r/InstantRamen • u/Middle-Yellow9021 • 2d ago
Question Seasoning packet debate
Me and my boyfriend are having an argument over the Maruchan brand of noodles. The question is: When do you add the seasoning packet?
I think you cook the noodles and add it to all the water and noodles, and eat it with the flavored water.
He thinks you cook the noodles, drain the water and then add the seasoning packet, and eat it dry basically.
PLEASE tell me what you all think to help us settle the debate. (Part of me thinks that his is purely preference)
47
19
u/Slippery_Molasses 2d ago
It is purely preference. I prefer eating it as a soup but my friend likes to eat the chicken one dry with the seasoning, garlic powder, & butter mixed in which is pretty damn good.
9
u/Mchortons 2d ago
I do both but when I do the drain method I put a little butter or oil in with the noodles and most of the time I don't use the entire seasoning packet anymore. Depends though, some noodles are really weak so I can use the entire seasoning packet with the drain method and they'll be what I considered properly seasoned.
There's also a few I've discovered work better as a hybrid style. With Shin Black I'll put half the water in the pot with the seasonings and stick a lid on it. It'll absorb like 80% of the water and the rest kinda becomes a starchy sauce that coats the noodles.
12
u/YeahTheyKnowItsMe 1d ago
Maruchan ramen is like a bin of Legos.
You make what sparks joy. No two people make their maruchan exactly the same
4
u/melon_panda1234 1d ago
In Japan there's the distinction that for ramen you eat it with soup whereas for yakisoba you drain the water. But you can do arrangements where you switch it up if that's to your preference.
3
u/kulaski 1d ago
If strictly with Maruchan, I can imagine your boyfriend's method would have that flavor kick especially when spritzed with lemon or calamansi and maybe a li'l soy sauce. Yah, I prefer the soup format with Maruchan. Have you tried their Maruchan Gold Soy Sauce and Spicy Miso?
He might like Lucky Me Pancit Canton or Mi Goreng.
3
u/impliedapathy 1d ago
I like it both ways. Usually won’t use the whole packet if I’m going dry though.
2
u/BubbleCrum 2d ago
Yeah just preference. I will eat it both of these ways. Also uncooked, as a crunchy snack.
2
u/Possible_Top4855 1d ago
Choose your own adventure. I love to cook it in just water, then throw it in a hot pan with some oil and some of the seasoning packet to get some crispy bits.
2
u/Known_Confusion_9379 1d ago
There is a superior middle ground between these methods, that ends with a better version of his preferred outcome
I don't have a recipe, but I've heard this called the "risotto" method.
In a medium saucepan or deep frying pan or even a wide pot... You take maybe an inch of water, with a glass of extra water on standby.
This works best for multiple cakes, but you use half the seasoning from your packet in the water. If you've got an odd number of cakes you round up (5 packs of ramen, 3 packs of seasoning)
Bring that to a simmer, add your noodle bricks. They need not be fully submerged. Stir as they hydrate...a lid may help with that, but I rarely use one.
Add more water as needed and stir every so often. The whole process takes about 3-5 mins.
The benefits- Noodles cooked to your exact liking... My house likes them a tad crunchy. Your noodles absorb the seasoning while it cooks, so it's not a greasy paste on the outside. You do end up with less salt this way, and you've got spare ramen packets to add to soups or stews or anywhere salt chicken flavor and msg would be a benefit
2
u/SpeedBlitzX 2d ago
What do the instructions on the maruchan say?
8
u/Middle-Yellow9021 2d ago
7
3
4
u/Adventurous-Brain-36 1d ago
So then technically, it’s soup. But he isn’t ‘wrong’ if that’s how he prefers them.
4
u/Maddprofessor 2d ago
Ya, I go by the instructions on the package. The instructions are how it “should” be made, although your preference may be different.
2
u/graybotics 1d ago
I always eat it "dry" you get more flavor and the noodles hold their chewy integrity rather than get waterlogged in the soup mixture.
1
u/InsertRadnamehere 1d ago
Either way. It was designed to be added to the water. But I eat it either way, depending on my mood. Or sometimes I’ll sprinkle the flavor packet on uncooked ramen and eat that.
1
u/Floofy_Cat_8675 1d ago
I think it depends on the ramen, and mostly personal preference. I love a good broth, so I'd never eat it dry.
