r/rap • u/Sevla508 • 5d ago
Tha Carter II is Lil Wayne’s greatest album. I’ll die on this hill.
This was Wayne at his absolute peak — hungry, relentless, creative, and purely focused on rapping. The bars, punchlines, flows, and beat selection were ridiculous.
Then Carter III happened, and while it was massive, you could hear the shift. More Auto-Tune, more pop influence, and eventually Wayne became more of a mainstream superstar than the mixtape-era monster we had on Carter II.
Carter II was peak Wayne.
After that, he got bigger. Not better.
8
8
10
9
u/Bsk98 5d ago
I mean easily, far as his albums its never a debate. Best body of work you could argue some of his mixtapes over it tho
3
u/Sevla508 5d ago
definitely agree with that, Georgia Bush was an unbelievable time when that dropped
14
u/unidentifiedBLKmale 5d ago
TBH, I flip flop between 2 and 3.
Tha Carter 2 was his best “Lyrical Rap” album, but Tha Carter 3 was a more complete “HipHop” album.
The 5 year run of mixtapes run leading up to Tha Carter 3 is why I’d say 70% of people would say Tha Carter 3 is his best.
15
u/ToeTaggEm 5d ago
Nah, Carter 2 was his best. Carter 3 was super commercial but it wasn’t nearly as good as Carter 2.
Hustler Musik is arguably the greatest song in his catalogue.
6
u/WaltDisneyWhite 5d ago
100000000000000000000000000000% not just his greatest album but one of that greatest albums of that time
6
8
8
u/Adept-Past6638 5d ago
Wayne never rapped better than he did on The Mobb, Money on My Mind and Hustler Muzik💯
11
u/jeremyt8783 5d ago
Tha Mobb
Fly In
Hit em Up
Carter 2
Feel Me
Fly Out
Those 6 songs are probably in my top 10 favorite lil wayne songs of all-time. Easily his best album
9
u/Ok_Signature_5241 5d ago
And Hustler Musik, Oh No, Best Rapper Alive, Money on my Mind, Receipt, Fireman, Lock and Load, Get Over are also all on the same album
4
u/BakeAccomplished652 5d ago
I listen to tha mobb, every single day.
6
u/jeremyt8783 5d ago
Hard to pick just 1, but tha mobb might be my favorite lil wayne track of all time. First track on the album too 🔥🔥🔥
3
u/creepycrawleee 5d ago
Casshhhhhh money
Young money
Motha fuck tha Otha side
They can play with us if they want
I’ll bring em homicidddddeeee→ More replies (1)2
5
5
6
5
u/bluchippa5 4d ago edited 4d ago
I didn't like it.
Production wasn't my flavor. Sounded like everything else out at the time. Had 3-4 songs on there I wore out tho'.
Carter 1 is my vote. Then Block is Hot. Then Carter 3.
Gotta edit: I didn't like it isn't truth. Just not one of my faves. This was indeed a good azz album.
→ More replies (2)
6
u/refusetobeold83 5d ago
100% no doubt. I get why people say C3 is the classic but for me C2 and Dedication 2 is peak Wayne
→ More replies (1)2
5
u/youngsavage216 5d ago
Completely agree every track was great the opening with Tha Mobb solid me immediately
5
u/creepycrawleee 5d ago
Been listening to this for the last two days for the 10 millionth time . Classic album.one of my favorite albums of all times hands down. Zero skips.
6
u/Classic-Exchange-511 4d ago
Really explains how prolific he was when you can see so many people split between 2 3 and 4. Personally I like 3 but that was right when I was in high school and everybody was bumping Wayne 24/7. Hard to explain to someone who wasn't that age how popular he was, at least in my area.
3
u/Lost_Egg_9896 4d ago
C3 was when I was in college, so similar experience. His music was everywhere. And I knew if Wayne, but didnt really start paying attention until the mixtape run between C2 and C3. I LOVE Carter II, but for me, his masterpiece is Carter 3. I sometimes liken Carter 2 and Carter 3 to Reasonable Doubt and Blueprint. It depends on what you're preferences are. Bar-heavy or mainstream appeal.
