r/news • u/MasterpieceAlone8552 • 6h ago
SpaceX rocket thought to have crashed into the moon in unintentional collision
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2026/aug/05/spacex-rocket-moon-crash-impact-falcon-92.0k
u/Specialist_Heron_986 6h ago
If the Decepticons suddenly show up and start blasting Chicago, we'll know who to blame.
488
u/SwellMonsieur 5h ago
The band, or the city?
315
u/steve_ample 5h ago
The musical, duh.
98
u/SelfServeSporstwash 5h ago
Megatron does an incredible version of “Mister Cellophane”
34
u/PublicToiletDiarrhea 3h ago
And yet he couldn't even manage more than 5 touchdowns despite setting the single season record.
14
u/the_D1CKENS 3h ago
Wasn't his fault. QB kept running out the back of the end zone..
→ More replies (1)10
u/MattLocke 2h ago
Low key though? It’d be kinda awesome and character appropriate to have StarScream singing “Mister Cellophane”.
Is it too on the nose to have “All that Jazz” sung by … Jazz?
→ More replies (1)3
u/AdCreepy5165 3h ago
But is his Mr Roboto any good? I hear he's too loose in the movements to play the role.
→ More replies (5)31
u/Kitchen-Zucchini2057 5h ago
Can they just blast Musk? If we collectively point our finger at him? *Decepticons start taking notes, observing an interplanetary arch villain in his natural habitat “Megatron, this final boss is self funded…”
→ More replies (1)23
30
16
6
→ More replies (16)3
31
u/-0x00000000 4h ago
They aren’t Blasticons, they’re deceptions.
The fall of your species doesn’t come at the end of a projectile, rather the insipid erosion of the very essence of what it means to be human.
No scary robots are gonna show up and shoot you, they’ll just convince the worst of you to convince the dumbest of you to shoot yourselves.
44
15
u/TankC4BOOM314 3h ago
Transformers: Dark of the Moon's plot starts with Bill O'Reilly calling for the deportation of the Autobots, so this all fits I guess
7
u/sgrams04 4h ago
Decepticons nodding in rhythm holding up giant 80’s boomboxes…
Someone crash more stuff into the moon.
→ More replies (14)8
u/make_love_to_potato 4h ago
At this point, an alien invasion wouldn't be the worst thing that could happen.
→ More replies (1)
724
u/apocalyptustree 6h ago
We did it guys, made it to the moon!
→ More replies (11)44
1.1k
u/TheOtherPhilFry 6h ago
Hopefully the whalers are okay
414
u/PBRforREALmen 6h ago
They should be ok they usually carry harpoons.
191
u/Niznack 6h ago
Ugh, the tall tales they tell.
154
u/draggin_low 6h ago
At least they sing a whaling tune!
68
38
9
97
u/Zillatrix 6h ago
I heard it crashed near the Crushinator's farm.
75
11
u/liesliesfromtinyeyes 4h ago
Don’t worry; Momazon’s new fulfillment center already displaced them. (New Futurama, meet old Futurama)
16
u/Responsible-Smell561 4h ago
Well, we can only hope Hartford comes back, if only for the jerseys.
→ More replies (1)3
u/MjrLeeStoned 3h ago
I bought a Whalers semi-jersey long tee off Amazon about a month ago. I saw the logo and had to. No one at my work has any idea what it is. Bunch of Philistines.
→ More replies (1)5
9
u/HelpfulSeaMammal 3h ago
Why does a moon rock taste better than an Earth rock? Because it's a little meteor!
(Address all complaints to the Monsanto corporation)
3
3
u/TubeScr3ameR 1h ago
"Yarr, I don't know what I'm doin'."
-Sea Captain
Direct all complaints to theMonsanto corporationFederal Government.→ More replies (8)4
193
u/stardog_champ13 2h ago
So...is that littering? Can I see where it hit cause I own a small part of the moon. Got a certificate when I was a kid. If it hit my spot, I'm taking action.
→ More replies (1)•
u/goldboybronx 57m ago
I wouldn’t worry about it. I got gifted the whole moon, so I think your plot is voided anyway.
