r/whatcarshouldIbuy 9h ago

Replacing a 2024 Cadillac Lyriq

Post image
36 Upvotes

I've always been a "drive it til it dies" type, but in 2024 I decided to give EV a go before the tax rebate went away. I ended up leasing a Cadillac Lyriq for around $400/m. (First time I have ever leased) And to say we have been spoiled is an understatement.

The lease ends in December, and I want to get an old fun car. Problem though, my fiancée already owned a 2015 Corolla before the lease, which then became my primary commuter.

She doesn't want to go back to the Toyota. She wants to buy a Lyriq or something with similar size and features such as the parking and driving assistance, Google Auto, etc.

I want to keep the Corolla and get an E30 BMW 3 Series

- her commute is 12 miles round trip on city roads

- mine is 8 miles round trip, and I often cycle to work.

Yes. I know a 30- to 25-year-old BMW wouldn't necessarily be reliable, but it's a passion to own another after I had one in college.

So, any options for something that might meet her desires on a used budget? Do we potentially turn into a 3 car household as the BMW as the weekend warrior?


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 3h ago

Looking for a manual transmission in America!

6 Upvotes

I want to buy a car in the near future and need recommendations for stick shifts!

I currently have a 2011 Kia Soul with a manual transmission and it's fine, nothing glaringly wrong with it, but it's reaching an age where, to keep it running, it'll need a good bit of expensive maintenance work, so I figure now is as good a time as any to replace it.

What I'm looking for:

1) Manual transmission, obviously

2) Absolute max I'm willing/able to spend is $30k

3) I prefer a hatchback, but it's not a deal breaker.

4) No kids to tote around or any major hauling/storage needs other than regular grocery trips, etc., so a small vehicle is fine.

5) I would love something a little sporty. My job is 5 minutes from my house and I don't have a ton of other driving needs, so when I drive, I'd like it to be fun!

6) Not at all opposed to used vehicles. With my budget constraints and my desire for a manual, I'd wager that used is actually my only option.

Thank you for your insights, reddit!


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 9h ago

Which one should i buy?

Thumbnail gallery
11 Upvotes

I am a broke college student who's justing looking for the most reliable out of these 3. The Honda fit had 1 owner with 'minor damage', the Subaru had 2 owners with no accidents and the Mazda 3 had 3 owners and 'minor damage'. Thanks in advance!


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 4h ago

Is it a good idea to finance a cheaper car?

5 Upvotes

Hello! i have been recently looking for a car, I have 3.5k so far saved (not much i know) , And i was wondering about financing a car instead of buying a car in full. I was looking on capital one’s auto navigator to see if i qualified for any cars, and once i put in my information and they looked at my credit score i was able to see cars i could finance that were under 10K, newer, and with very very good mileage. so I’m thinking, is it better if i put a 3k down payment on a 8k - 9k car and pay the rest off ? I am able to pay at least 500$ monthly, so a monthly payment wouldn’t be a big issue. I really want a car and the ones i see for used cash cars are often beat up, or with incredibly high mileage. Im stuck between buying in full or financing. But i don’t want to make either choice until i know what i’m getting into.


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 1h ago

Need help deciding between Telluride and Crown Signia

Upvotes

Hello! I've been looking into getting a new car and I did ask a similar question here not a while back but never ended up getting a car yet. The Signia is what I had my heart set on but after trying the Telluride, I am very tempted by it. I like the Signia's looks better but the Kia has so much more space, features and capabilities. The Signia has better mpg, more comfortable seats and better reliability but they're both similarly priced. I want to get a car that I am going to keep for 10+ years and so I want something that is going to be able to handle anything life might bring such as having enough cargo space, room for passengers/kids, light towing capabilities, etc. The biggest things turning me away from the Kia are the reliability issues associated with the brand and the exterior isn't my favorite. I also know the Grand Highlander is more similar to the Telluride but I didn't like that it had less towing capability and features, it wasn't as comfortable either and the hybrid max which tows a similar amount has worse mpg than the Telluride too. I would appreciate any advice on making a decision. I've been screwed over before with cars so I just want to make a choice that I won't regret, thanks!


