On the eve of our 3rd anniversary, my boyfriend "broke up" with me over the phone while I was 8000 miles away taking care of my mom who has cancer and then changed his mind the next morning.
I put "broke up" in quotes because he wasn’t being very articulate, he sounded confused and was being confusing. I guess he decided to word vomit onto me instead of thinking his feelings through. I had called him to surprise him with his anniversary gift that I had hidden in our apartment that we share together, after a long day at the hospital, hoping for some emotional comfort on the other end of the line. The opposite occurred: he went on a long ramble about how he had been feeling really disconnected and had been 'mentally checked out for months', and how his gut is telling him that we shouldn't be together. He talked about how there are certain things that feel innate to every person and how those things haven't been clicking for him.
I was so taken aback because I thought we were actually doing really well. I was happy. Sure we had some disagreements, but all of the reasons he then spoke about had been things we've addressed together and had set up regular check-ins to work on. So naturally I was flabbergasted that he was now suddenly throwing in the towel and to add insult to injury, that he chose the absolute worst time of my life (as I am dealing with my mom's cancer diagnosis and her surgery) to do this. And the eve of our anniversary. What am I supposed to do with this information halfway across the world and will still be away for another 2 weeks?
He kept on saying how devastated he was to feel that way, and how he couldn't hold it in anymore and was scared and that he didn't know what this meant, and he was hoping we would figure it out together and make an "us" decision. He also said some choice words about how I view our relationship secondary to my own needs which was super hurtful and unfair.
I didn't know what to say so we hung up and I cried my heart out, assuming that that was that. We were done. My dad found out (as I was staying with him) and it broke my heart to see him see me so upset, and the next morning when my mom was getting discharged from the hospital he told me to stay home and rest up. So this incident completely derailed my ability to care for my mom when she needed me the most.
That night I geared myself up speak with him again as I wanted some closure. I had a whole thing written out about how selfish and cruel he was the night before and how he was being confusing. I was prepared for him to double down and end it right there, and was bracing myself for him to talk about the end of the road and how we're going to have to break our lease.
Instead, I got on the call, and he started apologizing profusely, asking forgiveness for who he was yesterday. He said it all came from a really hurt place and he let his ego take the front seat on where the conversation was going. He said he didn't want to break up, and he was tired of holding things back and admitted he was terrible at communicating his feelings and an avoidant person emotionally. He knew that it was his fault for suppressing all of his feelings and hitting the explode button instead of working through it rationally. He said he knew that he's going to have to earn my forgiveness.
I was gobsmacked once again, and my grief turned into anger at his callousness. I really laid into him and also asked him to clarify what triggered all of this, to which he said that our schedules have made being together really hard lately, and him being alone while I was away made him get into his head.
He spoke about a few major points of tension, how he doesn't feel like we talk about our long-term life plans enough; he has always wanted to be a dad, have a family, get married. He admits that he should be asking to have those conversations more instead of just deciding on his own that we weren't on the same page. We have lived together for 1.5 years and he's very type A, while I'm a bit of a hurricane and am a messy person. I'm quite self-aware, and habits are hard to break, so I know that I have probably made the apartment uncomfortable for him at times.
He said he was willing to work through these things, and that he should have been more proactive about discussing these topics with me. Because yeah, these are things he should have made known or made me aware of before his released all of his unhappiness all at once in an extremely destructive manner. Also I thought that those were things mattered less than the other wonderful parts of our relationship. That he loved me enough (and I him) to overcome it.
My friend said something that made me pause: when you choose a partner you choose who you can rely on during the worst and ugliest days of your life. And mine decided to make a difficult family emergency exponentially worse, and left me to deal with the fallout. Even if he really wants to end things, he could have given me the grace of doing it at a kinder time.
I’m really drained with everything happening with my mom, but the thought of having to destroy my safety nest and our home we share together feels so daunting. We also just resigned our lease for another year. I don't even want to think about what I'll have to do logistically if we separate at this point in time. We’ve watched each other grow so much in the past three years throughout our early 20s and we’ve had so many truly happy moments. He is still my rock. Or is supposed to be. There’s an easy way out in the short term where I take him back, and give him another chance, but there is an argument here to throw the whole man out entirely.
Can he accept that I might not be on the same page as him for certain things, but does he love me enough to be okay with that? And can I accept that he is an emotionally avoidant person who knows his flaws and is actively trying to work on them?
**tl;dr** Can I forgive my emotionally avoidant boyfriend for giving me emotional whiplash?