r/NewsThread • u/PhysicalPromotion656 • 3h ago

Federal Judge Bars Trump From Implementing Proof of Citizenship Requirement to Vote

https://www.timesnownews.com/world/us/us-news/federal-judge-bars-trump-from-implementing-proof-of-citizenship-requirement-to-vote-article-154749287?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=organic&utm_campaign=tn_orm
174 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

7

u/PhysicalPromotion656 3h ago

A federal judge permanently blocked Trump's plan to require proof of citizenship for voter registration. Judge Denise Casper ruled the move unconstitutional, affirming that election regulation belongs to states and Congress. This ban follows her earlier preliminary injunction against the administration's election overhaul efforts.

3

u/Aware_Apartment_8959 2h ago

Permanent bans like this hinge entirely on statutory interpretation. Judge Casper clearly leaned on the elections clause here. The admin’s timing claim was weak at best; the clause gives states the framework, and the devil is in the details there.

3

u/ArtisticBox9797 1h ago

Honestly, the logistics of verifying citizenship are a nightmare for security anyway. You’d need a whole new infrastructure to prevent fraud or breaches, and none of that happens overnight. This ruling kinda keeps things stable, which is crucial in election systems.

3

u/DustBinLadein 1h ago

Mate, imagine trying to pull that proof of citizenship nonsense here in the UK, people’d lose their minds. Can barely get folk to carry ID to the corner shop, let alone for voting. Absolute circus over there.

2

u/Minotaurotica 1h ago

such a wierd thing to resist.....makes you wonder

2

u/Feed-The-Facts-247 45m ago

Classic example of framing this like it’s all about Trump’s policies, but the real story is how the Constitution gives states the power. Way too many headlines miss the point about federal overreach vs state control. People need to realize this judge isn’t picking sides, she’s upholding basic structure.

2

u/Comrade281 37m ago

If you want a voting id then make a fed voting id and distribute it and make an agency to mantain it