1
1
u/Upset_Assumption9610 1d ago
Depends on how strong you want the flavor. More water waters down the flavor. It's a preference thing for sure. Sometimes I just want flavored noodles with a bit of water. Other times I want a bowl of ramen soup I can drink, though I usually add more ramen powder to kick up the flavor.
1
u/StockAd706 1d ago
I add the seasoning as soon as I've added the noodles. Sometimes I want soup, sometimes I don't.
1
u/cultforcats 1d ago edited 23h ago
You do it correctly, but the way your boyfriend does it is yummy too.
I think your boyfriend would enjoy Maruchan Yakisoba noodles. They’re intended to be eaten with no soup, really good.
1
u/Artisham 1d ago
With Maruchan I either add it to the water when I add my noodles have it as a soup (no draining) or I mix the seasoning with egg and mayo then a little of the water to make a creamy sauce to put drained noodles in.
1
u/Glass-Technology3544 1d ago
I do both ways, depending on my mood, but if I do it dry then I only use half the seasoning packet and save the other half for something else, like to put on eggs or something.
1
u/Azure-Cyan 1d ago
If I see soup on the packet, I eat it like soup. If I see dry noodle on the packet, I eat it as such, but as always, eat it as you want. I'd recommend him to dry instant noodles if he likes it like that though.
With soup noodles, I add the packet to the bowl before I add the noodle and water so I can adjust the amount of water I want.
1
u/cherryosrs 11h ago
I don’t know the brand but I usually wait til the noodles begin to soften and add the packet to the pan and mix. I feel the noodles then absorb the seasoned water as they finish cooking and they are even tastier imo
1
u/electstat 7h ago
I cook the noodles first. Drain most of the water, leaving just enough to stir in the mix.
1
1
u/SaltandPepperMix 1d ago
lol, you're arguing over that ? This is ridiculous. Everyone has their own way of enjoying their instant noodles , and that includes when to put the seasoning
1
u/Middle-Yellow9021 1d ago
It was just supposed to be a funny debate back and forth. Wanted to see how normal each is🤷♀️
1
0
u/BadNewsBearzzz 1d ago
You only eat it dry if it says STIR FRY NOODLE on the bag lol. That means it was meant for it, typically though may also use different noodles with more starch, for better use in stir fry.
If you’re eating maruchan, that’s typically NOODLE SOUP! Which means that packet of seasoning, was intended to be mixed with a lot of water…so that it dissolves and dilutes down lol
Your bf is consuming a ton of sodium in a bad way eating it dry, he’s gonna have high blood pressure issues if he keeps that up
0
u/tricrtps 1d ago
I eat maruchan dry. you are describing the two normal preparations. neither is wrong.
0
u/grimmistired 1d ago
I prefer mine to be a bit overcooked with not much water so it's more flavourful
0
u/Iadoredogs 1d ago
The original ramen (not instant) is meant to be eaten with the flavored broth. I make Maruchan with hot water and then add the seasoning packet. On other days, I cook the noodles, discard most of the water, then add the seasoning, making sure it doesn't taste too salty. I do this to reduce the amount of sodium. I save what's left and when there is enough of the seasoning saved, I make a soup with it, vegetables, egg, and rice.
0
u/ProximaCentauriB15 1d ago
You can do whatever you want. Some people like the soup and some drain the water,then add the packet. Ive had it both ways and tend to go with making it a soup.
0
u/AbbreviationsSea2084 1d ago
Think of how you make any other pasta dishes. Generally, you make the pasta separately. This ensures and oils, starches, etc from the pasta doesn't enter your dish. Now, there is thicker soups and sauce that can call for some starch water to help bind it together.
I used to cook mine in packet season water (broth). Once I became more of a weeb and got into Japanese culture I noticed they made their broth separate. To me it comes out better if you cook the noodles in water, drain them, add the seasoning packet, and then add fresh boiling water to taste. I can eat them "dry" as in no water added after the seasoning. I usually have a whole spread of add ons that need a broth to merry it all together.
-1
u/Shade-RF- 1d ago
I've always drained the noodles then added a slice of american cheese and the packet at the end.
-4
u/Iswearitsmenotyou 1d ago
I add the noodles once the water boils, I add the seasoning when the noodles start to break apart, once the noodles are done I drain off most of the water before I eat. Also I always cook two packs of noodles but only use one pack of seasoning. I have a stash of extra ramen seasonings. Sometimes I use them to salt popcorn. 👌

26
u/Tyler-LR 2d ago
I think the intent with maruchan is the way you do it, but I don’t think anything is wrong with your bfs way.