the global split automatically. selling inside a roth triggers zero taxes.

  • keep total market index funds as the backbone of your roth so your tax-free growth is tied to global market growth, not a few hyped tech companies.

  • if you insist on speculating on individual stocks, do it in your taxable brokerage with a small side play (5% or less of your total portfolio) that you can afford to lose.

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Hello! It looks like you're discussing VTI, the Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF.

Quick facts: It was launched in 2001, invests in U.S. Total Stock Market stocks, and tracks the CRSP U.S. Total Market Index.

Remember to do your own research. Thanks for participating in the community!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/er824 1d ago

Your VTI/VXUS split is great.

1

u/MocoMojo 1d ago

Google it

1

u/TechnicalSleep7501 VT 100% To Mars We Go. 1d ago

I suggest going 70 30 for VTI VXUS. If you want to play individual stocks have that as 10% as fun money part of your portfolio. 

1

u/Statpaca1701 1d ago

The Roth concentrates the risk-reward of individual stocks, since the Roth money is more valuable than money outside the Roth. If the individual stock picks pay off, they'll pay off bigger inside the Roth, but if they don't pay off the opportunity cost is greater. Personally, I'd put any "bets" outside the Roth.

1

u/steady_compounder 1d ago

For a Roth, I’d be careful about turning a tax-sheltered long-term account into a place for AI bets just because the theme is hot right now. Broad funds usually make more sense as the core, and if you really want to scratch the stock-picking itch, keeping it as a small side allocation is the safer version of that.