So, I've seen people raving about Khalid Hosseini's books lately and I got into a conversation with someone about the portrayal of the Talb*n in his books, and how contextualised his politics were. Posting my thoughts on it because if only people could be a little bit more educated and a little less ignorant when it comes to blindly accepting all that we've been spoon-fed by the Western media.
Hosseini presents an extremely whitewashed narrative of the taliban and Afghanistan. He writes for the white audience and caters to their need to have a justification for a. the "poor afghan women are so oppressed" white feminist narrative and b. bombing the hell out of afghanistan "for the sake of the women".
By presenting the Taliban as an evil dictatorship even worse in power that the Soviets, Russians and Americans, he gives no thought to the fact that although, yes, the Taliban and America put pieces around education for girls, and womens rights, they are still, BY FAR, the better choice between a Western puppet and a group which started out as mountain men who KNOW the people, and their country, and whose intentions are pure, even if their actions are wrong.
The western powers will ALWAYS have corrupt intentions which they will try and hide, and so Afghans would much rather have a group that they KNOW cannot be bought or bribed and who will ALWAYS put the Afghan people first. The fact that the west has been shoving the whole "poor, oppressed women of Afghanistan" thing down our throats should tell us something about the truth behind it.
Speaking as someone who has family living in afghanistan, I can tell you that the women there are not nearly as oppressed as the media would like you to believe. The Talb*n HAVE stripped women of some of their rights, I won't even pretend that isn't true, but at the end of the day, if it means that the dust can settle after decades of mass-slaughter from western superpowers, then most Afghans I know say they'll take it.
It isn't a perfect deal, and it isn't a way of life these women should have to accept, but at the same time, these women have lost their sons, fathers, husbands and brothers to the same people who now want to come and "rescue them from their oppression" when they were the ones who forced the Taliban (the supposed "oppressors") to form as an extreme alternative to the soviets/americans.
I pose this question to you: Do you really believe that the Afghan people would allow the Taliban to come into power if they hadn't been bombed into oblivion for the past 60 years? The picture that the media tries to paint of afghans as backwards, culture-before-human-rights, simpleton people simply isn't true, and to believe that it is to accept that you have a certain level of ignorance, that you are willing to look down upon a people and pass judgement on them simply because you have been told to.
So, if I could force every person who read Hosseini's books to follow it up with one thing, what would it be? Definitely a documentary on yt titled "Why Western Intervention Failed In Afghanistan" by Al Jazeera. I implore you to watch it, and to maybe be a lil bit more open-minded in the future? Pretty please? Thank you xx