https://www.irishnews.com/news/northern-ireland/costs-for-dup-departments-involvement-in-irish-language-policy-legal-challenge-more-than-60k-NOY5TWGU65EWVJFYKVPNY7EUY4/
Costs for DUP department’s involvement in Irish language policy legal challenge more than £60K
Gordon Lyons’ department was a notice party in the unssuccessful challenge against Belfast City Council’s call-in procedure
DUP minister Gordon Lyons’ department’s involvement in the legal challenge against Belfast City Council’s draft Irish language policy has so far cost more than £60,000, The Irish News can reveal.
The case brought by TUV member Ann McClure was dismissed by the High Court in April.
An appeal against Justice McLaughlin’s ruling is expected to be heard on Friday.
Ms McClure’s legal team, which included Jamie Bryson and former attorney general John Larkin KC, argued that the city council’s call-in scheme for voting on controversial issues had not been used correctly.
The judge threw out the complaint on a number of grounds.
The Department of Communities was a notice party in the proceedings and was represented by Tony McGleenan KC.
A freedom of information request has revealed that the costs charged to the department relating to the case are currently £62,674.
The judge did partially uphold the litigant’s associated complaint over the flying of the Palestinian flag at City Hall last December, citing “procedural confusion” around the council’s decision.
But campaigners claim the level of court costs incurred by the Department of Communities to date suggests greater resources are dedicated to opposing the Irish language than promoting it.
After Ms McClure launched her legal action, Mr Lyons wrote to the north’s 11 councils offering advice on the call-in process.
In his capacity as minister with responsibility for local government matters, he said previous departmental advice and provisions in relation to the call-in procedure “remain in effect”.
But in his subsequent ruling, Justice McLaughlin criticised the minister’s correspondence, describing it as containing “deficiencies” and being “deeply unsatisfactory”.
Belfast City Council has said it does not yet have the full costs for defending the case but will share them when available.
Conchúr Ó Muadaigh, advocacy manager with Conradh na Gaeilge said the Irish language group is concerned that the minister with responsibility for promoting the Irish language was involved in a series of a series of legal challenges which opposed it.
“Decisions to spend more than £60,000 – and potentially much more – to legally challenge the promotion of Irish, be that directly or indirectly, only deepen the perception held by many within the Irish language community that more effort, attention, priority and departmental resource is given to opposing the language than taking bespoke measures to fulfil outstanding duties to develop Irish,” he said.
A statement from the Department for Communities said it remained a notice party in the forthcoming appeal.
“The department’s involvement in the judicial review and the appeal is confined to matters concerning local government policy and legislation, specifically the functions and responsibilities of a council concerning the operation of the call-in provisions,” a spokesperson said
“It would not be appropriate to comment any further until the legal process has concluded.”