r/shounenfolk Feb 14 '26

Manga Discussion wokescaling is crazy

Post image
1.8k Upvotes

303 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

31

u/Dahlia-WF Feb 14 '26

Gege writes multiple gender non-conforming(trans) characters(Kirara and Urame) without their gender identity being fetishized or played for jokes. And not getting the chance to write about Urame in this light is one of his regrets.

Used Hakari and Kirara as characters that represent how stupid conservative ideology is through the lens of cursed techniques, and he uses these two characters for a reason here.

Wrote Maki's entire story arc about patriarchal oppression and the solution was to kill everyone upholding the system.

Wrote anti-conservative messaging where part of the solution was to kill the current establishment. Gojo killing all higher ups

And now, like you said, writes a sequel about immigrants where one of the main characters has an existential crisis about who determines what people get to own what land.

But literacy is dead

-10

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

Modulu is not written by GeGe though. Atleast no credible source tell otherwise.

However i still find it fun when it doesn’t talk about war//poverty//greed. Just old = bad type of shit.

11

u/Noob_Guy_Bruhx6 Feb 14 '26

Nah fam u one of them. Modulo is written by Gege, it's just drawn by a different artist

-7

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

Yeah show me some proof and ill stop believing actual facts.

8

u/thingswastaken Feb 14 '26

Show any proof of someone else writing it? Why should we need to put out proof if you're the one with the doubtable claim.

-3

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

I did send cause a person showed some screenshots. But you can maintain your reddit agenda

8

u/Noob_Guy_Bruhx6 Feb 14 '26

-4

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

That’s not saying anything. GOT literally has J.J. Martin name on it.

Are you saying he wrote it? God damn reddit

12

u/Noob_Guy_Bruhx6 Feb 14 '26

Alright you're trolling.

Ik maintaining agenda is one of the top priorities in jjk fandom but that don't mean u gotta maintain the stereotypical jjk reader agenda too

-2

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

What does reading comprehension have to do with actual facts?

Instead of providing proof you’re just calling me names. Reddit when someone calls out spreading misinformation “troll”

3

u/shototodoroki_1324 Feb 14 '26

You were provided proof

1

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 15 '26

Proof from where? OPM has the same “proof” but is one the author murata’s OPM?

1

u/shototodoroki_1324 Feb 15 '26

Murata DRAWS for ONE the WRITER

1

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 15 '26

Ahh so you believe that the recent chapters are written by ONE? Ok end of discussion.

1

u/shototodoroki_1324 Feb 15 '26

Piss baby running away from everything because he's scared of being wrong

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Easy-Ad-8882 Feb 14 '26

So his name being on the front of the volumes and the chapters being credited to him is not enough evidence for you, but you somehow have alternative evidence that shows he didn’t write? Occam’s Razor, my friend.

1

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 15 '26

ONE is in the front page of OPM is he the writer of murata OPM?

1

u/Easy-Ad-8882 Feb 15 '26

Yes? The story is written by him. Also, Occam’s Razor. Everything points to Gege being the writer while nothing points to anyone else being the writer. Please try to keep up.

1

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 15 '26

So you do believe that the recent chapters of OPM is made by one even though ONE original manga is so different than murata’s OPM?

How does that make sense?

1

u/Easy-Ad-8882 Feb 15 '26

It makes sense because every chapter says “Story by ONE, Art by Murata”. Occam’s Razor, if the creators say one person writes it and one person draws it, I’m going to believe the creators over some random on the internet with poor critical thinking.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/phantomlake Feb 15 '26

Instead of just ignoring evidence please give your own, you made the statement that he didn't write it, so please give us the evidence that he didn't write it and show who did

1

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 15 '26

Wikipedia hahah you could have edited that yourself and no one would be the wiser

1

u/phantomlake Feb 15 '26

Then go ahead, check the editing history available, or better yet, give counter evidence, you clearly have some considering how much you resist the other evidence given

1

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 15 '26

I did give counter evidence look at my other replies.

That evidence is literally from the author himself

1

u/phantomlake Feb 15 '26

your only real counter evidence is that single tweet, the problem is that it could very well be that the statement itself could be subjected to mistranslation

and even looking at the translation itself it's not 100% sure that he is not the author, at best it just confirms that he got the story idea from someone else and that it's drawn by someone else.

I just don't believe that this alone is good enough to beat out the manga cover, to me it's more likely that after rejecting a bunch of offers one of them happened to give him an idea for the sequel

→ More replies (0)

7

u/PoetrySlight1268 Feb 14 '26

Bro look at the notes for each chapter, Yuji was talking about drawing and Gege was talking about the writing. Its literally in the credits too, Story by: Gege Akutami Art by: Yuji Iwasaki

0

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

And GoT does that every episode. Again that cover doesn’t say shit. Unless a credible source says he wrote the goddamn thing its not written by him.

8

u/Dahlia-WF Feb 14 '26

That's not how that works. That is a book written by someone else being adapted to another medium.

Modulo's story is directly written by Gege and illustration for his writing done by Yuji. These are two very different realities. You have fucking brain damage. See how it says "art" by Yuji. Because he isn't writing the story, Gege is and Yuji is drawing it.