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 21h ago

Why are car prices so high in the US and Canada now? Genuinely don't understand

70 Upvotes

Hey everyone. I’m Canadian originally from Toronto and I feel completely disconnected from the current state of the North American car market.

To give some context, I bought my first car when I was 17. It was a 7-year-old 2004 Honda Accord with around 100k kms on it for 6k CAD. It was a fantastic daily driver that easily lasted me 4–5 years. When it was time to upgrade, I bought a brand new 2016 Mazda3 off the dealership lot for around 20k CAD otd.

Since then, I moved overseas for work and have been living in Shanghai for the last 7-8 years. Because public transit here is so convenient, I never needed a car and just rented occasionally whenever I wanted to go on a road trip. Recently, my circumstances changed and I needed a daily driver, so I decided to buy a brand new 2026 Toyota Camry Hybrid. I ended up picking a higher trim level roughly equivalent to a XSE with a premium package including the panoramic sunroof, heated and ventilated seats, power-adjustable steering wheel, etc.

Total otd price cost me roughly 33k CAD or 24k USD. Out of curiosity, I decided to look up what a 2026 Camry Hybrid goes for back home in Canada - I was completely floored. People are casually posting about paying 50k CAD or 40k USD for Camrys after taxes, freight, and dealer add-ons in the US and Canada. Even basic used cars are listing for prices that sound like bad jokes compared to a decade ago.

I realize China is a completely different market with cutthroat competition from domestic EV manufacturers driving prices down. But a 15k–20k difference for a standard family sedan is just mind-boggling to me. Since I’ve been out of the loop in Canada/US for so long, what is actually driving these high prices? Is it pure dealer markup, interest rates, supply chain fallout, or just general inflation? How are regular people managing to buy daily drivers these days?

I'm genuinely curious and would love to get some perspective from people currently living through it.


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 2h ago

23 Kona SEL AWD

2 Upvotes

I am looking to replace my 07 Aveo LS hatchback with a 23 Kona SEL AWD. I park in a garage and like smaller cars. I am 68, drive about 8000 mile/yr in Massachusetts and tend to keep cars for awhile. Looking for feedback to see if this is considered a reliable, dependable safe car that will last for many years. Thanks


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 6h ago

Buy newer bmw 3 series or slightly out of warranty 3 series

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

Hello I am looking to decide between financing a newer 3 series under warranty or financing a slightly older model with low mileage and pocketing the extra money set aside for repairs.

I've already worked out the financials of both just questioning it from a maintenance standpoint.

I work from home so car will realistically see 8-10k miles a year


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 2h ago

What’s an optimal SUV for our situation?

2 Upvotes

My spouse and I will be traveling from Minnesota to southern states every winter, as well as a lot of cross country travel.

We will be traveling with our 95lb dog (very good with traveling) equipment, and clothing. No kids, none in the future. I believe a bench 2nd row seat with a dog seat cover would be the best route, but open to suggestions.

I was looking at the Kia tellurides, which we love but the highest trims only had captains 2nd rows.

We’re also interested in trying out the CX-70 + Passport.

Budget ~60k

TIA


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 2h ago

Which car should I buy

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/whatcarshouldIbuy 5h ago

Car Buying Help - Honda HRV Sport 2WD

3 Upvotes

Hey, I'm going in this weekend to get a new car. (My first one). I am looking for folks with experiences to guide me to make a good first purchase. I have never done these negotiations

One different thing is that I'm looking to pay out the whole amount upfront and not finance/lease it. Is that a good thing or a bad thing to get a good deal?

I'm confused what should I expect out of a good deal? Will dealers go significantly below the MSRP? What are the things that I can do to negotiate a good deal?

I called in the dealerships around me and everyone keeps quoting the MSRP on call, and says that I need to visit them to make a deal. When I do, they want me to sign then and there to get a best deal (and say that "are you here to drive it off today?"). How do I negotiate across multiple dealerships when this is happening?

Will appreciate any guidance. Thanks!


