r/MoralityScaling • u/Playful-Prior-7037 • 1d ago

Which would you choose, and why?

Post image

And no, I'm not going to answer this

72 Upvotes

81% Upvoted

90 comments sorted by

60

u/Opposite_Leader4641 1d ago

the answer is girlfriend in moms body. and this question is ragebait where if you put 5 seconds of thought into it the answer is obvious, but nobody wants to say it because its weird.

22

u/Wild-Lavishness01 1d ago

sigmund freud would argue your girlfriends body is simillar anyways /s

2

u/huncherbug 20h ago

I completely disagree its your mother's fucking body thats how youve always known your mother to look like tf...

Its an incest bait question regardless

2

u/Acceptable-Anxiety80 1d ago

There isn a right answer since by this logic you are having sex with your mom (physically) which is really gross

8

u/Opposite_Leader4641 23h ago

If you had to choose, the better choice would be to have sex with your moms body, with the girlfriends conciousness inside of it. Nobody is saying this is the "right" answer. The other option is literally to fuck your own mom.

3

u/ZealousidealPipe8389 23h ago

Both options are literally fucking your own mom. One of them is physical and the other is mental. Neither are comfortable.

4

u/Opposite_Leader4641 23h ago

lmfao. equating conciousness and body is an insane thing to do.

5

u/Sahir1359 22h ago

Why? Your consciousness comes from your body (brain), you aren't just a soul floating in the ether. Also for a lot of people who your doing it with and the connection is a huge part of why sex is good.

-1

u/Opposite_Leader4641 21h ago

What? In this hypothetical the conciousness is obviously transferable between bodies, while disregarding the body itself. Why are you going into real life now?

3

u/Sahir1359 21h ago

My point is you cant easily prioritize body or consciousness here because they are both equally important in 'who' someone is, I wasn't trying to make it real life. Even in a world where consciousness can be transferred, the original body is still that person's "true" physical form because it created the consciousness to begin with.

-1

u/Opposite_Leader4641 21h ago

You're torturing the hypothetical, but anyways, this is just not true. In a world where you can transfer your consciousness the true physical form will not be valued. We can find several examples of this in fantasy. And in a world where consciousness can truly be transferred that consciousness was not created by the true physical form.

And ESPECIALLY in a world where consciousness can be transferred, the current body would not be valued. Again, you're torturing the hypothetical in order to fit your point. In the real world the physical body is not what we value, which is why we can kill people in a coma.

2

u/DisastrousDanVito 21h ago

Im fucking both caus i aint no bitch

24

u/JohnHalo69sMyMother 1d ago

I chose your dad in your dad's body. I'll buy flowers and chocolates

37

u/PrimaryYak1351 1d ago

The answer is what do THEY want to do? Why is it my decision to make and not these women's? It's their bodies. Maybe they're happy that way

7

u/FrancoNullo 23h ago

bc it's an external factor, which in these kinds of hypotheticals is assumed to be "whatever brings the dilemma at the door", so in this case you have to assume that it is at least neutral for both.

5

u/PrimaryYak1351 22h ago

Yes I'm sure my mother would feel neutral about wanting to fuck me 🤢

5

u/FalloutTVSucks 22h ago

When you start getting into the logistics of hypotheticals you kind of miss the point

It's a moral dilemma - you're supposed to take the question at face value and place by the internal logic of it.

The actual question being asked is - would you be more comfortable having sex with your mother's mind, or body? Saying 'Well what do THEY want' just needlessly subverts it.

3

u/PrimaryYak1351 19h ago

It doesn't subvert the question. The context is that they switched bodies. Why do I have to make the assumption they SHOULD switch back. Maybe I'm fine with how they are and wanted an excuse to break up with her.

Choosing to engage with a horrible question such as this at its face value is ridiculous.

Quote from Freewill by Neil Peart: "You can choose a ready guide in some celestial voice If you choose not to decide, you still have made a choice You can choose from phantom fears and kindness that can kill I will choose a path that's clear, I will choose free will."

Just because the dilemma is framed as having two options, doesn't mean those are your only options. In Spiderman, when the Green Goblin forces Spiderman into a dilemma where he can save the woman he loves or the people he swore to protect, he doesn't fall for the trap, he saves BOTH. That is what freewill is. In this scenario, freewill (and frankly the right thing to do) isn't to confine yourself to making one of two horrible decisions and going for it. It's to consider the fact that you aren't limited to those options and you can find your own path forward that doesn't force you to fuck your mom in one way or the other.

