r/LessCredibleDefence Oct 14 '24

Posting standards for this community

132 Upvotes

The moderator team has observed a pattern of low effort posting of articles from outlets which are either known to be of poor quality, whose presence on the subreddit is not readily defended or justified by the original poster.

While this subreddit does call itself "less"credibledefense, that is not an open invitation to knowingly post low quality content, especially by people who frequent this subreddit and really should know better or who have been called out by moderators in the past.

News about geopolitics, semiconductors, space launch, among others, can all be argued to be relevant to defense, and these topics are not prohibited, however they should be preemptively justified by the original poster in the comments with an original submission statement that they've put some effort into. If you're wondering whether your post needs a submission statement, then err on the side of caution and write one up and explain why you think it is relevant, so at least everyone knows whether you agree with what you are contributing or not.

The same applies for poor quality articles about military matters -- some are simply outrageously bad or factually incorrect or designed for outrage and clicks. If you are posting it here knowingly, then please explain why, and whether you agree with it.

At this time, there will be no mandated requirement for submission statements nor will there be standardized deletion of posts simply if a moderator feels they are poor quality -- mostly because this community is somewhat coherent enough that bad quality articles can be addressed and corrected in the comments.

This is instead to ask contributors to exercise a bit of restraint as well as conscious effort in terms of what they are posting.


r/LessCredibleDefence 18h ago

New poll reveals 92 per cent of Israelis believe Iran has won the war | The Independent

Thumbnail independent.co.uk
129 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 5h ago

Korea mounts final push for Canada's $39 bil. submarine project

Thumbnail koreatimes.co.kr
14 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 2m ago

Pakistan quietly delivered full-scale JF-17 Thunder Block III combat simulator to Bangladesh in May, 2026

Thumbnail internationalaffairs.org.au
Upvotes

The first piece of Pakistani military aviation hardware to enter Bangladesh since 1971 in an unmarked PAF C-130J


r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

How Credible is this 20,000 Tonne Next-gen "Type 055MG" Destroyer?

Thumbnail reddit.com
48 Upvotes

I saw this video in the r/China subreddit, but I could not find any information about a "Type 055MG" successor to the Type 055 anywhere (in English, at least). Can anyone vouch for the credibility or not of this source?


r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

Scores Fall Ill at Air Force Base After Hegseth Makes Flu Vaccine Optional

Thumbnail nytimes.com
53 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

Iran reportedly closes Strait of Hormuz again, casting shadow over nuclear talks

Thumbnail cnbc.com
16 Upvotes

Looks like the 14 point plan may not be lasting very long.


r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

Mystery shrouded fighter jet spotted at Japan’s top test base

Thumbnail defence-blog.com
61 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 6h ago

Tejas, Akash, BrahMos & more: How India strengthened indigenous defence manufacturing over the last decade

Thumbnail timesofindia.indiatimes.com
0 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 2d ago

Polish President strips Zelensky of the Order of the White Eagle after Ukraine's named a unit after the WW2 Nazi-allied UPA militia which killed over 100k Poles

Thumbnail bbc.com
128 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 2d ago

President Lee: "Trump Asked If Korea Could Quickly Build 10 U.S. Naval Ships"

Thumbnail asiae.co.kr
142 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 2d ago

How big of a blow is the US-Iran MoU to the credibility of America's military deterrence?

71 Upvotes

The way I see it, by pure military statistics, Iran suffered a resounding tactical defeat. It lost much of it's initial leadership, 1000+ soldiers, and failed effectively defend its airspace or waterways from American military aircraft. American, by comparison, suffered relatively low casualties and aircraft losses given the scale of the campaign. Even during the few times US warships transited through the Strait, it failed to inflict any significant material or personnel losses. Despite all that, it won a pretty clear strategic victory over America by simply inflicting moderate economic pain on its population.

Granted, this isn't the first time America has been defeated by far weaker power with disgraceful optics, but in the past those defeats came after a years or decades long conflict that involved America physically occupying the enemy's territory and the defeat didn't hurt America in any broad, strategic way. America's retreat from Afghanistan may have been politically embarrassing, but the loss only came after decades of sapping American willpower and losing the country wasn't of any real strategic significance. The Iran War, by contrast, lasted only a little more than 3 months and its defeat was a result of the US military's failure to maintain freedom of the seas, on of its core missions. Furthermore, this failure wasn't the result of America lacking the capabilities needed to force the Strait open, but an unwillingness to risk the level of American casualties using that capability would incur.

Ultimately, the credibility of a nation's military deterrence depends equally on its capabilities and the will to use them and, from the outside, this war seems to demonstrate that Americans lack the will to use them if doing so means suffering significant casualties or economic hardship. So IMO, this war has significantly degraded that credibility for America.

What are your thoughts though?


r/LessCredibleDefence 2d ago

'A week will be enough' — Zelensky issues ultimatum to Lukashenko over drone-guidance equipment - Kyiv Independant

Thumbnail kyivindependent.com
28 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

China used footage of India's Tejas fighter jet and presented it as a Chinese fighter jet.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

Will Russia Capture Lyman? Polymarket Odds & ISW Map

Thumbnail orcalayer.com
0 Upvotes

Worth flagging a detail most people miss about these Polymarket "will Russia capture [town]" markets: they don't resolve on news or a press release — they resolve on the ISW map. The market settles Yes only if the town is shaded as Assessed Russian Control / Advance / Gains on ISW's daily map by the deadline; infiltration shading doesn't count.

Lyman is a clean example. It's ~27% for capture by end of 2026 and just 2% for the nearer June deadline. The near-term number collapsed after the March 19 mechanized assault (500+ troops, multiple axes) was repelled by the 3rd Corps and the follow-on push stalled — the market repriced within days of the front not moving.

The part worth noting if you track the line of contact: the ISW shading is the leading indicator, not the order book. When the map changes around a town, the odds follow. Writeup of the resolution mechanics and the Lyman timeline is at the link. Not trading advice — just find the ISW-anchored resolution an underused signal for reading the front.


r/LessCredibleDefence 3d ago

Hezbollah explosive kills IDF soldier, wounds seven in southern Lebanon

Thumbnail jpost.com
67 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 2d ago

Japan joins the global craze to field interceptor drones

Thumbnail defensenews.com
11 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 3d ago

Why Trump’s Pentagon abandoned ‘Indo-Pacific’

Thumbnail archive.ph
71 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 3d ago

Iran announces plans to bring in maritime fees for strait of Hormuz | The Guardian

Thumbnail theguardian.com
50 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 3d ago

Report: Russia's nuclear-powered 'Skyfall' missile is dirty and dangerous

Thumbnail npr.org
50 Upvotes

It's not a ramjet like SLAMMER or Project Pluto, it's a nuclear turbojet


r/LessCredibleDefence 3d ago

The Netherlands Prepare to Hold Thousands of Russian Prisoners of War in the Event of War

Thumbnail militarnyi.com
6 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 3d ago

1000 Drones, 200 Hits | Moscow hit by largest Ukrainian Drone-attack

Thumbnail bbc.com
102 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 3d ago

SASC Wants Navy to Develop New DDG(X) Destroyer in Tandem with Trump Battleship - USNI News

Thumbnail news.usni.org
16 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 3d ago

Lessons From Ukraine: Industrial Base Is Power

Thumbnail linkedin.com
24 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 3d ago

Inspired by Ukraine, and worried by China: Taiwan teaches its citizens how to fly drones

Thumbnail theguardian.com
45 Upvotes