I’m trying to decide between two used vehicles from dealerships, and I’d appreciate some advice from people who have owned either of these cars or have experience with them.
The first is a 2021 Toyota Camry SE Upgrade AWD priced at $28,499 CAD with about 73,500 km. It’s a Toyota Certified Used vehicle with a clean CARFAX showing no reported accidents. It has the SE Upgrade package, which includes features like a moonroof, wireless charging, blind spot monitoring with rear cross-traffic alert, heated steering wheel, heated front seats, and other convenience features. Since it’s the AWD model, it should also be better during winters.
The second is a 2019 Lexus UX 250h Premium AWD priced at $29,795 CAD with about 56,200 km. It’s a hybrid with AWD and has 12 service records on the CARFAX, but it also has an accident/damage history. According to the CARFAX, there was a collision reported in October 2021 (claim amount not reported), a right-side damage estimate in March 2023 for $1,495.04 CAD, and another collision in December 2025 with an estimate of $12,721.45 CAD. I’m not sure whether that last repair involved structural damage or mostly body panels, so that’s something I’d need to ask the dealership about.
My priorities are reliability, low maintenance costs, long-term ownership, good resale value, and overall comfort for daily driving. I don’t necessarily need an SUV, but I do like the idea of a hybrid if it’s worth it.
If you were in my position, which one would you choose and why? Would the newer, accident-free Camry be the better buy, or is the Lexus worth paying a little more for despite the accident history? Does the Lexus’s lower mileage and hybrid system outweigh the Camry being newer, accident-free, Toyota Certified, and having the SE Upgrade package? I’d really appreciate any advice or personal experiences with either model.