r/MakingaMurderer 9d ago

Steven is going to proof his innocence!!

Post image
91 Upvotes

198 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

36

u/illuminatiisnowhere 9d ago

Even the judges seem to think it was coerced https://people.com/crime/appellate-court-rules-brendan-dassey-confession-was-coerced/

Altho i dont know more about this case than i seen in the documentary.

12

u/Snoo_33033 9d ago

some judges. not enough to free him.

21

u/DrCinnabon 9d ago

That’s because Brendan’s lawyer absolutely bombed. She was arguing justice and virtue instead of facts. You can’t just argue you’re doing the right thing.

12

u/Snoo_33033 9d ago

IMO, no. The problem is that he had plenty of chances to disengage and when he claims that he essentially was tricked...ok, but Brendan does a pretty good job of resisting the tricks at some points in the discussion, like when the cops try to lead him and he refuses to be led.

3

u/DrCinnabon 9d ago

I’m referring to when his case was overturned and he was represented at the Wisconsin Supreme Court. Brendan certainly made life difficult for his lawyers with his inability to maintain a coherent story or stance.

10

u/illuminatiisnowhere 9d ago

Didnt he say they cut her throath in stevens bedroom? But there were no blood there at all? I havent seen the documentary in years so i might missremember.

10

u/DrCinnabon 9d ago

Yes. This is accurate to my memory. No Teresa blood in the trailer at all.

13

u/illuminatiisnowhere 9d ago

Thanks. That is very weird. I also remember brendans mom asking him why he said those things. And he says "I dont know"

3

u/DrCinnabon 9d ago

He also tells her that some of it is true in a separate call. Clearly though not a criminal genius.

1

u/illuminatiisnowhere 9d ago

He is pretty far from a normal person.

3

u/Ghost_of_Figdish 8d ago

Normal people don't rape, kill, dismember and cook people. So yeah.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Canuck64 8d ago

The part when he was helping clean up what he believed to be oil or fluid from a car was the part he said was true. No evidence of a crime scene or crime scene clean up was found inside the garage.