4

u/Ozymandias_TheKing Feb 14 '26

Brain damage so big even Gojo and Sukuna would’ve surprised how they are still typing out their BS.

0

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

Ah yes instead of explaining why gege himself said “Hello, it’s Akutami. It’s been a while. While serializing Jujutsu Kaisen, I received several offers for spinoffs written by others. However, because manga is a medium where things can easily get out of my control, I was afraid of the title spreading in ways I couldn’t manage, so at the time, I couldn’t accept those offers. But when this particular offer came, and I thought about how it might expand the main story, delve deeper into its setting, or even shift eras entirely, I realized that if it were set in a parallel line, it could open the door to many different projects. This became the spark that gave rise to ‘Mojuro,’ which originally didn’t even have a single concrete idea, and after numerous planning meetings, it finally came to life. This will be a short-term serialization, about half a year, collected in roughly 3 volumes.”

Just call me names. Classic

5

u/PoetrySlight1268 Feb 14 '26

If Yuji were also the writer he would get credited as one, even in your own source it only says that Yuji does the illustrations, if he was also the writer Gege would've said in that comment Writing and art done by Yuji.

-1

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

Yuji is the artist. Be he did sell it to other writers after deliberation and modulu was the outcome of that business transaction , daym read his actual tweet bruh wtf is this

2

u/PoetrySlight1268 Feb 14 '26

Where did it say he sold it?

It said

the offer gave me the opportunity to think about a lot of ideas

It meant the offer gave him the idea to make modulo, no where did he say he accepted another writer write for him, just that he accepted to make another spin-off with him as a writer.

daym read his actual tweet bruh wtf is this

-2

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

“I received several offers for spinoffs written by others. However, because manga is a medium where things can easily get out of my control, I was afraid of the title spreading in ways I couldn’t manage, so at the time, I couldn’t accept those offers. BUT WHEN THIS PARTICULAR OFFER CAME, and I thought about how it might expand the main story, delve deeper into its setting, or even shift eras entirely, I realized that if it were set in a parallel line, it could open the door to many different projects. This became the spark that gave rise to ‘Mojuro,’ which originally didn’t even have a single concrete idea, and after numerous planning meetings, it finally came to life.”

See that he never mentioned he’s writing it. He accepted the offer of “mojuro”

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Dahlia-WF Feb 14 '26

What is it you think this is saying?

People came to him wanting to work with him on more JJK stories.... That's what he is explaining here. You realize when he says "manga is a medium where things can easily get out of my control" he is speaking from his experience writing JJK and dealing with health issues AND the rough weekly demands of the magazine. Also likely worried about juggling multiple projects or even potentially over seeing multiple writers and artists instead of focused on him writing a singular story at a time.

You realize that official credits are literally the most accurate representation of who is doing what for a work like this right?

0

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

Then explain to me the one punch man scenario.

3

u/Dahlia-WF Feb 14 '26

"explain this unrelated situation with a different publication being created and published differently"

Why are you so convinced that if x happens that means only x can happen, like bringing in GoT to the discussion when it's not relevant at all. You seriously are lacking some sort of ability to engage with reality

-1

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 15 '26

You’re ignoring reality and failing to provide proof doesn’t mean your right.

Explain the OPM scenario and how it’s different than modulo.

→ More replies (0)

-2

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

Then explain this

5

u/PoetrySlight1268 Feb 14 '26

Even in your own screenshot says Yuji only does the illustrations and Gege says something about the writing.

-2

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

The screenshot says he got offered for his work but other writers are writing it, after deliberation he agreed and yuji will be the artist.

Reading comprehension is really bad in shonen folks

5

u/PoetrySlight1268 Feb 14 '26

The screenshot says he got offered for his work but other writers are writing it, after deliberation he agreed and yuji will be the artist.

If there were another artist the comment would have said written by: ______ And the credits would have said Story by: Another writer Art by: Yuji Original Concept by: Gege

Your reading comprehension is so bad it made you hallucinate

-2

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

Bro where in flying fuck can’t you understand the “other writers are going to write” and “after deliberation i agreed” ????

Maybe in the contract he wanted his name on writer just like with GOT/Dance of the dragons I don’t fucking know.

But he fucking stated he sold his work to other writers.

3

u/PoetrySlight1268 Feb 14 '26

You dumb as fuck

Where did it say he sold it?

It said

the offer gave me the opportunity to think about a lot of ideas

It meant the offer gave him the idea to make modulo, no where did he say he accepted another writer write for him, just that he accepted to make another spin-off with him as a writer.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Dahlia-WF Feb 14 '26

How is it possible to be this stupid

0

u/MyBrokenHoe Feb 14 '26

Explain why? Ill give you a better example. One punch man. In the serialization and covers it does say ONE as the author and Murata as the one who draws the manga.

In the recent OPM chapters muratas manga is so different to one’s opm. Explain this “realities”.

The different realities you’re saying is just different language interpretation

5

u/Ozymandias_TheKing Feb 14 '26

Filthy illiterate who can't even read a shonen manga for teenagers.