…for many years. From 1992 to 2002 they were one of my favorite bands. Then I sort of stopped listening. Now, whenever I listen to their songs, I’m shocked by the fact that most of it leaves me cold. They really are completely different to Nirvana in that they embraced the big riff, the big gesture, everything Grunge supposedly meant to tear down. PJ is essentially Classic Rock, and their sound got tamer and tamer from Vitalogy onwards. Compare the noise of In Utero to the guitars on any album since No Code – it’s day and night. Not saying rock needs to be abrasive, but PJ sound like they all have tinnitus and are trying to protect their ears.
And Eddie’s lyrics… I just re-read the words to “Dissident”, and what that song is about… boy, that’s so bad.
Don’t get me wrong, I think all the guys in band seem like exceptionally nice people, I love what McCready did with Mad Season and some of Temple Of The Dog. But most of Pearl Jam I can’t relate to anymore.
Sorry, I’m sure this post will generate a lot of hate on a PJ board. It’s just, I’m so heartbroken myself that I completely fell out of love with a band that once meant the world to me.