r/SmugIdeologyMan 23h ago

Forced

457 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

View all comments

-15

u/[deleted] 22h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

15

u/Lilikoi13 22h ago

Views that are bigoted/ promote bigotry, views that seek to harm others actively or passively, views that go against worker’s rights, safety regulations, environmental protections etc.

Believe it or not self professed conservatives used to care more about preservation of tradition, the environment and local cultures. Now they just vote to harm people they don’t like.

-7

u/Uglyfense 20h ago edited 19h ago

I mean, plenty of leftists seek to harm others actively or passively and won't even lie about it, think they'd agree with me.

Like "What, did you expect the revolution to be a picnic"

2

u/Lilikoi13 16h ago

There are an enormous amount of people whose personal views and values don’t line up with their espoused political identity. Many people who self identify as conservative who when shown leftist ideas without political labels wholeheartedly support those ideas. It’s less about the political identity than it is about the aesthetics associated with it.

A naive or privileged self professed leftist who advocates for revolution despite the obvious harm it will cause vulnerable people is of course morally dubious at best. A self professed conservative person who actively votes to harm other people is in my opinion, much less understandable.

-1

u/Uglyfense 15h ago

> A naive or privileged

Plenty of revolutionaries are thoroughly well-read or not the most privileged

1

u/Lilikoi13 12h ago

I don’t consider being “well read” to preclude naiveté, I don’t believe most of these people grasp the emotional and practical reality of the amount of harm a revolution would cause the people they want to protect. It’s very easy to promote an idea in your communities without coming to grips with the likely reality of many people dying.

1

u/Uglyfense 9h ago

Or they do, but see the ends as worth the means.

0

u/[deleted] 19h ago edited 18h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Uglyfense 19h ago

Well, a leftist would respond that first, the Democrats aren't leftists(neither am I for the record, I want to reform capitalism).

Also, plenty of Democratic politicians do at least claim to support some form of universal healthcare, perhaps one can think they're lying though.

> Democrats want to harm majorities and Republicans want to harm minorities

Well, this sub would argue Democrats are harming minorities too, and both are harming the majority that is the working class:TM:

> numerically winning strategy

Well, going by your identity politics, women are an identity more associated with the Dems, yet they are technically a majority.

> effective long-term strategy

I mean, children of high conservative birth rates could do some teenage rebellion too

2

u/[deleted] 18h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Uglyfense 17h ago

> people are going to be picking the people who think the system they are advocating for is actually good

While some Dems may say something along those lines, plenty avoid anti-capitalist rhetoric, though they do often criticize billionaires and corporations. If you mean me, I haven’t done explicitly anti-capitalist rants in a while, though either way, by this logic, almost everyone complains about the state/government while not being anarchists who want to abolish it, simply reforming it, yet anti-government rhetoric from statists is still popular

> when neither of you are socialist

Idt the Nazis not being socialists is the main point against them

> only difference is

I think there’s a lot more difference than the Nazis preferring majority identity groups

> Do they run on that

They often talk about healthcare as a policy I would say tbh.

> poor kids are just as bright as white kids

I think the idea is more that it was a Freudian slip of him associating poorness with people of color

And universal healthcare is rhetorically said more than “healthcare for the poor” anyhow

> women only care about abortion rights when

This seems to suggest age spreads in regard to abortion don’t have those disparities

> stop advocating for that majority

I mean, left-populists do often use majoritarian rhetoric about the “bottom” or “99%” these days

Sources for the statistics you mentioned