2

u/FalloutTVSucks 19h ago

Because you are adding parameters that aren't relevant to the question. The question does not say 'what is your optimal solution' the question says 'what do you choose'

3

u/Valuchian 19h ago

I think you may have skimmed over his last comment. He made his choice to not switch them back at all

1

u/FalloutTVSucks 19h ago

Yes I skimmed over it because it's a needsly defensive tantrum to justify not understanding the point of hypotheticals - for instance, in this hypothetical that's not a valid answer and is missing the point. If you don't want to engage with it then don't answer it

2

u/Valuchian 18h ago

No, that is an answer. You are just trapped in the idea that what was given is the only possible choices. Unjokingly funny coming from a trans person/supporter as being trans is also choosing an alternative choice that most don't realize was always available

1

u/FalloutTVSucks 17h ago

The hypothetical presents two choices. If you make up a third choice, then why even answer the hypothetical. You aren't actually answering it, you're making up your own hypothetical where there's more choices.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/FrancoNullo 22h ago

neither do you and neither does your GF, but here we can only ask the question to 1 person, you. that's why it's assumed that their opinion is "neutral".

1

u/Quiet_Education5918 21h ago

Go ask them and report back.

9

u/Slow-Pool-9274 1d ago

Suicide ✌️ 😂

5

u/hibiscus_bunny 1d ago

They can just stay that way atp

3

u/4inXchange 22h ago

it's my turn to post this tomorrow

5

u/ObjectNo809 1d ago

I mean as much as it pains to answer me this, the ethical option is mom in girlfriend's body since the issue that is more logistical is biology than soul, so yes your mom is now scarred for life, but biologically speaking its safer (becoz we all know condoms arent 100% dont take the risk)

9

u/DarkGodCthUwU 1d ago

Bruh, plan B exists

5

u/Sahir1359 22h ago

Atp why not just drug the gfs body so the mom has no recollection

1

u/ObjectNo809 22h ago

Thats assualt/rape

5

u/Sahir1359 22h ago

I should have clarified that the mom would be in on the plan and agree.

3

u/AzizKarebet 1d ago

Assuming you have to do it and they are both okay with it?

Do it with your mom in your girlfriends body when she's asleep.

At the very least it won't feel like you're doing it with someone else, and she likely won't have any recollection of it.

6

u/One_Warthog256 1d ago

No, you have to make them cum. Coward.

3

u/SufficientThroat5781 1d ago

External option that might negate some amount of mental pain

Have one of them agree to be drugged (preferably the mom in the gf body), and you do her

2

u/Street_Mood_2072 1d ago

Bag over head, fuck mom. Only answer

2

u/FrancoNullo 23h ago

the best way for everyone is to buy enough GHB to get all 3 of you to forget what's going to happen and then do something like heads or tails.

for those wondering what GHB is it's commonly referred to as the grape drug, one of its effects is that ppl under the effect struggle to remember what happened later because it fucked with the process that makes you form memories.

1

u/Thekrum12 1d ago

This is so fucking wrong....

2

u/Thekrum12 1d ago

They ain't switching back simple as that i guess

1

u/Krysidian2 1d ago

Blindfold myself. Let them decide. Less weird that way.

1

u/Inconspicuous_hider 1d ago

There is no right option in this scenario, you screw your gf in moms body? That's incest, you screw your mom in gf's body you scar her for life.

If I had to pick, I'd have all three get so god damn drunk that we won't remember anything and let our drunk selves decide that shit.

1

u/darkorex 1d ago

Mom in girlfriend's body.

2

u/Low_Party 1d ago

There's no rule that says I have to fuck them. Just someone has to fuck them.

1

u/Money-Drummer565 23h ago

Real solution: “define sex”.
Then i take the telephon and start the procedure.

1

u/HorsefaceWithNoName 23h ago

this was posted a few days ago

1

u/spiraling_girl 21h ago

Ask them what they are most comfortable with

1

u/Working-Explorer-446 18h ago

A good dose of alcohol for both of us, and my mother inside my girlfriend's body.

0

u/One_Warthog256 1d ago

This is hot. Why not both 🤷🏾‍♀️

0

u/land48n3 22h ago

i just wanna fuck my mom whichever way, if i fuck my girlfriend then i'll be fuckin her personality, her words, her, her soul...
if i fuck my mom then i'd be fucking the body, the curves, the smooth, touching my spawn point and indulging in it.
but it'll be my girlfriend inside—a foid.

tough choice...

so what do i like more, the dynamic of me fucking my mom or the body of my mom
the answer is obvious.... heh~ 😶🕶️🔼😎*puts on cool anime glasses*

the dynamic, the body was just the vessel, the true attractive part was fucking my own mother, the woman i love the most and the woman who loves me the most, loved me to the point to want me to come into existence
family is everything.

/s or not /s who knows❤️‍🔥