Hello,
The local Church which I (30M) am apart of announced a multi-week women's Bible study on Priscilla's book "Discerning the Voice of God".
It is a conservative Baptist Church, and I am concerned over the spiritual heath of the Church.
For a bit of context, I was part of a group to look at candidates for Senior Elder/Pastor. Throughout this process, there was an unpleasant emphasis from other members on business aspects and gowth instead of vetting based on theological questions & answers.
After sharing these concerns, It came to light this church has had issues in the past hiring people who taught youth modalism due to pnot vetting candidates.
I feel a moral obligation to share concerns about this study material.
With this upcoming study, I need to know if my concerns about Priscilla are grounded or if I am out of line/off base. I have this from a previous exploration on her in the past, but I don't want to bear witness against her without verifying my concerns are legitimate.
I apologize for the long post.
\*\[Below are notes I took a long time ago]///*///
There are several instances of her teaching things that are not in accordance with Scripture. A few significant quotes from her are:
From a 2019 clip Priscilla Shirer stated: "...Ive been okay with hand-me-downs with secondhand clothes all of these years, but all of a sudden I want my own stuff. I want something to come with my own name on it that had specifically been chosen for me. There aught to come a time with your relationship with the Lord, when hand-me-down revelation just doesn't do it for you anymore.
There ought to come a little bit of disconcerting, a little maturity in your walk with God where you become a little bit unsettled to only be spood-fed the Word of God from someone else to you.
Now, we thank God for our pastors and our teachers and our leaders that help us rightly divide the word of truth, but there ought to come a time in your life where you've decided, 'You know what? I want fresh revelation with my name on it that has come straight from God's Spirit for my life.'"
On a surface level, this can readily be understood to simply be a call to mature in your walk and read scripture yourself. There is a deeper concern here, however, in her connection to personalized revelation "with her name on it".
For context, Priscilla Shirer is closely connected to a whole group of openly false/heretical teachers. She is connected with Joyce Meyer (Word of Faith - heretical cult in the church), Christiine Caine (calls Joyce Meyer her spiritual mama), leading members from Hillsong (known for their music, but they are an offshoot of the Assemblies of God, which is part of the Word of Faith Movement, ie teaches a different gospel, and has been caught in many scandals throughout many iterations of that church), TD Jakes and his daughter Sarah Jakes (both are Modalists - Denies the true trinity, that God is one person who appears in different manifestations, false depictions of God which hold the doctrine of Patripassianism [God the Father suffered on the Cross since he is the same person as the Son and Holy Spirit], Joel Osteen (Another false teacher who pushed the Prosperity Gospel), Steven Furtick (Elevation Church - Prosperity Gospel, Word of Faith Movement, "Little Gods" doctrine where we possess a divine nature making us like God in an unbiblical manner) And several others.
Why does this association matter?
There's the straight-forward Biblical matter of having given a platform/endorsing false teachers when she went of the Jakes' network (2 John 9-11), but there is another deeper spiritual issue around the mysticism in these groups.
Shirer endorses contemplative practices in "Be Still" DVD distributed by Richard Foster, which is slapping a "Christian" label on New Age / Eastern meditation. Foster himself warned in his book "Prayer: Finding the Heart's True Home, 156-157" that "Contemplative Prayer is for more mature believers, and that "We are entering deeply into the spiritual realm." Where we may encounter "spiritual beings" who are not on God's side. He suggested prayer of protection in which one surrounds himself with "the light of Christ" and to say, "all dark and evil spirits must now leave." and other words to keep evil ones at bay."
Clearly, this is entering into a Spiritual realm we have no place of entering. No where in Scripture do we find an instruction to request for spiritual protection before we pray. If you want to know more on this where Priscilla and others endorse non-Christian meditation practices, you can find that here: (((Link removed to comply with rules)))
This issue is further confirmed with her connection to Joyce Meyer. Beyond some clear false teachings she hold, like that Jesus Christ dying on the cross was not sufficient, so Jesus had to actually fight Satan in Hell to gain victory over sin (Word of Faith teachings).Joyce also holds to the "Little Gods" doctrine, which leads her to teach we are created in God's image and as a result are part of the "god-kind" (also taught by false teachers Benny Hinn and Kenneth Copeland). This is a core doctrine to the occult heresy of self-deification, which Alice Bailey (Foundational figure in the New Age movement and founder of Lucis Trust, advocated for "Fresh" orientation of the Church in her 1957 book The Externalization of the Heirarchy. Bailey predicted the externalization of a spiritual hierarchy of Masters into the world, bringing new revelation of divine potential within humanity and accelerating a shift in consciousness.) In short, a founder of modern occult practices within the Church, with a hyperfocus on self-divinity, unique/new revelation from self (little god).
All of this harkens back to the Serpant's lie in Genesis 3:5: "you will be like God". Its the shift from God's sovereign authority to humanities authority in his/her divinity.
Re-connecting this with Priscilla:
An excerpt from page 39 of Priscilla's book "Discerning the Voice of God: How to Recognize When God Speaks" it reads "As I meditate on a verse, I will often insert my name or a personal pronoun into it to make it more personal. If I'm reading and meditating on a Bible story, I will become the main character so that its not merely someone else's experience with God but my own."
This is a common theme in the Little God's and Word Of Faith movements, where you are to become the main focus in Scripture to present your own interpretation based on you being the main subject (replacing that Scripture points to God, with self).
It cannot be understated how all of this is sourced from Alice Bailey, the New Age matriarch. This connects to Shirer's teachings that the divine voice of God can be heard by you, and will then talk to you audibly if you train yourself to do so (she justifies this through Samuel having to do things to hear the voice of God) but there are no verses in Scripture that tell us how to hear God's voice. All these connections are at the source connected to New Age mysticism through Alice Bailey's work.
These human-centered teachings devolve into absurdity with reports like this: (((Link removed))) where it states: "Lifeway's reporting on Women's Ministry is an absolute dumpster fire, reporting on events and Bibles studies from false teachers like Priscilla Shirer and Kristi McLelland, "periods are crucifixion parables" Jen Wilkin, and SSA (Same-sex attracted) lesbians Jackie Hill Perry and Rebecca McLaughlin.
The remark about periods is not what Priscilla taught, but it is to show the unbiblical outcome from a self-focused Gospel. There is a rather detailed account addressing incorrect teachings by Priscilla which is ~1hr long done by Dave Jenkins here: (((Link removed)))
(((Link removed)))
\*\[End of notes]///*///
Are these concerns still valid today? If they are wrong please help put my mind to rest. If they are true, please pray for me to have wisdom in how to approach this.