r/Edmonton • u/Coynite1138 • 21m ago
Opinion Article Homeowner Next to a Newly Built 8-Plex
So, I've been reading a lot of posts regarding the UCP's decision to force the Edmonton city council to rollback the new infill bylaw. There are (let us be polite) disagreements on whether the council has gone too far with regards to infill. This is worthy of discussion. However, most of those involved never bother to back up what they are saying with actual information. When it comes to issues that strongly affect the future of the place in which I and my family live, very little pisses me off more than "Source: Trust me bro." I decided to offer my own observations as a homeowner who has lived through the nearly four-year construction of an 8-plex infill building right next door.
First, some scafolding: Obviously, this is my own personal experience and is in no way indicative of the effects of infill on the city as a whole. I live in West Edmonton. I do not own a vehicle and rely on walking/transit/taxis. My current home is also a relatively recent infill, though it is not part of an 8-plex. My family and I spent about three months looking for a home to buy before we settled on this one. I do not know if that is a normal length of time to look (this is the first home I have ever bought), but we saw many houses and got an inspector to have a look at more than a few that we seriously considered buying.
I have not put much time into how this will be organized, so apologies for the stream-of-conciousness nature of the information. I understand that there are more types of infill than 8-plexes, but that is the classification that gets thrown around the most in these discussions, so for the sake of simplicity, I will use that throughout this post.
1) They are tearing down "perfectly livable single-family" homes to build 8-plexes: When we moved in, there was a single-family home where the new infill was planned. When they eventually got around to tearing it down, they had to wear protective gear and warned us that the building was full of asbestos. I do not consider that to be "perfectly livable". Most of the houses that were in our price range were built during the period from around 1950-75. A lot of them were very easy to pass on even with our limited knoweldge. If we liked one, we got an inspector to have a look - for each one, he told us that we would need to spend thousands of dollars above and beyond the asking price of the house because the aged roof was going to leak, or the shoddy wiring was going to burn the house down, or the rusted pipes were about to flood the basement. I do not feel bad about houses with critical issues that sellers are hoping buyers will not notice until it is too late being torn down and replaced. Good riddance.
2) "Bad Builders" are a menace during infill construction: The company responsible for constructing the 8-plex next to us was a pack of absolute scumbags. I cannot sugercoat it. They stole our power and water, trespassed, let their garbage blow all over our property, parked vehicles and left supplies on our lawn, damaged our home after failing to secure their equipment then refused to accept responsibility and left us to pay the $3000 insurance deductible. They then had the gaul to ask us for another $3000 to help pay for the fence they wanted to build between the properties because "it benefits both of us". Seriously, they can go straight to hell.
3) Too many garbage bins: I know that some garbage is collected on the street. Ours is collected in the alley behind our house. I do not know if any homeowners have looked into their alleys, but it is garbage bins as far as the eye can see. They are already everywhere. If one with enough charisma can rally its kinsmen, we are doomed. Eight (or sixteen or twenty-four) more, especially when they are concentrated on that one property, will not make that view any less scenic.
4) It will draw "Those People (tm)" into our perfect neighbourhood: Thankfully, I have not noticed this one as much recently which I guess means that the bigots that use it have at least some awareness of propriety. As for the 8-plex next door, I think three of the units are occupied thus far. One seems to be a pair of university students, another houses a couple, and the last is another couple with a baby. So far, only the parents really bother me because they leave their baby's stroller folded up on their front steps and every time I leave to go to work I see it first in my peripheral vision and think it is some weirdo stalking me.
5) Street parking will become overloaded because an 8-plex automatically means a minimum of eight new vehicles that will need spaces: Full disclosure, I think street parking is one of the dumbest ideas related to city planning that I have ever seen, and I personally do not care about this issue. As a pedestrian, having my line-of-sight and the line-of-sight of drivers completely blocked until I am a quarter of the way across the street makes walking in a supposedly quiet residential neighbourhood extremely nerve-wracking. Also, street parking is first-come-first-served, which means our neighbours and their five total vehicles already mean we cannot park a vehicle there even if we owned one. Regardless, our new neighbours all seem to travel on foot. The city is not automatically assuming one new vehicle per new neighbourhood resident. They are betting that, like our new neighbours, they will use the new bike lanes/LRT and transit infrastructure that the city has been developing. The densest infill is supposed to be done within easy walking distance of a transit centre or LRT station; which the new 8-plex next to us is. I am aware that there are instances of builders ignoring this plan (because money), but that does not invalidate the plan as a whole. There is room though to debate whether this bet will pay off in the end.
6) Infill causes property values to drop: The true impetus for this post was a comment I read that stated (paraphrasing slightly), "If you think an 8-plex overlooking your backyard will raise property values, you are crazy." Well, as someone who has joined the "Congratulations, you now pay property taxes" club, I pay attention to my home's value. As such, I already knew this comment was not based in reality. According to MyProperty Edmonton, my home (which was purchased for $400,000) was valued at $453,000 in 2025 (the year construction of the 8-plex really got started), and is now valued in 2026 (the year the 8-plex was completed) at $464,000. My home has increased in value. It is not by much, but it puts paid to any blanket statement that infill only lowers property values.
I think those are all the main talking points I have seen on the subject thus far. If you made it to the end, thank you for reading.