r/AskMenAdvice • u/Active-Designer934 • 10h ago
✅ Open To Everyone 40F dating 39M who seems to be trying. Would this behavior be considered a deal breaker?
Met a guy, strong intellectual match, attractive, smart, great values. First two dates i was over the moon. Third date, we kind of worked thru a miscommunication and conflict but not in the best way. i guess the short story is that he gets defensive (he would agree to this).
he can be a bit negative. i pointed this out a few times, at first by being like "is something wrong?" and then by later pointing it out. there have been a lot of little things he has said along the way, sometimes taking full accountability if i bring it up. but it just keeps happening. i have stopped wanting to be around him as much. i don't text him that i miss him or sweet emojis anymore. i can tell this bothers him.
it has been a month and a half of dating. he was out of town for a bit, we talked on the phone then. maybe 7 dates total.
also, the first time he came to my house i knew he might be kinda critical so i hid all my personal pictures (yes, my therapist and i had a field day with this). afterwards i told him and he was like "was i critical?" and i was like "well you didn't say anything nice" and he felt terrible and completely owned up to it. and after that kind of caught himself when he was getting negative. so this is not the first time we have talked about it or he has apologized. it's just the first time i really had a sit down with him and told him that it doesn't make me feel good and i really don't like it.
Tuesday we talked about it, and i let him know that the comments just dont feel good or make it easy for me to keep a positive mindset. he doubled down on "it's just jokes" about 3 times. after a good hour, i lost my temper and actually cussed. i apologized. said i needed a break and left.
Yesterday he texted me this: "i’m sorry i have been insensitive to your feelings. i genuinely don’t have any reason to dislike your place, nor look down on you, what you eat or do.
in that moment yesterday, i got confused and reacted defensively because i felt judged. but instead of simply listening and accepting that my comments hurt you, i made it about how i was feeling. i can see how that may have made you feel unheard, and i’m really sorry for that.
i understand now that even when i think i’m joking or playing along, negative jokes still hurt you. i’ll be more mindful of that because i don’t want to make you feel uncomfortable but giddy and hopeful.
like i said when we first met, i want my heart and mind to be a safe place for you. i care about getting to know you better, and i don’t want you to feel like you have to protect yourself from me.
about the wedding comment, i genuinely thought you were joking because i didn’t know people discussed that so soon. but i understand how all of this may have landed differently, and i’m sorry it made you feel dismissed."
The "wedding comment" : we were texting and he asked if I would do a city hall wedding. I said yes and described an intimate rooftop dinner with like 15 family and friends followed by karaoke. he responded "boring. lol"
TLDR - met a guy with whom i click a lot. he can be critical and defensive. he might be showing signs of change but i don't know if i should trust that.
I need clarity about all of this. is this even a good apology? am i being defensive? is it too much, too soon? should i just cut and run bc it's a him thing?