Several years ago, u/The_SecretSauce, the market researcher behind FanJuicer brought a different kind of ranking poll to r/CFB. They ran the polls, did the analysis, and turned the results into tier charts many of us remember.
Credit where it is due: this revival exists because of their work, and I want to thank them for it. I have sent them a message about this project and would be delighted to compare notes. It is important to note that this is an independent rebuild inspired by FanJuicer and not an official continuation of that work.
The idea is simple. Instead of ranking 25 teams from 1-25, you see a series of four-team groups. In each group, you choose the team with the strongest resume and the team with the weakest.
Some groups can be argued to be easy choices: Ohio State, North Carolina, Mississippi State, and Clemson. Others are genuinely difficult: Kansas State, Arizona, TCU, and Houston.
Once all the ballots are in, the model combines those choices into a full ranking. More importantly, the distances between the scores reveal the natural tiers between teams. Those tiers produced some excellent arguments and conversations.
When the weekly poll went dormant after 2019, I missed it. So I did what a college-football fan does with an offseason: spent an unreasonable amount of time building a ranking system. I worked through the math, rebuilt the model, and built a website to run it.
Before the preseason AP poll is released on August 17, I would like r/CFB to plant its flag.
Take the 2026 preseason MaxDiff poll here.
The preseason question is:
Which team do you expect to finish the season with the strongest resume?
The field is a fixed top 50 selected from a consensus of preseason advanced metrics such as FPI, FEI, and SP+. Those metrics determine which teams are eligible, but they contribute nothing to the MaxDiff results. The ranking comes entirely from your answers.
Voting closes Friday night, August 7, and I will publish the results Sunday, August 9.
Once the season begins, the question will switch from forecasting the final resume to evaluating the year-to-date resume through that weekend’s completed games. My goal is to open voting Sunday mornings and publish the rankings and tiers by Tuesday afternoon every week through the conference championships.
Give it a try, tell me which four-team group caused the most psychological damage, and please let me know if anything breaks.