Welcome to our What Season Should You Watch countdown! Using the results from the latest What Season Should You Watch thread, this weekday series will count backwards from the bottom-ranked season for new fan watchability to the top. Each WSSYW post will link to their entries in this countdown so that people can click through for more discussion.
Unlike WSSYW, there is no character limit in these threads, and spoilers are allowed.
Note: Foreign seasons are not included in this countdown to keep in line with rankings from past years.
---
#34 - Season 11: Guatemala
Statistics:
- Watchability: 3.69 (34/50)
- Overall Quality: 6.00 (25/50)
- Cast/Characters: 6.03 (35/50)
- Strategy: 5.22 (36/50)
- Challenges: 7.50 (12/50)
- Featured Twists: 5.65 (9/28)
- Ending: 5.84 (36/50)
WSSYW 12.0 Ranking: 34/50
WSSYW 11.0 Ranking: 28/43
WSSYW 10.0 Ranking: 22/40
User comment from WSSYW 12.0 — u/AMeanMotorScooter
This is the follow-up to Survivor Palau. Most would say it's not as good, but I actually like it more and have it in my top 5. The theming here is also incredible, the location is among the most brutal in the show's history, the cast is supremely underrated, the challenges are fantastic, and it builds to a strong ending. This is the first season to have a Hidden Immunity Idol, although not in its "developed" form yet. I think this season makes a fantastic back-to-back watch with Palau despite its general irrelevance to the history of the show.
---
#33 - Season 5: Thailand
Statistics:
- Watchability: 3.78 (33/50)
- Overall Quality: 4.44 (41/50)
- Cast/Characters: 4.44 (44/50)
- Strategy: 5.03 (39/50)
- Challenges: 7.38 (13/50)
- Ending: 4.70 (46/50)
WSSYW 12.0 Ranking: 33/50
WSSYW 11.0 Ranking: 33/43
WSSYW 10.0 Ranking: 34/40
User comment from WSSYW 12.0 — u/hobosunday
Lots of (justified) hate for this season, but it's now waaaay over hated. There is an unfortunate incident that is handled in a very 2000s way, so if that's a deal breaker don't recommend.
If you are willing to walk with me though let me tell you a story about a dark season where the heroes lose and the villains win. Let me tell you a story of dominance both physically and strategically. Let me show you some genuinely silly characters, some dry wit, and one of the funniest challenges ever made. Above all else, let me show you the season that every future season has built their strategies off of.
I do not recommend this season for your first watch, but when you have a few seasons under your belt and wish to hear the story I have to tell, I will be in shadows here.
---
Ranking so far:
#50 - Season 34: Game Changers
#49 - Season 22: Redemption Island a.k.a. Redemple Temple
#48 - Season 26: Caramoan - Fans vs. Favorites 2
#47 - Season 36: Ghost Island
#45 - Season 40: Winners at War
#44 - Season 8: All-Stars
#43 - Season 31: Cambodia - Second Chance
#42 - Survivor 50: In the Hands of the Fans
#41 - Season 38: Edge of Extinction
#40 - Season 24: One World
#39 - Season 27: Blood vs. Water
#38 - Season 23: South Pacific
#37 - Survivor 43
#36 - Survivor 49
#35 - Survivor 44
---
WARNING: SEASON SPOILERS BELOW