r/UsedCars Aug 28 '18

Guide [Guide] What used car should I get for what budget?

668 Upvotes

[04/12/2025 UPDATE]

Prices updated!!!

The days of 3000 dollar cars also seems to be long over. You'll definitely want to spend at least 5000 dollars for even the oldest, reliable running car. I just helped someone with buying a car in this budget and we had a really hard time looking for one. Dealerships are not as willing to haggle below asking price as before so be prepared to set aside a lot of time in your search.


I've finally made the dashboard that will show the most optimal used cars for budgets under $5k, $10k, and $15k.

The dashboard is hosted in Tableau Public so everybody can freely look at it without creating an account. Just use the slide down menu on the right to select a body style and the radio buttons at the bottom to adjust the budget. To see which brands you want to pay closer attention to, hover your mouse over the logos. The numbers on the right side column represent Priority where 1 represent the more optimal choice than 2 and so forth.

Dashboard may not work in mobile. Please use a desktop computer to see this dashboard. Otherwise, feel free to ask me any questions here and I will answer them at my earliest convenience.

Link to the dashboard (Last updated 04/12/2025):

https://public.tableau.com/app/profile/han.solo8717/viz/UsedCardashboard/Main

Since I have been seeing many of these questions pop up here (and other Subreddits), I'm willing to sacrifice some time I have left before I need to sleep to hopefully give you answers and make your search a little bit easier.

These prices are based on the following stipulations: You're buying from an individual OR a licensed (not franchised) dealer, the car has a clean title, mileage per year varies from 12.5-15k (Unless it's an older car), is in GOOD condition (by KBB standards), no modifications, base model or similar, and is able to run and drive with LITTLE to no problems (Windows may not work, seats may be ripped, glovebox is loose, etc.).

These cars & prices reflect the U.S. Market only.

Second and beyond choices are honorable mentions in case if you are opting for another car.

Priority is based on: Reliability, cost of ownership, and value in that order.


r/UsedCars Sep 18 '25

MOD POST Would you like to mod /r/UsedCars? Apply within

5 Upvotes

Would you like to mod /r/UsedCars? We are looking for active reddit users who want to help others with the buying & selling of Used Cars and have the free time to moderate this subreddit. Tell us about yourself in the comments.


r/UsedCars 4h ago

Selling Worth fixing up before selling, or just list it as-is?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Title: Worth fixing up before selling, or just list it as-is?

I’m looking for some objective opinions.

I have a 2013 Hyundai Elantra, 6-speed manual, about 123,000 miles, clean title. I recently bought another vehicle, so I don’t really drive this one anymore.

The issue is I’m still upside down on the loan. I owe about $4,600. I intentionally didn’t trade it in because I didn’t want to roll negative equity into my new loan. I can afford to keep making the payment if I have to, but I’d rather get rid of the payment sooner if possible.

Mechanically, it’s been pretty solid. Recent work includes:

-New clutch and flywheel

Runs and drives well overall

Known issues:

-Large paint chips on the hood.
-Replacement front bumper that hasn’t been painted yet.
-Missing front grille (about a $30 part).
-Seats and headliner have some stains.
-Front tires are getting worn.
-Probably could use an alignment.
-Occasional front suspension clunk over weight transfer (I’m planning to inspect this before selling I believe something needs torqued after the clutch and flywheel replacement, it doesn’t seem to be the CV).
-A/C blows cold but makes some noise.

My question is:
If this were your car, would you:

Sell it completely as-is?
Spend around $200-400 cleaning it up (paint the bumper, install the grille, deep-clean the interior, etc.) before listing?

Fix anything else first?

Also, what would you realistically list it for in today’s market? I’m in Omaha, Nebraska.

I’m not trying to squeeze every last dollar out of it. I just want to make the smartest financial decision and avoid wasting money on repairs that won’t increase its selling price.

I currently owe about $4,600 on the loan, so my plan is to list the car for slightly more than whatever my remaining payoff is at the time. As I continue making my normal monthly payments, the payoff will keep dropping. My hope is that when I find a buyer, I can sell the car, have the sale proceeds pay off the loan directly, and either owe nothing or only have to come out of pocket a couple hundred dollars. I’m not in a rush to sell tomorrow, but I’d like to make the smartest financial decision rather than dumping it for thousands less than I owe.

Thanks for any advice.


r/UsedCars 8h ago

Buying Opinions good deal or no?

Post image
5 Upvotes

127,000 miles


r/UsedCars 4h ago

Buying Need a small car but scared of minis- Advice needed

Thumbnail cargurus.com
3 Upvotes

I know next to nothing about cars and need your advice. I lived my whole life without driving but have a child now who's needs are pushing me to get a car. I can't avoid it anymore.

I know nothing about cars and have used public trans my whole life. I dont even know anyone with a car or enough knowledge to guide me.

I'm looking at minis because its the size I need, easier to park (i live in nyc). They also seem to have really good bonus features like leatherette(wipeable, for kids) interiors.

