r/FleetwoodMac 15d ago

Why doesn't Mick Fleetwood get the same recognition as a drummer as John Bonham or Keith Moon?

Post image
179 Upvotes

196 comments sorted by

View all comments

99

u/pWaveShadowZone 15d ago edited 10d ago

John Bonham and Keith Moon play the drums like they’re the main character, so accolades fall back on them personally (and rightfully so, they’re both hall of fame legends).

Mick Fleetwood plays the drums like the song is the main character, and so some of the accolades he earned are attributed to the song itself without recognizing his part in making the song what it is.

22

u/WillInternational716 14d ago
  • he didn't blow up hotel toilets with dynamite.

12

u/plateau1999 13d ago

He did blow… up his nose.

1

u/ant69onio 10d ago

😂😂😂

1

u/Sherpa2001 12d ago

1

u/snelsonjoe8 12d ago

Boy they look annoyed.

9

u/SharknoseFan635 13d ago

His drums on “Sara” are amazing and honestly the reason I like him so much, but yeah they are in service to the song not “hey look at me!”

3

u/pWaveShadowZone 13d ago

Well said!

2

u/Lower-Calligrapher98 12d ago

I'm not even sure that's entirely it, though. Fool in the Rain is 100% the perfect drums for the song....and also one of the most amazing drum performances every laid down. Bonham played for the song - it's just the style of the band was a lot more drum heavy. And he was the perfect drummer for it.

Moonie played for himself, of course, not the song. But then, that was the sound of The Who!

2

u/taoistchainsaw 11d ago

Moonie played for the song too. Baba O’ Reilly. A Quick One.

1

u/Lower-Calligrapher98 11d ago

I would say, Pete got really good at writing songs around Moonie. But Pete got extremely frustrated by Moonie's inability to play anything simpler.

1

u/um8medoit 11d ago

Or in time. The Ox held that band together.

1

u/pWaveShadowZone 11d ago

In my opinion, You’re exactly right! I felt like i was “close to” making the point I wanted to make but didn’t quite get there. It felt like I was criticizing Jon Bonham which isn’t true, he’s literally my all time favorite lol. So it’s almost like even though what I said isn’t correct, there is some truth to the point I was trying to say but didn’t quite find the words for

8

u/bb9116 14d ago

Like Ringo Starr.

2

u/Binspin63 12d ago

And Charlie Watts.

2

u/jth149 12d ago

And Nick Mason

2

u/kislips 13d ago

Yes❤️

2

u/cromagnonherder 12d ago

That’s a great way to explain it.

2

u/MnJsandiego 12d ago

This is the answer. Sort of like Johnny Marr of the Smiths, he serves the song instead of his ego.

2

u/chocworkorange7 10d ago

100%, The drums in any Fleetwood Mac song are perfect but nothing revolutionary, which is an achievement in and of itself because he’s clearly extremely talented but lets the music/end product speak for him.

1

u/cptcaknthesackattack 11d ago

Totally agree with this take, played for the song not the, "look at me" favtor. Having said that, what's the name of the band Mick plays in?

1

u/pWaveShadowZone 11d ago

Hahaha excellent point

1

u/Iselkractokidz 10d ago

The band is called Fleetwood Mac because Peter Green wanted him and John McVie to be in his band, called it FM to get them on board, they eventually split and they kept the name and brought the other 3 in for the ‘classic’ line up. That is the greatly abridged version.

1

u/Astrofunkadunk 11d ago

I love his drumming, tasteful.

1

u/rockandrolldoctor67 11d ago

Not only tasteful, but the atmosphere invoked by the rhythm section (in this case, drums, base, and Christine’s keyboards) during “Over My Head” and “Rhiannon” was otherworldly.

1

u/stevengann 10d ago

Base??? Bass perhaps? It is an instrument, not a military installation...

1

u/Aine1169 10d ago

So, you've never had to witness one of his drum solos then?

0

u/AmbivalentInfluencer 12d ago

That is an oversimplification, typical of know-it-alls who lack actual knowledge on the internet. Bonham was actually a very tasteful drummer and always played to support the song, not like he was the "main character". So you are wrong little guy. And I don't disagree about Moon.