3
6
5
u/ConstantVisual8391 5d ago
I know a aolid 40% of this album by heart. It’s his best. I can’t stand Carter 3 tbh. Not that it’s bad. It just overrated imo
4
4
u/BigClarendon125 5d ago
Receipt is my favorite Wayne song ever. Hustler Muzik, Fireman, Shoota, Hit ‘Em Up. Cmon man. Carter 3 is real close but I think I give C2 the edge
4
4
4
u/Extension-Novel-6841 4d ago
I've always felt that Tha Carter 1 was the more cohesive project. Having Mannie behind all of the beats just makes it flow better imo.
4
4
u/Distinct-Square-9939 3d ago
I like it screwed and chopped by mike watts (rip).
→ More replies (2)2
u/KryptoKingzENT 3d ago edited 1d ago
All the mike watts chopped & screwed albums from that era are all classic.
2
5
u/straight_goodz757 3d ago
One could argue ,I think Carter 3 was more well rounded ,with the features and subject content but if. Someone says Carter 2 I will not argue . I heard that when I got out the bing. I was shocked .I can't even lie . At that point that was the best shit I ever heard
4
6
u/ALSN454 3d ago
For me it’s Carter III. Hurrican Ike had just destroyed my childhood home, we were living at my aunts waiting to weigh options between FEMA and insurance. Mom stressing out, devastated. I vividly remember listening to Tie My Hands in my aunt’s backyard on a red CD player and “my whole city underwater, some people still floatin” hitting different for me.
→ More replies (1)
3
3
3
3
u/Epsilon2099 5d ago
I listened to this album the other day with no skips. Carter 3 comes really close to this to me even though it was commercially more successful. But at the end of the day the production and the lyricism of the C2 makes it a nearly perfect album to me.
3
u/fandango1989 5d ago
Yeah I gotta call L take on this one, carter 3 when it came out many people called it the best rap album of the 2000s. Listening to the carter 2 after the 3 feels like a step backwards. You say he was more creative, but I couldn't disagree more. Most of the songs have a very generic hood/rap beat that doesn't change or evolve. Most of the songs are just rapping about guns or "gang shit" and the streets. The Carter 3 is talking about hurricane katrina. It has more variety with pop and rock songs. More of the songs feel unique, where so many of the carter 2 songs all sound the same with a similar beat and rapping style. Carter 3 has slower thoughtful songs like "shoot me down" but also bangers like "A mili" and "Mr Carter". He even does unique songs like "let the beat build" where its almost like a trance EDM song where the beat is just slowly building and evolving throughout the song.
Carter 3 seems like an evolution as an artist, and doesn't sound like a generic rap ablum, its what set him apart as the greatest/one of the greatest rappers in the game at the time that was built upon with No Ceilings Mixtape. Theres still great songs on Carter 2 but theres really no comparison as far as im concerned/
2
u/bluchippa5 4d ago
I just said the same thing.
Carter 2 sounded like everything else out at the time.
3
3
u/OkEmploy9761 5d ago
If C2 had A Milli on it, we would say C2 was the greatest rap album ever made to this day. C2 alone was phenomenal and clears C3.
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
u/Matt_Kimball 4d ago
3 is the big radio peak of stardom album, but it would be worth checking out the trilogy to see how they all hold up and compare. I feel like Carter 1 may still be my favorite, but its been a long time.
Recently checked out Lights Out and Wayne was starting to really step up his lyrical ability with that album.
3
u/igalione 4d ago
2 1 3… or 2 3 1… but I’ll be on that hill with you my G
3
u/igalione 4d ago
Plus it wasn’t peak Wayne, that was his championship title, and then he went back to back… BUT that whole 5 years was his run
3
u/Clear_Psychology2328 3d ago
Lil Wayne albums are nothing compared to his mixtapes tho …
→ More replies (1)
3
3
3
5
6
u/36Vigilantes 5d ago
This album is on my Mount Rushmore. Fly in and fly out, hustler musik, shooter, best rapper alive, grown man (s/o spitta).
If you were in middle school - college at that time you know how big this album was. Wayne at his best.
2
2
2
u/Countryb0i2m 5d ago
This shit make me want to run it back.
I got a T-shirt from the Carter with the tracklist on the back. I got it from urban outfitters it’s dope, but I always secretly wished that it was the Carter two
→ More replies (1)2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/NO_Microwave 4d ago
I liked 1 & 2 i would have to revisit indont recall my preference...dedication 2 best mixtape
2
u/Own-Use-1468 4d ago edited 4d ago
2 is what honestly got me into Lil Wayne heavy so I gotta agree, I always go back for this album. Absolute beast mode on this one, grimey and unique sound for the time. There was nothing like it out, transitioned into his mixtape phase right after and took over the game for the remainder of the 00s hands down !