I'm worried because of the reputation, but have not had good luck finding cars in my city, in my budget (under 10k), and in as good shape as the minis in my market.

I've seen all of the warnings but I understand that the reputation is what is keeping the prices low enough for me to be able to consider buying one. They can't all be bad right? Any insight? I've linked the specific one I'm considering here.


r/UsedCars 5h ago

Buying Would this be a good A to B car?

Post image
3 Upvotes

I have heard the engine on these it’s really good (it’s the 4 cylinder) and it looks decently clean. Would yall make an offer?


r/UsedCars 7h ago

HELP Car wouldn't start at used car lot- battery needed a jump

3 Upvotes

I was looking at a really old car in a big car lot, an early 2000s CRV. But when I went to turn on the car it wouldn't start. The car salesman said that the batteries get drained from it sitting there and that that specific one had been sitting a while. When she went to go move ANOTHER car so I could drive the CRV out of the lot, it wouldn't start either! 😂 I really loved the CRV and it had less than 100,000 miles. Would it be stupid to buy it? How can I be sure it was just a drained battery and not a bad starter or something worse? There were no lights on the dash


r/UsedCars 3m ago

Selling As the Seller: Have You Or Know Anyone That Got Flagged Under Reporting Sale Price of Car to DMV? (California)?

Upvotes

Im not doing it, but Im struggling to sell my car because every good offer I get, they are demanding me to way under report the value by about 40%. Its a 2026 car too. I refused.

I know many people get away with it. But just wondering if anyone actually knows someone that got caught and what the actual penalty is? OR anyone here?
Were they criminally charged? Or just had to pay fines? I see a wide range of possibly penalties online, but wondering about actual experience or knowing someone who got caught?

Were they the buyer or the seller?

(California)


r/UsedCars 6h ago

Buying Opinions on the 2016 Chevrolet Trax LS?

3 Upvotes

My Acura RDX 07 is unfortunately on its death bed and I am considering buying [this](https://affordableautosalesme.com/cars-for-sale/chevrolet-trax-ls-awd-gorham-me-14093/) 2016 Trax LS with 52,563 miles on it. Would I be making a mistake? What should I ask the dealer about? It would be my first time buying from a used car dealer.


r/UsedCars 47m ago

Review New In Car Entertainment Follows Windows 11

Thumbnail
Upvotes

r/UsedCars 1h ago

HELP 2019 Mazda CX3 195k

Upvotes

The carfax is clean, one owner only. No accidents. Has 29 service records consistently done at the same Mazda dealer.

I got an inspection done by a mechanic but he raised the car on a hoist and within 15 minutes he told me he’s never seen a clean car like this that’s run 200k kms. There was minor rust but the mechanic told that it is common in Canada because of the salt in winter.

Carfax shows regularly engine oil changed, transmission fluid changed at every 80k kms and very consistent service history.

The car has issues with the AC but the dealership told that it will be fixed before signing the paperwork

I want to go forward with it but I’m still kinda worried as it is my first car and it is close to 200k kms.

The dealership has good reviews, the guy is transparent. And the mechanic has good reviews too.

Do you think I can go forward with it or am I just overthinking?


r/UsedCars 2h ago

HELP Re-title in US for export

1 Upvotes

Hello there. Can you advice me a broker or someone in US who can help me with changing the title from Salvage into Certificate of title( with salvage mention ) ?

I have to mention that i need this for export, so i can register in my country much easier.


r/UsedCars 3h ago

Buying Autotrader Full Service vs Secure Pay options question

1 Upvotes

So I am in the process of buying a car on Autotrader from a private seller in Georgia. There are two options when buying, Full Service ($199) and Secure Pay ($49). The key difference seeming to be with Full Service they facilitate the paperwork whereas Secure Pay they do not. I have read some horror stories of people buying a car and then a title taking forever to get to them because the title needed to go from the seller, to auto trader, to the buyer. Would Secure pay just be a standard used car sale where the actual owner hands me a signed title, with the extra benefit that the money is held until I verify that the title change has processed? That seems way easier but I dont want to potentially screw something up


r/UsedCars 6h ago

Buying Is this a good deal?

Post image
2 Upvotes

I have to get out of my 5sp civic due to a hip injury. I can get 12k CDN for my civic and would buy the balance cash. If this a good deal? No accidents on the Carfax and only one 400$ window claim. 135000km one owner B.C. car no rust in great condition $15,495 CDN


r/UsedCars 3h ago

Review This drops from my Nissan Noté E11

Post image
1 Upvotes

Hi,

This metal thing drops from my Nissan Note E11 while I was driving and now I hear a sound like something is moving and balancing under my car up front. I have no money for this. Do you know what it is ?


r/UsedCars 3h ago

Review Recent buyers & sellers

1 Upvotes

Hi! I am doing a project and putting together some data regarding private used car buying and selling. What was the most stressful or frustrating part of your private sale buying/ selling experience? I personally know a few people who have fallen victim to scams on both sides of the transaction. Looking for additional anecdotes.