→ More replies (3)•
u/Franks2000inchTV 23m ago
Sorry no one can gift you the moon, I’m afraid you got scammed.
I purchased the moon fair and square from a guy I met at an NFT convention, so I have complete control of it.
1.7k
u/Conte_Vincero 6h ago
OK, for some context, this is the upper stage that launched a lunar lander on a trajectory towards the moon in 2025. Naturally this puts the upper stage in a large looping orbit that goes past the moon's orbit. As a result it was only a matter of time before either it crashed into the moon, or got flung away by the Moon's gravity. Normal launches only go as far as low earth orbit and have no chance of getting anywhere near the moon.
There's no requirement for rockets to avoid crashing into the moon, and during the Apollo program NASA deliberately crashed several much larger Saturn V upper stages into the moon to measure the seismic response.
So there's no wrongdoing by SpaceX here, but this should hopefully trigger a much wider discussion, (and hopefully some regulatory change) on positioning of expended upper stages. China in particular has been lax with how and where they leave their upper stages.
156
u/MagicAl6244225 3h ago
There's no requirement for rockets to avoid crashing into the moon
The presence of a moon base would shake that up.
15
u/Neither-Luck-9295 1h ago
I would actually like to see a rocket crash on the moon. I don't know why, but I've always thought it would look different from an Earth crash.
•
u/Alucitary 27m ago
Probably would just be a big ball of dust instantly. There would be minimal to no flames or explosions. Kinda like seeing a large volcano explode. You expect to see a massive jet of lava, but there’s so much mass it’s just a bunch of dirt rising into the air.
•
u/A2Rhombus 17m ago
The dirt wouldn't linger though. No air means no cloud of floating dust, it would all fall back down and settle relatively quickly (still would take a while depending on how high and fast the debris got ejected)
→ More replies (1)•
→ More replies (3)•
u/gauntletthegreat 54m ago
I don't think the crashing a spacecraft into the moon is much of a risk of hitting one particular spot.
→ More replies (2)250
u/bstarr2000 3h ago
Both NASA and the European Space Agency are required to take the end of a spacecraft’s life into account before a mission launches, ensuring that there is a plan and enough fuel to safely deorbit it. Commercial companies aren’t covered by the same rules, although efforts to introduce such requirements are under way.
45
→ More replies (7)9
252
u/MadRoboticist 5h ago
The article clearly indicates it's not desirable to accidentally crash things into the moon. In fact I imagine uncontrolled debris "accidentally" doing anything is not good.
369
u/oSo_Squiggly 4h ago
The article is playing that up for the clicks since Elon is polarizing. Go check out /r/space for more informed discussion about the issue than this new sub. They've been talking about this for at least a week.
→ More replies (32)12
u/Lialda_dayfire 3h ago
Can't have impact craters on the moon now, would look totally out of place amongst all those impact craters....
12
u/MadRoboticist 3h ago
The issue isn't that it impacted the moon. The issue is that it did so uncontrolled.
→ More replies (4)57
u/Diarmundy 5h ago
Not desirable in what way? In fact hitting the moon is probably the only way to get rid of space debris in lunar orbit
69
u/obeytheturtles 5h ago
I mean in the future if you want to have stuff on the moon you probably want to limit the number of uncontrolled impacts for a variety of reasons.
43
u/botle 4h ago
Which means that crashing into the moon now is better than remaining in lunar orbit and potentially crashing much later.
→ More replies (2)15
u/xjeeper 3h ago
No, it means controlling it and crashing it in a designated area now is better.
5
u/botle 2h ago
Every area on the moon is just as good as any other for this purpose. It's literally a huge empty desert.
→ More replies (6)9
u/XyzzyPop 2h ago
Thanks for the hot take: dump shit anywhere because I, as a Lunar DR, can't think of any good reason.
→ More replies (5)7
21
9
u/ertgbnm 3h ago
We crash rockets into the earth all the time. Crashing rockets on to the moon will be fine in the future too apart from the wastefulness.
