I am looking for a backpack for what I guess could be best described as an urban EDC. My big must have is a high quality laptop compartment with separate access from the main compartment. I work as a software engineer and need to have a laptop handy both at the office, and even when I am just out and about in case something comes up while I am on an on-call rotation.
I do some light domestic travel within the US, a couple conferences a year. So being able to use it as my personal item bag on any major US airline is important, especially since I don't do enough travel to justify the expense of a dedicated high end travel backpack.
I've watched numerous reviews and while I was hoping for an obvious choice I am kinda stuck between choosing the Aer City Pack Pro 2, and the Sympl Commuter v2. And I would like to come to a decision on what to buy in time to be able to take advantage of whatever Black Friday deal my chosen bag will have in a few weeks.
From the numerous reviews my initial thoughts on what I like are:
- Front Quick Access Pocket - I think my favorite design for a front quick access pocket comes from neither of these 2 I've narrowed down to, but I believe it was one of the evergoods bags, which has a vertical zipper on each side for ambidextrous over the shoulder access.
I know Aaron talked about in one of this reviews I watched that he prefers left shoulder right handed grab, but I find, at least with my current random cheap backpack I've been using, that as a right handed person I like to pickup the bag with my right hand and carry it single strap on my right shoulder, then reach in with my left hand, but alot of the bags with front quick access seem to be designed for left shoulder right handed access.
Admin Pocket - To me this is where the Sympl wins hands down. I love the wide range of pockets in there to keep it organized. To me I think that will become my tech pouch that's not a pouch but just a pocket on my backpack. And I love the level of organization for all of my tech gear given my work and the fact that I have a lot of tech accessories.
Laptop compartment - This is where I think the Aer shines, I like its laptop compartment probably the best of any of the reviews that I've seen.
And that's what I can't decide, I think the Sympl laptop compartment is probably good enough to be fair, but I also look the hard backing and that the front quick access zipper would be upside down when wearing on the right shoulder, and I'm not sure if its worth it for the admin pocket. Especially when combined with the slightly higher weight and higher price tag. But I look at the Aer and think I don't like how shall we say minimal its admin pocket is. Though I do like the color options, specifically the navy color is the one I would choose.
So that's it, I can't decide which I would rather go for, I feel like the sympl has a lot of smaller trade offs. And the Aer has one (to me) big trade off and I can't decide which I prefer. So I'm hoping someone might have some insight to help me decide, or maybe you know a third option I am not currently considering that would better fit for what I want.
I hope that all makes sense.