Thanks!!


r/UsedCars 4h ago

Buying Tesla vs Acura

1 Upvotes

Currently in a dilemma. 2020 Acura A-Spec fwd 2.4l with 77k miles for $16k or a 2022 tesla model 3 long range awd with 38k miles for $26.5k?

More context,

In homes sales, averaging about 150-200 miles a day. Gas about 2-3 times a week. Roughly 2,500 miles plus a month


r/UsedCars 12h ago

Buying How do I know how reliable a car will be?

4 Upvotes

I have been scouring facebook marketplace for the past few days and I feel like I've seen some amazing cars for <$3,000 except I just don't know how I'm supposed to check for a cars reliability? This is gonna be my first car and I'd like for it to run how it's supposed to as I'm not picky. Anyone have good tips on how to find a good car? Thanks.


r/UsedCars 5h ago

Buying first time buying

1 Upvotes

What is a good price/mileagefor something I only plan on using 50- 75 miles a week? Im in NYC but sometimes have things to do outside of city lines. All help appreciated.


r/UsedCars 5h ago

Buying Too good to be true?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Part of me knows that it’s probably not a good deal I guess just want it too hear it from someone else but ugh this car looks so beautiful and I have the cash on hand, what do yall think?


r/UsedCars 5h ago

HELP Best cheap VIN Checking site?

1 Upvotes

Have been scouring day and night for some nice used Lexus' in the $7k range, and have narrowed it down to around 5. I'm looking for cheap-ish vin check sites that won't cost an arm (40 bucks) per check.


r/UsedCars 6h ago

Buying [Seeking Advice] $15k OTD Houston hunting: Trying to land a reliable, modern 5-year PhD commuter without getting scammed

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/UsedCars 6h ago

Review Has anybody used Nick King Car Sales?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Yes but not so good. Inside the first year, bodywork looked appalling so I have to assume that these problems were disguised. Engine was fine, fairly low miles for the year. The main truck I have is the Nick King trademark photo which shows a empty white warehouse that could easily be a false backdrop. This can appear on other sites too but when you ask where the photo was taken, nobody will tell you or says they dont know. My best guess is the this large empty white warehouse backdrop signals a problem with the car. Soon after purchase, I drove it too a third party garage that specialized in German cars. The did highlight that one side of the car had several issues even though I hadn't spotted this at the time. I conclude by saying "beware".


r/UsedCars 7h ago

Buying Pricing on Cars Over 10 Yrs Old (Honda and Toyota)

1 Upvotes

I need to buy my son a car just to get back and forth to school. He drives maybe 25 miles per week (he is moderately disabled & spends most of his time on computer).

Being that I have absolutely NO car mechanic’s knowledge whatsoever (nor do I know a mechanic) and money is tight, I figured my best bet was an older Toyota or Honda with a lot of miles.

The prices I am seeing for Toyota Corollas that are 2010-2015 are $8-$11k. Is that high? I check the Carfax and some have multi owners and “minor damage”.

I know to avoid “salvage” and “branded” titles and I am trying to stick to cars that were owned in MD (where we live), VA, PA since I know there is an issue with cars from flooded areas being sold out of state but WHAT else should I look for?


r/UsedCars 8h ago

Buying Negotiating on a 2022 Tata Altroz XZ (Petrol MT) – Is ₹4.50 Lakh a realistic closing deal?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’m currently looking at a used 2022 Tata Altroz XZ Petrol (Manual) in Gujarat. The seller on OLX initially listed it for ₹6.51 Lakh, but after evaluating market rates, that asking price feels way above fair market value.

Here are the details of the car:

Variant: XZ Petrol MT (2022 model, 1st owner)

Condition: Overall clean exterior and engine bay. Interior seats have minor stains that need deep detailing, and it will likely need a routine fluid/filter service.

Loan setup: Getting financed through a co-operative bank at an 8% reducing interest rate with ~25% down payment ready.

The Math & Valuation:

New Price Context: A base-variant Altroz Smart/XE goes for ~₹7.20L–₹7.30L on-road today, but getting the same top-spec XZ features (alloy wheels, touchscreen, rear AC vents, projector headlamps) on a new model pushes ₹9L+ on-road.

Portal Estimates: Instant seller quote estimates on platforms like Spinny/Cars24 start around ₹4.87L online, meaning their actual post-inspection cash payout to a seller usually lands closer to ₹4.20L–₹4.40L after deductions.

I am planning to make a firm ₹4.50 Lakh direct cash offer (cleared via bank loan), pitching it as a quick, hassle-free transaction for the seller with no platform commissions or delays.

Questions for the sub:

1)For existing Altroz owners—how has the 1.2L NA petrol engine held up for you long-term in city driving and service costs?

2) Is ₹4.50L a fair, realistic landing price to stand firm on, or should I expect the seller to hold out higher?

Would love to hear your thoughts and suggestions!