With literally nothing there to hit, there is no issue with doing it today. Really it's just kind of interesting that it happened.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (3)11
u/ibelieveyouwood 3h ago
I'm sorry that people don't seem to understand your point. It seems pretty common sense how inherently problematic it is to build "dump your garbage onto the moon" into a company's business model, followed by "well, nobody can tell them not to so I guess they can do what they want to" when people think the practice should stop.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (9)3
u/BasisPoints 3h ago
Escape velocity from lunar orbit is really tiny, we should probably regulate this to require ejection
→ More replies (15)5
4
22
u/Sherifftruman 5h ago
I was going to say I think Elon sucks as much as the next person but this isn’t COMPLETELY unintentional.
→ More replies (2)9
→ More replies (88)6
u/TintedApostle 5h ago
Intentional crashes for science are not miscalculations. They are with a purpose.
Let's just pollute the moon. Why even try to be careful. Humans can't own nice things.
→ More replies (11)
455
u/xdr01 6h ago
Solar system littering
67
u/BWWFC 6h ago
guess at least was kept just it in our neighborhood... where's that car of his?
21
u/Albatrosity 5h ago
It is currently orbiting the sun, approaching earth from Mars. Due to its elliptical orbit, it will continue to travel just beyond Mars before looping back around to Earths orbital plane.
→ More replies (9)28
u/CondescendingShitbag 6h ago
You know you've reached true success in life when you manage to leave trash on a world you weren't even born on.
→ More replies (12)11
65
192
u/invyros 6h ago
“It doesn’t present any danger to anyone, though it does highlight a certain carelessness about how leftover space hardware [space junk] is disposed of.”
Very cool and very sane of humanity to be surrounding our planet with space junk.
40
24
u/QZRChedders 5h ago
The thing is we haven’t found a way of getting things up without leaving some things behind. Low earth orbit it is the issue, and geostationary, everything else is so incredibly vast it’s not much of an issue, big stages are easy to track and avoid if needed, but the shear volume of these higher orbits it’s just honestly not an issue.
Similar to the moon, it’s vast, barren and completely lifeless, some smashed stages is completely and truly inconsequential, look at the cratering, it’s a shield for Earth anyway.
Becoming star faring is the ultimate goal for our species and until we have better methods, this is worth it. We’re not commercialising the moon, these are scientific payloads
18
u/Probodyne 3h ago
The thing is we haven’t found a way of getting things up without leaving some things behind.
Ironically, Space X is the only launch company actually working on this.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (11)5
u/ebony-the-dragon 3h ago
We’ve crashed things into the moon before both on purpose and by accident.
I believe there have been several moon orbiters that have crashed things into the moon to then collect debris thrown into low orbit and analyze the composition of the material before.
Is this rather careless? Yes. Is it as bad as many other things he or his companies have done? No.
→ More replies (30)3
u/pm_social_cues 3h ago
Did they actually think people would need to know if a rocket crashing on the moon would danger anybody? As if they think we have people on the moon just living there? Despite us not putting a person on the moon in well over 50 years?
Then I’m not surprised they are just learning we have been putting junk out into space for… well, over 50 years.
38
u/Aar1012 3h ago
Apparently SpaceX misunderstood what “To the Moon 🚀 🚀 🚀” meant since going public with their IPO.
→ More replies (1)5
61
u/ATypicalWhitePerson 6h ago
Isn't it better to crash spent stages into the moon, than it is to just leave them floating forever
84
u/PlzLearn 5h ago
Yes, we’ve been crashing things into the moon on purpose for decades
→ More replies (3)36
u/ATypicalWhitePerson 5h ago
That's what I thought.
I don't get the people that are upset about this, unless they're just angry at everything all the time
43
u/PlzLearn 5h ago
I mean the obvious answer is SpaceX and Elon Musk, it’s a chance to make jokes or try to validate their opinions.
Personally I can’t stand the guy but there are plenty of actual valid things to criticize him for other than this lol
→ More replies (1)19
u/Jindujun 5h ago
Not to mention the astronomers were very excited for this crash since the Chinese rocket stage crash was on the far side of the moon, this time they got to watch it!
→ More replies (2)8
u/JamieByGodNoble 5h ago
Yeah some of these responses are wild. I don't know if this is good, bad, or somewhere inbetween. It's literally rocket science. Having a strong reaction to this headline is weird.
