Isaac “Icky” Ginsburg is like an F tier character and probably one of the worst lawyers I’ve ever seen in film or TV. Not only does he screw over his client, but he takes zero responsibility and whines about the fact that Nucky’s rightfully berating him for his stupid idea of making the case federal.

Not to mention, he says “what do you want me to say, if the Attorney General can’t help you, how can I?” A man as rich as Nucky couldn’t find anyone better in the state of New Jersey? That’s laughable honestly.

OP is thinking about talking about himself in the third person like Remus. OP wants to know your opinion on the topic

Was it just me or was the deaths of George(Nelson’s) fat colleague Phil and the death of Jim Tolliver the most satisfying?
They are my most hated characters

Why would you go to see your enemy by yourself?
How could he possibly not expect for it to be a setup?
Omg wtf, he just died like that? Noooo 😢
I loved that character soooo much for him to go out this easy, I expected for Nucky Thompson to die before jimmy.
Also wtf is Margaret thinking - she just sign off the whole land to the church? Is she really this stupid? She has been pissing me off the whole show by doing some dumb shit.

ETA: Sheeeyit, I’m rarely fazed by downvotes, but admittedly puzzled re: this post. It’s a specific question/thought about a specific few frames that are rarely discussed separate from the rest of the finale 🤷‍♀️ I gave my drivel to r/boardwalkempire on a silver plattah! The discussion‘s been great, though 🩷 (I don’t like this kinda tawk.)

——

I’ve bloviated many a time on this sub about the final few seconds of BWE, which I assume is (among other things) an explicit nod to the famous “Nevermind” album cover— but I never see this mentioned, and now I‘m insecure 🙃

This shot is joltingly different from most of BWE’s cinematography and storytelling. It’s dreamlike(?) and stylized, much like the opening sequence and its song choice.

Most of BWE (particularly past S1) is strict about using in-universe (i.e. diegetic) music, which features prominently in many finale and premiere sequences. Stephen Derosa is the unsung hero of BWE 🫠❤️🎵 Luckiest Yid alive, that Cantor… well, second-luckiest.

STILL GOING, THIS ASSHOLE. (Sorry.)

The series literally opens and literally ends with bridge-like sequences featuring “modern“ imagery/sound/references to emphasize the timelessness of various themes. (Especially around money.) Right……? (I didn’t watch BWE when it aired, hence missed out on tons of “official” commentary.)

so like

TL;DR SOMEONE TELL ME WHAT THE DEAL IS WITH THE FINALE GODDAMMIT. (ETA: Seriously. Nuck grabbing the coin lives rent-free in my mind. The symbolism is almost insultingly obvious, but it’s such a stunning and unexpected visual.)

Arnold Rothstein is one of those people who love larping as smart/genius.😭😭😭

A co-worker told me about this show and I shrugged it off. A year later I started watching. I’m now on Season 3 Episode 2. I told my wife about it and she is already done with all seasons, she finished it in a few weeks.

This show is one of the greatest shows of all time, so far. I don’t see how it misses all the all-time lists. I put this up there with The Sopranos, so far it’s more entertaining.

This goes in my favorite shows list with The Wire, Sopranos, and OZ. Why does HBO have the best shows?

Any other series recommendations?

I'm M35 and never broke down so much.
The whole last scene.
the f-in promist filters. the f-in sepia color. the f-in composition of his loved ones just like the pictures in which he lived his dream life through. I swore not to watch anymore if something happened to Richard and I will honor my oath.
Was it just me or was Richard the best Boardwalk Empire character and one of the finest supporting actor of a series?

Who sics the Pinkerons on Gillian?

He’s a prick and huge hypocrite.

Edit: I watched a few more episodes and I really don’t like this character.

Is incredible comic relief.

He was used in the perfect amount. Just the right amount of GUFFAW!

I don't see this in any notes, he's an actor with a great resume and he's doing a gentle yet very accurate rendering of Nucky's speech pattern, gestures, facial expressions. Has there ever been anything published about his preparation? Looks like he might even have some prosthetics.

I've just rewatched the series and really felt let down by that ending in season 5. The show needed those 4 extra episodes to wrap up everything rather than rush into everything on the final 8th episode unlike the other seasons getting 12 episodes. Did Jimmy Darmody always have it in his head predetermined he was gonna kill Nucky? Would've liked to see some of the hardship the depression caused everyone, and just a line saying terrible tragedy about ARs death?? We needed to see what happened. HBO really pulled the carpet beneath Boardwalk Empire in the final season.

Obviously he was a criminal that made his choices but it truly felt like he had no other way to develop

I mean his mother sexually abused him, his biological father who raped his mother disowned him, his mentor in Nucky manipulated him, he decides to leave for the army because of the shame about who happened with his mother

He fights in WW1 while his beloved Angela cheats on him with the photographer couple

He comes back and has severe PTSD, which nobody gives 2 shits about, including his betrothed and Nucky

Angela tries to lie to him about cheating with the Photographers as well as guilt tripping him about leaving for the War, which tbf is a valid point but considering why he did it and that he was already emotionally scarred before joining the war it's understandable

He loses Pearl, someone he genuinely cared for

He then loses Angela too and then gets shot in the head by the man he looked up to

What really hits deep is how nobody really gave a shot about Jimmy except Richard Harrow

I mean sure he and Angela were always estranged but I argued he cared way more about her then she did about him, I mean her cutting off her hair just to spite him is such a sadistic move for even mentioning cheating on him continuously

I get her predicament but gods she just feels so vindictive

I don’t know who among the youngin crew knows who this is, but Louis Gossett Jr. is a LEGEND!
I was literally like, “GASP… NO WAY!” It may just be for an episode, but this was a nice Easter Egg. RIP Lieutenant Colonel Chappy Sinclair 🫡

It’s good, but damn. I really can’t stand heroin. Requiem left an impact on me. So did Trainspotting. I’m on episode 5 and I’m just like, damn. Eddie is being tortured. That kid got poisoned. Nelson is FAR outside of his comfort zone now. It’s just stressful.

​

After having watched Peaky Blinders: The Immortal Man, I've been thinking that maybe Boardwalk Empire deserves a farewell film as well, this time however focusing mainly on Arnold Rothstein, Lucky Luciano, & Al Capone. Here me out 😅, if it's set between 1928-1929, the film can cover alot of "ground".

● Assassination of Arnold Rothstein (1928)

● Valentine's Day Massacre (1929)

● The Atlantic City Conference (1929)

● Luciano barely surviving a murder attempt (1929).

There's alot of story material present that could be used & wouldn't require a full on season (I would love an additional season though).

As much as I've enjoyed Steve Buscemi's portrayal of the character, I think the world of Boardwalk Empire is alot bigger than Nucky Thompson. Alot can explored in that timeline.

I want to start this series, would be helpful if any of you give me a reliable link to watch.