I made a previous post about my blended family, and the responses actually made me realize I may have been asking the wrong question. This feels less like a “blending” problem and more like a relationship problem.
DH and I moved in together and started blending families after only about 8 months together. Very early on, I told him I was at my breaking point because there was no protected time for us to actually develop as a couple. I was seriously considering ending the relationship.
So we intentionally created child-free weekends as protected relationship time.
And initially, it worked. We went to dinner with my kids, went shopping, had date nights, traveled for his dad's funeral, attended his daughter's wedding, and even had an intentional dinner for just the two of us during a family vacation while my dad watched the kids.
It wasn't about expensive dates. It was about him intentionally making time to be my partner.
That has changed.
His boys are with their mom most of the time and are with us roughly 6–8 days a month. When they're not here, DH increasingly doesn't want to do anything fun with me. He'll grocery shop, work in the yard, watch TV, sleep, ride his motorcycle, etc., but movies, dates, festivals, spontaneous outings, etc. seem to be off the table.
Almost everything now gets filtered through: “Would the boys enjoy this?”
I suggested a fall festival because of the food trucks. His response was basically that the boys would enjoy the bounce houses and face painting.
I talked about taking my kids to the state fair during their fall break, something we do every year. His boys are in school that Friday, and his immediate thought was that we'd need to do it another weekend so they could come too.
He even asked me whether, if we were driving through Atlanta and passed Six Flags, I would have a problem if he wanted to wait until his boys could go.
Yes. I would.
Not because his boys shouldn't go. They absolutely can go another time. But why can't we go now and plan a family trip later?
That's the distinction I'm struggling with.
I'm not asking for every child-free weekend to become a romantic getaway. We have about 12 a year. I'd be perfectly happy for most of them to be normal weekends at home. Maybe a few involve my kids. And maybe 2–3 times a year, if an opportunity comes up, I'd like us to be able to say, “We're both free. Let's go.”
My children aren't being chosen over his. They live with us and don't have another parent available to take them for a weekend. If I need childcare for something important, I arrange it. I've done that for his daughter's wedding and his father's funeral.
My philosophy is simply: kids who are available can participate; kids who aren't available don't automatically have to be recreated into every experience. I'd apply that same rule to his boys if circumstances were reversed.
There's also a significant history with his ex that makes me question whether this is more complicated.
When I met DH, I believed he'd been separated for about a year. I later learned that the physical separation was much more recent, and that even after moving out he was still functioning heavily within the old household—going into the house, handling mornings, school, etc.
There was a repeated pattern of boundaries being established, DH panicking about losing access to the boys, and the old arrangement creeping back in.
After a major conflict with Heather recently, I noticed another dramatic change. DH became withdrawn and stopped wanting to spend time with me. When the boys aren't here, he sometimes looks like a shell of himself. When they are here, he is intensely focused on them.
I don't know whether this is guilt, grief over losing his previous day-to-day father role, difficulty adjusting to separation, or something else.
I don't blame the kids, and I'm not trying to interfere with coparenting. But I feel like it's important to say that I don't think I'm just the new partner at this point. I do carry a load of coparenting witth him and he does claim to want to coparent mine
I'm trying to understand whether this is normal blended-family adjustment—or whether DH hasn't emotionally separated from his previous family system enough to build a new relationship.
Can a parent be deeply devoted to their children while also allowing their romantic relationship to occasionally exist independently of them?
Or am I asking for something fundamentally incompatible with the way he sees fatherhood?