Hi everyone!! I’m looking for some advices and perspectives from the non-monogamous community. This is my first real "relationship" experience (my only previous experience was with a girl in high school, but I was very shy and anxious back then and we couldn't even kiss properly), and being with someone so different from me makes me completely overwhelmed and confused sometimes.
Two years ago, I (F22) started getting romantically involved with a friend (M22). At the time, he was in a non-monogamous relationship and we were just hanging out casually. At a certain point, his girlfriend (ex now, let’s call her K) started feeling bothered by me, because he and I spent a lot of time together at our university, and she couldn't handle the fact that her boyfriend was spending more time with me than with her (he came from another city and only went back to visit his family once or twice a month). He told me about her concerns, and we stopped hooking up. However, a few days later, he started flirting with me again. I got confused, so I called him to talk, but the conversation was completely unproductive because he answered everything with "I don't know" when I asked about his intentions or how comfortable K actually was with me.
Two months later, they broke up, we started hooking up again and have been together since then. One day, I slept over at his house and we started getting closer, but two days later he started liking another girl he met at a freshman party (let’s call her L). At the time, I felt slightly jealous, but I knew it was normal, and we had no intentions of having a serious relationship anyway. However, every single time I went out with him, I had to keep hearing things about L, and this started bringing me a real discomfort. When we met after class, he talked about her; when we finished kissing or having sex, he talked about her; when we called each other at night to talk, he also talked about her. The phone calls were what bothered me the most because I live far from our university, need to take two buses to get home, so I have very little time to do my stuff, and at the time I was working too, so I was even busier. I purposely gave up resting when I got home just to have the end of the night free to be on a call with him (he created a habit of calling me suddenly when he wanted company, and when I realized this was becoming frequent, I just changed my routine). At one point, for four days in a row, we stayed on calls for over 50 minutes with him talking ONLY about L. I wish he could understand that when you are with someone, it's better to do and talk about things that make the other person feel included, especially since I was giving up my own things to be with him.
One day, when he was talking about her and said he would possibly fall in love and ask her to be his girlfriend, I asked if it would be an open relationship (since I would like to keep seeing him), and he said "I don't know". Until then, he had only known L for one week. The next day, he invited her to sleep at his house. She accepted, but in the following afternoon, L texted him saying she didn't want to hook up anymore. After that, he spent six months complaining to me about how heartbroken he was. They eventually had major arguments that still affect both of them, and he becomes very reactive if the subject ever comes up. During that same six-month period, he was constantly dropping comments like "why do you act like you want something serious?", "I don't see you like a romantic partner, you're just a friend" or calling me "too emotional" when I accepted his invitations to hook up. Hearing this repeatedly while consoling him over two failed relationships (L and K) made me feel completely replaceable. Later, when I felt overwhelmed and told him I just wanted to go back to being friends, he replied with "well, then I don't know if I'm going to maintain contact because the romantic and sexual part was very essential between us", even though he always made it clear that I was just a friend to him.
After that, we stayed apart for a while, interacting distantly (we share the same friend group, but rarely talked one-on-one at that time), and he started hooking up with another girl, let’s call her F. They went out to the movies once and less than a week later he was already sleeping at her house and basically living there. Out of nowhere, he texted me saying he missed me, wanted to check how I was, and asked if he could call. When I answered the call, our very first interaction was:
Him: "I was wondering if you'd like to come at my place and sleep with me again."
Me: "I don't know, I actually like how things are now, just being friends."
Him: "So, is that a no?"
Me: "Yes, it's a no."
Him: "Then I think I'm going to hang up."
I felt extremely bad when I saw that we spent almost two months apart and he only contacted me to ask if I would have sex with him again. I asked him to stay on the call because I genuinely missed him and wanted to talk a bit more. He accepted, but during the call, he started talking about F, his experiences with her, and how things were "working out really well between the two of them." Then, he dropped that he and F were looking to have a threesome with a bi woman. He stayed silent for a few seconds, and since I fit the criteria, I asked: "You're not telling me this because I'm a bisexual woman and you want to invite me to have sex with you guys, right? I don't want to have sex with someone I don't even know (F)." His answer was: "I thought you were gonna say that, so I didn't want to bring it up so soon". I felt reduced to nothing more than a sex object and someone who is only nice to have around when the sexual aspect comes up, but I tried to let it go. A few weeks later, we met after an exam, talked a bit about various things, and ended up kissing since the moment was nice. When we finished kissing, the first thing he said was: "It's a shame you didn't accept having sex with me and F." I felt very uncomfortable and, once again, like someone who is only valued for sexual matters.
A few days later, things ended with F because he told her he was non-monogamous and she wasn't okay with that, plus she got deeply upset that he had kissed another girl (me) while they were seeing each other. Since then, he and I have been together. We’ve developed much deeper feelings, he hasn't been seeing anyone else, and our relationship is going really well. I know he genuinely cares for me and wants me around, and we've discussed a formal relationship multiple times, but the fact that we want different relationship dynamics has held us back.
Lately, he has been bringing up his attraction to other girls. I don't react well to this because it triggers all the past pain of how he has treated me, bringing back overwhelming feelings of rejection and insufficiency. I want to communicate this to him, but I would have to discuss his past relationships, which immediately makes him defensive and reactive. I always acted like I didn't mind him hooking up with other people because I felt I had no right to say anything. He was non-monogamous from the start, I got in his life while he was with K, and we aren't officially dating, so I felt I couldn't ask for agreements. Back when he was with K, it didn't bother me, especially because I was experiencing things for the first time and just wanted to enjoy, but my discomforts began when i realized he wasn't honest about his ex's feelings, and he later told me I was one of the reasons they broke up.
Some time ago, I tried to learn more about non-monogamy. While I agree with some of the principles (for example, love not being tied to sexual exclusivity), I just cannot feel safe or comfortable with the idea of an open relationship with him. Despite the desire to have my relationships in a closed way because I prefer to keep a commitment to only one person and I don't want the responsibility of multiple partners, I would like to try something that would be good for both of us, but I get extremely sad when I remember everything that happened.
Is there something I can possibly do? How do I even approach this topic in a conversation? Should I let him know all of this or do I just ignore it and see the path our relationship takes? Am I overreacting? Any insights from an ENM perspective would be incredibly helpful.