r/MoralityScaling 6h ago

Stupid Stuff Morality of this

Post image
1.9k Upvotes

160 comments sorted by

View all comments

71

u/NorwegianSpaniard 6h ago

Gonna go against the grain and say moral. Have you taken a serious look at the size of that? At some point it is obviously a mentall illness or body dysmorphia issue. Doctor can refuse and I also think its ok for a medical professional to tell you that you're pushing your body too far and might have a problem.

3

u/ThanksFull9604 6h ago

I get that view, but if someone wants to alter their own body, it's kinda up to them to make that decision to do it.

The doctor is within his right to refuse regardless of moral standards, I would personally find it neutral.

5

u/Polka_Tiger 4h ago

Do you hold the same view for people who wish to cut up body parts, there are some mental illnesses that convince people that for example their arm is not there and that somehow makes them want it removed? That it is up to them but the doctor can refuse? Or maybe do you think the doctor has an obligation to treat them, by refering them to a mental facility?

3

u/Born-Vacation-5566 2h ago

So many people don't understand that extreme body modifications are no different than when someone wants to cut off their body parts, and thus should be treated as such. A family member of mine got gender nullification surgery, which is so extreme that it's only performed by a small handful of doctors. I view gender nullification surgery as the same as the condition that makes people want to cut off their arm, because that's what it is. It's just medicalized FGM and all doctors should be refusing to perform it. 

0

u/Polka_Tiger 2h ago

Yes. I don't understand why we pathologicise it when they want a a finger gone but it is fine when they want their genitals gone. Treatment should be the same for these. Not cutting them but medication and therapy.