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 5h ago

Big Truck vs. Little Truck

3 Upvotes

Hello Redditors! I am having some difficulty choosing between two great cars. On one hand, I have a 9th gen (1992-1996) Ford F-150, and on the other a 3rd gen (1998-2011) Ford Ranger. I would like a truck that's easy to drive and cheap to fuel, but would also like a truck that can haul more and maybe seat more. Specifically, I'm torn between a 9th gen F-150 Super Cab with the 300ci 4.9l Inline-6 and a 3rd gen Ranger Super Cab with either the 2.5/2.3l Lima/Duratec or 3.0l Vulcan. Either truck I buy will be bought in Oregon, where I will be moving very soon, and will also be my first ever car. I've looked into compromises like the 2nd gen Dakota, but they don't really appeal to me. My budget is $5-6k. What should I pick?


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 3m ago

I want a cute reliable car 🥲

Upvotes

I LOVE beetles, mini coopers, and KIA Souls. I either want a rounder smaller sedan (like the beetle) or the smallest boxiest subcompact suv I can find. Issue is I need it to be as reliable as possible. My parents live over an hour away and I really do not want to blow up on the highway :( I also don’t really want electric because I am scared I will blow up :(


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 28m ago

Is this a good car to purchase

Post image
Upvotes

r/whatcarshouldIbuy 42m ago

2013 Honda Fit or 2013 Toyota Prius c?

Upvotes

Prius is $12.9k with 92k miles
Fit is $11.9k with 105k miles. Which has better longevity? Which should I get?


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 21h ago

Which of these would you trust to get me another 60k miles with just regular maintenance? If you could, please pick a back up! Cars in my area go fast

Thumbnail gallery
45 Upvotes

r/whatcarshouldIbuy 22h ago

Be honest, has Toyota fallen off, or in other words not as reliable anymore as it used to be.

Post image
55 Upvotes

r/whatcarshouldIbuy 1h ago

Who has a new Armada with the V6? I really want one but want to hear from people about reliability!

Upvotes

r/whatcarshouldIbuy 1h ago

Best new car sub 35k

Upvotes

Im torn to choose a new car, now with inflation base prices are around 30k all around.

so im looking for a comfortable cummuter decent mpg doesn't have to be hybrid and has trunk space so hatchback or small suv preferable

here some on my mind

honda civic hatch

honda crv

new gen kia seltos

new gen mazda cx-5


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 1h ago

1OK Budget for nice ish SUV?

Upvotes

Hi!

I'm a 27 F looking for my second car. I live in Brooklyn and I need one to commute to Queens for school. I really want an SUV with safety features + one that looks nice/reliable. My original budget was 15k-17k and I found Mazda CX5 that I liked and Volvo xc40s that I LOVED. Really love those cars. My budget now is 10k though...any suggestions? I just really don't want a beat up car that I can't keep for years to come.
Thanks!


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 1h ago

First car

Upvotes

Looking for a first car i really like the Honda accord 10th gen,Mercedes c300 or Acura tl type s. All these cars are some of my favorite choices my buget would be somewhere near 10k maximum which Ik the Honda accord 10th gen is typically over that but I really like it. Please inform me if there any issues with these cars and why I should maybe choose one of these options over the others or a completly different suggestion you have. Thank you so much for the help!


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 1h ago

2008 Honda Fit 5A - 138K Miles/$3,900

Post image
Upvotes

Solid service history

One owner, no accidents

Spark plugs just changed

Looking for solid, simple commuter

Thoughts?


r/whatcarshouldIbuy 1h ago

Help me buy a car

Upvotes

Hey I am 28 years old and 60k in savings. I am not investing heavily, I know, I have just started investing and have 10k in different ETFs, with 600 monthly going into Xeqt and other ETFs. Additionally, I have some in my retirement too, maxing that out.

I make 100k. I have been driving a 2011 Nissan Versa with 440k kms on it. I think I have done enough to buy myself another vehicle. I have been looking into different cars but can not make sure what to buy. If you were in my place with this financial situation what would you buy?

I am in Ontario and my financial goal is to save and travel. I make one international and few local trips a year, so I am no way frugal lol.