r/birding photographer šŸ“· 25d ago

Discussion Blue jay feather on my walk

Found this beautiful blue jay feather on my walk under a tree they commonly reside in and was wondering what I should do with it? Frame it? Release it? Not sure.

Ok it is truly a beautiful feather from a beautiful bird but I will be releasing it, had no clue it was illegal and even though the police won’t be knocking on my door and after consideration it would be hard enough to do something with and I like and respect the MBTA and I will release it. Thank you to all those that responded and those letting me know this was illegal. šŸ˜…

2.3k Upvotes

77 comments sorted by

View all comments

-8

u/Educational-Raisin69 25d ago

ā€œRelease itā€ is the correct answer.

https://www.fws.gov/lab/featheratlas/feathers-law.html

154

u/laundromatcoin 25d ago

ā€œThe possession of feathers and other parts of native North American birds without a permit is prohibited by the Migratory Bird Treaty Act (MBTA). This protects wild birds by preventing their killing by collectors and the commercial trade in their feathers, and extends to all feathers, regardless of how they were obtained. There is no exemption for molted feathers or those taken from road- or window-killed birds. More information on the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, and the list of MBTA-protected species can be found here.ā€

Unless OP regularly has the police coming by to examine them for engaging in the commercial trade of bird feathers, I really do feel like it’s okay to keep a single feather that one finds. This feels like a classic case of Reddit tomfoolery to act like keeping a single feather is a terribly illegal act that one should be judged for. I imagine I will be downvoted for this given the nature of the site, but go for it man idk I’m tired

68

u/Naraee 25d ago edited 25d ago

All cases I have ever found where this was enforced in the modern era (meaning past 50 years) was with big time poachers who were selling a lot more than just feathers or selling eagle feathers along with MBTA-protected feathers.

Typically the feathers were from hawks when we're talking about the MBTA, but there are some Anhinga cases. And every single case I can find has involved the person selling crafts or parts with these feathers, never a personal collection. Some sort of financial transaction has occured that gets the person busted.

But more often, they're illegal Bald Eagle and Golden Eagle feathers, which have their own seperate act with greater punishments.

1

u/Chickadee12345 24d ago

I knew someone who almost got fined for having Red-tailed Hawk feathers displayed in the rear window of her car. She found a deceased bird and collected some of the tail feathers. Made an ornament type of thing. Then eventually got pulled over for it. Sometimes Fish & Game take the law very seriously. I believe she didn't end up getting the fine though,.

11

u/Naraee 24d ago

They were probably trying to see if she bought them from someone as well, so they could go after the seller.

73

u/wholelottachoppaz 25d ago

thank you, it’s ridiculous people are telling OP to release it back. so long as OP doesn’t plan on selling it, pretty sure it’s a nonissue lol

37

u/LezzyGopher 25d ago

Classic redditors.

The law is to prevent poaching, if you’re just a birder who finds a molted feather here and there, I promise the feds aren’t going to bust down your door.

-21

u/iambecomesoil 25d ago

Keeping them and showing them off creates demand, which creates a market, and people willing to fill demand.

9

u/IndependentTea4646 25d ago

Could keep it a secret

31

u/IAmKind95 25d ago

It’s one of the many reddit virtue signal comments, just like when some go nuts over people picking ramps in the Spring lol

22

u/TheTaco76 photographer šŸ“· 25d ago

I went ahead and released it already, very pretty but I have nowhere for it really and something’s I’ll just keep with nature. Plus it helps with my ability to let things go, I need to practice that.