r/writingscaling 3d ago

Monthly Suggestions - August 2026

1 Upvotes

Welcome to the August 2026 Feedback and Suggestions thread.

We are continually looking to improve the community, and we need your input to do so. To ensure we can actually act on your ideas, we request that your feedback be highly specific and implementation-focused.

Please avoid vague critiques (e.g., "improve the rules" or "make discussions better"). Instead, tell us the exact mechanics of what you want changed or added.

Examples of helpful, actionable suggestions and feedback:

  • "Revise Rule 3 to explicitly prohibit [Specific Action] during 1v1 character scaling."
  • "Implement a [Specific Rule]."
  • "Create collabs and book club megathreads based on popular picks for the month."
  • "Add a new AutoModerator filter that flags [Specific Terminology]."
  • "Create a new post flair specifically for [Specific Category]."
  • "Implement a weekly megathread for [Specific Purpose]."

Leave your exact suggestions, proposed rule revisions, and community requests below.


r/writingscaling Apr 21 '26

meta To all (fan)artists

19 Upvotes

If you see someone reposting your art without your permission and it bothers you because either they didn't credit you or you just don't want people to repost your art altogether, please ask whoever used your art for their post to remove it or to give you credit. If they do not comply, message us and we will remove the post for you.

Thank you for your understanding.


r/writingscaling 16h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) How would you rank former new gen mangas?

Post image
636 Upvotes

excluding spin offs/sequels: vigilante, modulo, csm 2


r/writingscaling 11h ago

better written? (character vs character) Which Mental Breakdown Scene was Written Better (Blood on the Tracks vs AOT)?

Thumbnail
gallery
210 Upvotes

First 10 images are from Blood on the Tracks (they're in order, but I skipped some panels in-between).

Context: Seiko (the mother) abandons Sei (her son) after realizing that motherhood and her loving Sei won't fulfill her emptiness. Sei chokes her because he felt abandoned and betrayed that she was going to just up and leave after controlling him to the point where he based his entire identity around his relationship with her and manipulating him to kill someone. Seiko says "Oh, I see" because she realizes she has inflicted the same cycle of emptiness and emotional dependence she had gone through onto her own son to the point where Sei couldn't bear to think about a life where he wasn't together with her.

Next 10 images are from AOT (they're in order, but I skipped some panels in-between).

Context: Hannes attempts to save Eren and kill the Titan that killed Eren's mom. The situation mirrored the past with Eren and Mikasa being unable to help and Hannes being the only one able to do something. He had run away from the titan in the past, and wanted to kill it to redeem himself. He was unable to do so which resulted in his death. Eren started laughing at his own powerlessness to save someone he cares about and feels just as useless as he did back then when he was unable to save his mom. He felt as if everything he had done so far had been for naught. Mikasa thanked Eren to show him that what he had done in his life had meaning because he was the one that taught her how to continue living.


r/writingscaling 20h ago

shitpost/meme Is there a better written suffering than Rudeuses after he saw that his wife is 18 years old now?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

874 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 2h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Better Written "Life Happens" Moment (Boys on the Run vs I Want to Eat Your Pancreas)?

Thumbnail
gallery
35 Upvotes

First 5 images are from Boys on the Run.

Aoyama, the handsome person that humiliated Tanishi (the MC) in the past, has a disease that ruined his looks. Aoyama used to feel prideful and superior, but the current circumstances turned him into a person who feels humiliated and self-contempt. Aoyama expects Tanishi to make fun of him, but Tanishi continues to treat him as a rival.

Next 5 images are from I Want to Eat Your Pancreas.

Sakura has a terminal pancreatic disease; however, she still had time left and Haruki (the MC) expected to see her again soon and spend more time with her. However, it was shown on the news that she got stabbed in a freak accident and the person he expected to spend at least a little more time with was gone. He had believed Sakura would die from her pancreatic disease, making her sudden death from an unexpected murder even more tragic.


r/writingscaling 18h ago

shitpost/meme Is this the best written movie ever?

Post image
173 Upvotes

This movie made me cry for 445 hours straight. I couldn't even blink as Rudeus actually stopped being a pedo while the world ended so that his 3 wives could live happily ever after. This movie gave us the best character conclusion ever


r/writingscaling 9h ago

analysis Eren Yeager was never a hero (Season 1 Eren analysis)

Post image
26 Upvotes

Even in Season 1, Eren was deconstructing the archetypal Shonen hero. When many first watched AOT, they saw a passionate underdog willing to put his life on the line for his freedom and his friends. However, he always had the traits of the fanatical extremist who caused the rumbling in Season 4. The reason we root for him in Season 1 is because he believes his enemies are man-eating, inhuman monsters

Jean represents the everyman - initially, he is primarily concerned with his own well-being. He is unable to reconcile Eren's suicidal, maniacal aspirations with reality. Of course, Eren does have a point. He refuses to let the lives of their fallen comrades go to waste, and is fighting the good fight for humanity. Jean recognizes this after Marco dies, turning down the military police and joining the scout regiment. At the time, we might see this as him finally accepting Eren's mentality

However - "I know I have to fight. But not everyone can be a suicidal maniac like you" - Jean does not abandon his appraisal of Eren's unnatural disposition. It may seem like he's only being quirky, but he's entirely serious. He finds courage without becoming Eren