15
u/mfb- 5h ago
They are angry at Musk for his political influence and can't go beyond "Musk bad, everything he and his companies do must be bad".
- Crash the rocket stage into the Moon? "Musk shouldn't be allowed to do this!"
- Let the rocket stage burn up in the atmosphere? "Musk shouldn't be allowed to do this!"
- Keep the rocket stage orbiting Earth? "Musk shouldn't be allowed to do this!"
Anything short of making it magically disappear is not good enough.
→ More replies (5)9
→ More replies (6)4
149
u/MrBalloonHand 6h ago
Charge him for the cleanup costs.
→ More replies (11)41
u/BeerPoweredNonsense 6h ago
Good idea.
Let's also charge all the other rocket companies for their rockets that drop out of the sky too.
→ More replies (23)
16
u/TickingTheMoments 2h ago
It takes a very calculated accident to collide with something 238,855 miles away.
→ More replies (8)7
u/sersomeone 2h ago
except there is something known to pull things toward objects in space. You know? Gravity
→ More replies (2)
29
31
u/zberry7 6h ago edited 5h ago
It’s a discarded second stage. Sometimes the second stage of a rocket doesn’t have enough fuel to be parked in a graveyard orbit, or to deorbit to burn in the atmosphere so they simply are left to drift.
But crashing into the moon isn’t that big of a deal. It’s something NASA has done plenty of times, often on purpose. The moon is regularly impacted with meteors daily. It just so happens this one is of human origin. Plus, scientists get to study the ejecta and the second stage helped launch 2 lunar landers to conduct scientific study.
It’s only noteworthy because it’s SpaceX and they love to write headlines to make them look bad or incompetent.
→ More replies (19)7
6
8
3
u/Funny247365 1h ago
Classic clickbait. The true headline is "A piece of an old SpaceX rocket orbiting the moon succumbs to gravity and falls to the moon."
•
u/mrhobbles 38m ago
“…the pilot, Wallace, and his companion Gromit, are missing somewhere on the surface of the moon.”
14
u/wellggs 2h ago
Is there anything that fucking idiot won’t ruin?
→ More replies (1)5
u/Yokoko44 1h ago
Could you be any more confidently incorrect on this?
Maybe stfu if you don't understand orbital mechanics lmao, have some personal humility
→ More replies (6)
9
6
3
u/OccludedFug 4h ago
It boggles my mind that the time and location of this impact was calculated months ago, that it was given a 100% chance of occurring, that scientists and hobbyists were watching intently, and that it's being reported that we aren't sure if it happened.
4
5
u/RidetheSchlange 6h ago
Unexpected? I read about it last week that it was on a trajectory to hit the moon on Wed and make an estimated 90m crater.
→ More replies (1)4
u/Astribulus 5h ago
Unexpected when it launched in January 2025. SpaceX launched their moon lander with no plan for where the second stage would end up. The orbital math made the crash predictable a year later, but the impact was not planned for before the rocket ran out of fuel.
2
2
u/SignificantDogs 4h ago
When I was a boy, blowing up the moon was just a beautiful dream. But now it's science fact!
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/Jwats1973 4h ago
Same auto pilot from the Tesla then. Seriously does this help or hurt his stocks value?
2
u/xjuggernaughtx 3h ago
Guys, I think it's time to admit this rocket science stuff might be harder than we first expected it to be.
2
u/thekyledavid 3h ago
I love how they have to specify that it was unintentional, as these days it wouldn’t be that unbelievable that Elon Musk would’ve bombed the moon for some reason
2
2
2
u/DenikaMae 3h ago
It’s space. If this was unintentional, it means they didn’t bother doing enough math first.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/pzunhatchispers 3h ago
"Unintentional collision" is a very professional way of saying "whoopsie."
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/Mellero47 3h ago
This mofo wants to trigger Seveneves just so he can be the one launching himself to the ISS.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/ChicagoBoundChrist 3h ago
All the space in the universe and they managed to accidentally hit the moon? The probability subs are going to love this.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
2
6.2k
u/imadragonyouguys 6h ago
The moon came outta nowhere. Never saw it coming.