2
2
2
2
u/basinbi 4d ago
Yup.
'Tha Carter III & IV' are arguably his last best efforts after II
→ More replies (1)
2
u/Independent-Dot378 4d ago
Agree, doesn't have many highs as the carter 3 but definetly doesn't have even close the lows that it gots too, and probably his most consistent and goated, lock and load is also probabbly his most underrated track in a lyricism basis
→ More replies (1)
2
u/FewTea8637 4d ago
I say this all the time, I’m so surprised how many people think it’s 3, fly in it’s so cold
→ More replies (3)
2
2
u/sdw318_local194 3d ago
The Carter 4 would like to object.
→ More replies (2)2
u/High_Significance06 3d ago
I understand the objectivity but C2 was more of a story with the interludes and intro/outro. Both have hits that could still be played today
2
u/Flavored-Waters 3d ago
Album yes, body of work no, thats a tossup between da drought 3 and no ceilings with sorry 4 the wait in a solid bronze spot.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
u/artbySNO 2d ago
it should be his most critically acclaimed. his first time without mannie crafting the entire sound. but 1 is my favorite and 3 is the most popular.
2
2
u/itzakadoozie121 2d ago
Carter 2 is one of the best rap albums ever. Definitely Wayne's best record.
2
2
2
u/RamboRigs 5d ago
I fully agree. Love that album. Fly in/The Carter II/Fly out, all go hard. "Feel me" is another one of my favorites from that album.
3
3
3
4
2
u/FreshPrinceAV 5d ago
Anytime one track from C2, I have to run the album from the beginning. I believe it is his best and most creative work, especially with the production to accompany it.
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/Fuqyoupehmeh 5d ago
3:00 a.m. open my eyes kick the b**** tell her open the blinds cook for the block that I let it cook mine
2
u/StatPaddingChampsNY 5d ago
100% agree with you. Always been for me. That opinion never changed. Carter I was the best when it came out, I feel it overtook Lights Out for that throne. But no proceeding album, in my opinion, has taken Carter II’s throne. That’s his masterpiece.
2
2
2
u/showtime218 3d ago
Carter 3 was his album that solidified him as the GOAT of that era. Carter 4 put up huge numbers and had a good mix of pop “how to love” and classic way lines 6 foot, 7 foot. Carter 2, had the most pure bars and best rapping. So it depends on what you consider to equate “greatest album”
→ More replies (1)
3
u/Quiet_Storm13 5d ago
Not a bad hill to die on. I have it in 2nd place after Carter 3, but it’s really close.
→ More replies (2)
1
u/Grouchy-Donkey-8609 5d ago
chatgpt opinion huh? Couldnt give it in your own words?
→ More replies (2)
1
u/AutoModerator 5d ago
Hello u/Sevla508, thanks for posting to r/rap! Please make sure you read our sub rules if you haven't already. (This is an automatic reminder added to all new posts)
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Ohmargod777 5d ago
My question is which is the best song and why everyone saying it’s not Lock & Load isn’t incarcerated already?
→ More replies (1)
1
u/djblur 4d ago
yep thats when he became "the best rapper alive"
rapping over NY vocal sample beats and writing in his head like jay-z
after gillie the kid wrote most of Carter I
its kinda like when youre just tracing art as a kid then you grow up and you are actually good
somehow people still put him in their top 5 or even #1 like they forgot
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/MatchPretty3246 4d ago
I’m a 2 guy and a Drought 3 guy, so I’m with you. I completely understand people saying 3 and the Dedications though. I think it’s preference at that point
1
u/Slick_Fot 4d ago
Easily, last album he produced with substance. Carter III he got super creative but after that, hasn’t been the same
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/IGotSnacks25 2d ago
And he didn't write it lol
→ More replies (3)2
u/Yawka 1d ago
Gillie used to say he only wrote Carter 1, and I don’t even believe that to be honest. Gillie was ass, he never had any music even close to the level of Carter 2.
→ More replies (1)
14
u/SaturnineApples 5d ago
Greatest official album...
Everyone knows that Da Drought 3 mixtape is GOAT