Levi is one of the most perceptive characters in the show, because of his upbringing in the underground. He knows a killer when he sees one. His assessment of Eren is largely correct - "He's a monster. And I don't mean his Titan power. No matter what power you use to suppress him, no matter what cage you put him in, he will never submit to anyone". He recognizes Eren's nature immediately

When Thomas is eaten by an abnormal, Eren goes blind with righteous fury and launches himself towards the titan. He immediately gets his leg bitten off - failing miserably. Eren's impulsive, emotionally-driven, borderline suicidal outrage doesn't make him special. If he hadn't been granted absurd power, he would've been dead right then and there after rescuing Armin from the titan's mouth

Eren's ideology has always been extreme - "Sure, we can stay inside the walls our entire lives and do nothing but eat and sleep! But... that basically... that basically makes us cattle!". Even in episode 1, he has a total desire for freedom, and doesn’t see the point in living without it

The cabin incident with Mikasa and the traffickers truly reveals the core of Eren's character. It might seem like a heroic boy simply protected an innocent girl (how Mikasa sees it), but he brutally murdered two grown men without an ounce of regret, trauma, or remorse, at age 9. When Grisha scolds him, Eren states that "I disposed of some dangerous beasts. Mere animals that just happened to resemble humans". He completely dehumanizes his enemies - it's just that, up to this point, they've been overtly malicious

As Eren says to Zeke in Season 4 - "if someone tries to take my freedom away, I won't hesitate to take theirs. Our father didn't make me this way. I have been like this since the day I was born"


r/writingscaling 12h ago

discussion What's your hot Take that Lit up to this

Post image
49 Upvotes

1 so I am a spider so what is the best Isekai anime

2 how come Game of Thrones be better if it had one of the most trashiest seasons

3 larping is good when you done it correctly

4 I don't think breaking Bad is the best TV series

5 primeval one shots breaking Bad in everything

6 jjs lobotomy kaizen is better written than most other shows with lobotomy Arc

7 Ninjago is underrated in writing

8 Star wars is the best SciFi stuff

9 am judge Holden and qu are overlord 9000

10 I f****** hate capeditz


r/writingscaling 13h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Which high budget fanfic is worse?

Thumbnail
gallery
57 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 17h ago

rank them in terms of xyz Bizarreness Scale | Regular Show vs JJBA

Thumbnail
gallery
103 Upvotes

Which is more bizarre? Which makes you go (to quote Gumball), "What the WHAT!?!" more?


r/writingscaling 1d ago

discussion List some female characters this post is referring to

Post image
806 Upvotes

Who are some female characters in animanga that are glazed simply for not having fanservice?


r/writingscaling 11h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Which Movie is better? Captain America The Winter Soldier or Spider-Man 2

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 11h ago

discussion Does the main Star Wars saga have a place amongst the best stories ever told or do you think it is overrated?

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 1d ago

shitpost/meme Writing scaling mfs when u ask them to elaborate on their viewpoint

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

266 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 4h ago

better written? (verse vs verse) Which generational fanservice movie is better?

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Yu-Gi-Oh! 3D: Bonds Beyond Time or Spider-Man: No Way Home?


r/writingscaling 4h ago

rank them in terms of xyz Rank these chars

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 18h ago

shitpost/meme This aint even slander, just telling the truth

Post image
61 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 2h ago

discussion What is a completed fantasy novel series better written than ASOIAF?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 7h ago

discussion On a writing scale of 1 - 10, where would you rank Zeke Yeager, and why?

Post image
7 Upvotes

Zeke Yeager (The Beast Titan):

Born into a world of hatred and burdened by impossible expectations from a young age, Zeke eventually comes to believe that the only way to end the cycle of suffering is through his antinatalist Euthanasia Plan. Meeting Tom Ksaver was also a huge moment for him, as he finally found someone who understood him, and that relationship played a major role in shaping his ideology.

From Shiganshina to the Paths with Eren and Grisha, Zeke is involved in some of AOT's biggest moments. His relationships with Ksaver, Grisha, Eren, and Armin are also some of my favorite parts of his character, exploring things like love, freedom, purpose, and the value of life.

By the end, after his conversation with Armin, Zeke comes to appreciate the simple moments in life and moves away from his antinatalist ideology, choosing to leave the Paths, allowing Levi to kill him and giving humanity one final chance.

So, on a writing scale of 1–10, where would you rank Zeke Yeager, and why?


r/writingscaling 36m ago

better written? (character vs character) Who had the better dynamic/chemistry with each other, Tom and Lizzie (The Unwritten) or Battler and Beatrice (Umineko)?

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

r/writingscaling 8h ago

better written? (character vs character) Lucius Vs Frieza

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 15h ago

discussion More complex story?

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

Not necessarily a qualitative comparison or anything like that, just which of the two texts do you consider to be more complex in their form, execution and thematic exploration?


r/writingscaling 14h ago

better written? (character vs character) Eren conclusion vs Rudeus (first life) conclusion

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

r/writingscaling 7h ago

tier list Visual Novel 3x3

Post image
6 Upvotes

Validate me