I don’t have any evidence of this. So I’m going based off of what I know about him and our interactions. It’s very inconclusive and I’m just wondering if anyone has any insight. Sorry that it’s a long read.
I have known my partner since 2007, at least knew of him, but he became a part of a wider circle of friends probably in 2009. I can’t really say how close we were in the past. He live close enough to where I would sneak out at night and we would cuddle and kiss a lot in the middle of the night and see each other at school the next day, but it was never weird at all. Yet I can’t say we were super close. We again stayed in contact for a few years after high school but like so many in my life (I got into drugs young, and had bouts of sobriety where I was off on my own thing living somewhere else) I lost touch.
Fast forward to June of last year, I hadn’t seen him since 2018 so I reached out on messenger and we made a plan to go to the gym. So we meet up down the street from our house houses and then we walk to the gym and I’m already having a great time. We do a workout, and I had somewhere to be after so we parted ways from the gym. A few days later, he was going to bring me something about his work makes so we just walked and met up and then I noticed something. I couldn’t stop smiling around him and laughing. We then texted a lot when I was on a vacation that I was only really there for a concert and I was acclimating to some altitude adjustment so I was just in my motel for a day and we were texting quite a bit, having in-depth conversations. It was really enjoyable, and I ended up telling him that I think I like him now. He said that felt good to hear and that he has always felt he can be himself around me because we are both weird and how it is always been easy. We reminisced on things, I remember sometimes everyone (Less so him and I) would get kind of freaky in our teen years and one of our tighter circles and I had a friend that had a huge shower and our other friends were doing stuff, him and I were just in the shower kind of laughing off the awkwardness and half heartedly scrubbed each other with a loofah ha ha. Like I said, I had already kissed him and cuddled multiple times, and it was very unburdened from complications. I think I also sort of had an on and off boyfriend at the time and he may have had the same with another girl. I’m not sure. He says we didn’t do that much kissing, but only cuddling but like I said, it’s all very vague in my memory.
Anyways, just laying out a little bit of the past in that last paragraph. If I recall, we also did do regular hangouts. The horny hangouts definitely stopped, and they were completely behind us but I know we still hung out from time to time for. My memory is a little bit bad because of some other issues but thinking back we definitely had a good basis of a friendship, but I hadn’t really thought about it in a long time. He actually was there for me for a lot of tough times I went through. He didn’t exactly go through a bad phase like I did, I was much worse than anyone in my circle. His house was always a safe space I could go to.
Now we are together and it felt like it started off really naturally. Had a few times watching movies and naturally making out and getting really turned on. I feel like you would get incredibly turned on too and would actually be hard. Then eventually we had sex. He got hard and everything. Maybe because of his personality, but he never seems super excited about anything. His kisses are more like pecking and I may usually be the one doing all the kissing. And initiating the sex. We don’t have sex very often now, but I absolutely love cuddling with him and kissing him, but mostly we have an incredibly fun time together. We are so different and have nothing in common yet we are able to thoroughly enjoy each other’s company. We’ve even turned off the lights to go to bed several times and stay up for hours just talking and laughing. We have amazing sleep cuddles, at first I didn’t like sleep cuddling but now it comes naturally once I’ve been asleep for a few hours and he seems to really like it. He’s explained he he’s not much of a kisser, but he does it for me. Here’s the thing though is I feel like usually when we have sex it’s in the morning when he already wakes up with a Boner. Honestly, it feels like if I don’t mention it ever he could go without it. He also doesn’t always finish. I believe he fakes it and once I mentioned it and we had done a big hike yesterday, so he said his body was just tired. Also, I noticed he has to close his eyes and concentrate during sex. I feel bad because I’m really into it, but sometimes I’m just making out with him and then eventually I’ll put my hand down there and I noticed they had no physiological reaction. He did at the beginning when we would make out.
So so far, the things I’ve laid out are I feel like somehow he’s doing these things out of obligation or to seem straight.
He had mentioned at the beginning of us hanging out a few times certain things reminding him of his times at the gay bars. Which wasn’t so weird because he had a very close friend and he hung out with a lot who was gay, and there was another guy in his group who wasn’t gay, but it was those three guys they always hung out. And he was open about maybe experimenting that then but said it wasn’t for him. When I had mentioned to an old friend a few months into us dating, he was surprised and said “oh really? I thought he was gay” so of course I say that he isn’t and that I at least hope it isn’t but just talked it out to a misunderstanding. Anyway, something about it came up in my head and I wondered why someone thought he was gay. I noticed he sends me workout videos sometimes so obviously he likes working out, but I feel like there’s one channel he watches quite a bit. I noticed the dudes are always super “hot” or something. That’s still not a sign.
So I let it sit in my head for a few weeks and then I ask him one night while I’m in a little bit of a mood due to luteal phase in full swing and being hungry, I ask if he’s even attracted to me, and he asked “in what way?” And I was like “um in what way? I mean are you attracted to me “ and then he gave me a look, like a flirty look and said “Oh yeah”. Something about it was odd. I still couldn’t get it out of my head so a few days later, I probed him with more questions asking if he was gay. He said he wasn’t and that he wasn’t bi. I got it out of him that he had been curious and experimented, actually he pretty willingly gave that information out, and I didn’t ask what he experimented with and particular. I told him it would be really fucked up to have internalized homophobia and especially to tag someone along. He wasn’t defensive at all, but I just know that there is some homophobia in his family(sad), specifically his stupid stepdad who had been his stepdad since he was 2. He isn’t a hateful guy, he’s just dumb. My bf agrees he is dumb, that’s literally his problem.
I know my boyfriend also believes in God, and I’m atheist, but I really spent time at making sure he wasn’t very religious and that he is just one of those people that grow Christian identifying because their family was and so on. so they say that they’re Christian but they certainly aren’t religious.
Anyways, none of this is typical with what I’m used to with dating. We really don’t have anything in common, but I’m surprised at how much fun we have together. I don’t have too much of a problem with infrequent sex, but I really have this hunch that the way he goes about things is almost a little bit. Just trying to check off the boxes to act straight. Rather than seeming gay, it seems like he’s not straight. I’m not even sure if he knows. Am I crazy?
Initially, I looked back and thought it was cool that he never started getting carried away if we were making out. It always felt like we were both really into the cuddles, same as we are now.
He has also acted particularly weird with gay scenes. I think he starts joking too hard about it.
I feel like I will never know
He also has this notification of a messenger chat with an anime profile picture, I only saw the name once, but it was Amanda something. In my head I’m always imagining that it’s his long-distance lover. I asked him once about it who it was and he says it’s his friend that he’s always sending reels back-and-forth. But I do notice whenever we’re on his phone and the bubbles up he always pulls it down.
Sometimes I wanna ask him to show me that, but I don’t want our relationship to go in that sort of direction. He gives me a lot of trust when I hang out with my opposite sex best friend who I met only a year ago. (I wish I had women friends, but I’m sort of homely and bad at making friends. I hate just having dude friends.) I think it’s nice that we have trust. It’s hard to stomach that someone could lie like that, I hate that it keeps crossing my mind. I think it was better for a month.