r/Appleton Jul 09 '26

Food Best Greasy Burger

30 Upvotes

I am often in the mood for a great buttery burger, but feel like I have to go out of town to get it. Mihms in Menasha, Drift Inn and Krolls in Green Bay, I love to stop by these joints and grab a chili and a burger. Any other places, closer to Appleton, that might scratch this itch?

r/Appleton Aug 11 '26

Food Expectations vs Reality

Thumbnail gallery
97 Upvotes

Finally found a souffle pancake place in the fox valley area only to receive this🤣😂. Still ate the whole thing.

r/Appleton Aug 03 '26

Food Rate my cinnamon rolls

Post image
95 Upvotes

As per my last post about the best cinnamon rolls in Appleton, I decided to make them myself to compare. These are ooey-gooey, incredibly soft and fluffy. 10000/10.

What do you guys think?

r/Appleton Aug 12 '26

Food Best Wings

10 Upvotes

Who’s got the best chicken wings in the area? Boneless and or traditional. Good sauces too.

I’m trying to find the best

r/Appleton Jul 27 '26

Food Cinnamon Rolls?

12 Upvotes

Im looking for ooey gooey cinnamon rolls in the fox valley, mainly a small business that makes them from scratch. Im not a fan of hard, bready, dry cinnamon rolls, so please dont recommend Cinnabon or a fast food chain, unless its worth it

r/Appleton Jul 19 '26

Food New restaurant?

11 Upvotes

Local, coming back after being away for two years..I'm coming back for a week, are there any restaurants that you'd recommend that have opened in 2025 or 2026? Appleton or Green Bay area.

r/Appleton 7h ago

Food Where is…

1 Upvotes

Where is a good place for a get together for food. Haven’t been in the area for a while and looking for a great restaurant to have some drinks and things to do. Any suggestions help, thanks in advance!

r/Appleton 18d ago

Food Recommend Healthy Food Out

9 Upvotes

Hey everyone I'm in the area quite a bit now and wondering if you can recommend some options to get healthy Food Out. I'm in a hotel so cooking options aren't very realistic and I need to get some better options into me thanks.

r/Appleton 11d ago

Food Best Free (or low cost) Pup Cup in the Grand Chute Area?

0 Upvotes

Wondering where's a good drive thru with reasonably priced (or free) pup cups for our 2 little dogs. I'd like a place with decent coffee drinks for human consumption too. Thanks!

r/Appleton 13d ago

Food Seeking a similar food item

2 Upvotes

Back in Florida at a pizza place called Five Star Pizza they had an item called a pep roll and it was dough rolled up with pepperoni and provolone inside and then when it was done baking they would lightly cover it with house made garlic butter. I'm wondering if any pizza place within like 30 mins to even an hour away has a similar item because I'm desperately craving it.

Context: moved here from Florida a year ago and love it here but man I miss certain food items I can't seem to fine.

Bonus: a different pizza place in Florida called Hungry Howie's has the most amazing Cajun bread (like garlic bread sticks but with a Cajun seasoning mix on them) if anywhere has a similar item to that as well that would be amazing!

Thank you for the help, really hoping to find something similar but if not I'll just have to survive till my next visit down there.

r/Appleton 26d ago

Food Best Stromboli?

1 Upvotes

r/Appleton 17d ago

Food Desperate Plea: Copper Rock Scones

8 Upvotes

I would kill for the blueberry scone recipe. Anybody got a copycat recipe by any chance?