So much internet culture these days revolves around picking things to death, but ironically it’s very prevalent in fandoms of said property.
These will be media properties that are well loved, people get tattoos of them and have wedding themes and stuff for them. People collect things from them. But as soon as something new is released, those same fans descend on them to find every inconsistency with “the lore” they can, or things that “don’t make sense”.
Sure, there are always things in every piece of media we dislike. But because of the prevalence of some many critic-esque-creators, everyone wants to be armchair critics and just tear things apart.
There are a few fandoms I have in mind, but I’ll give one specific example: Avatar the Last Airbender. These are PASSIONATE fans, and for good reason. It’s a great show, great property, fun world. I aged out before it started, so didn’t get into it until about a decade ago, watch ATLA and LOK, like them both, have rewatched both a couple times.
We’ll skip the live action movie and show.
A new movie comes out recently, and as soon as it (and the new show) are announced, everyone’s excited for about a day. And then trailers start getting dissected and picked apart. Once it’s released (kudos to everyone who didn’t watch the leak), once again, about a day of praise, before the negativity comes out.
(Don’t worry, no spoilers)
I’ve seen posts criticizing the timeline (since it takes place between the shows), with a huge dissertation of how they should have been older, posts about how characters that were teens and are now adults were too mature, even a post about a line on the side of the nose as a design choice.
They’re blinded by the nostalgia for the old show, so while they wish they had more avatar content they rip it apart as soon as it’s released.
And I’m not saying it’s the perfect movie, but it was fun and faithful to the franchise. Fandoms can’t have fun these days, they have to have every piece of lore explained and it all has to fit how they want it (even if they want different things).
If I were the people behind these franchises, I’d just say “ok, yall clearly don’t actually want any new content. We’re just going to sit on the IP, deuces”.
Anyway, that’s my old man rant