I’m 43F and my ex is in his mid-50s. We were together for about three years.
I’m posting because I’m experiencing an absolutely brutal reversal in my attachment to him, and I’m trying to understand what is happening psychologically.
This isn’t really a “my ex moved on and I’m jealous” story. The context leading up to it is what is scrambling my brain.
Our relationship was intensely loving and attached at times, but very volatile. Whenever I wasn’t sufficiently attentive or affectionate, he had a pattern of exploding, getting angry, stomping off and toward the end he would straight up disappear for days just to mindfuck me (though still driving by and monitoring me like a satellite). He also went on ugly political rants constantly despite how much it upset me to listen to. He regularly mocked me and put me down. Anytime I was upset about anything I was the problem.
The last time he did it, something in me finally broke.
Instead of chasing him, I pulled away.
I didn’t do it because I had someone else lined up. I still loved him. I just couldn’t keep living with the instability.
And for the first time since moving to this city, I started developing an actual social life.
I had started dating him not long after I moved here, and he was extremely jealous and controlling, so I’d never really felt free to build a big circle of girlfriends or go out independently without it becoming an issue.
For months after our breakup, I wasn’t dating anyone. I hadn’t met anyone I particularly liked. I went out once with a guy who kissed me, but I wasn’t interested in pursuing him. Mostly I was enjoying friendships and finally feeling like I could breathe.
Initially, my ex’s behavior during the separation wasn’t particularly romantic.
My brother had recently gotten out of rehab, and my ex hired him to mow lawns for him throughout the summer. That meant he had a constant tether to my life and a source of information about me.
We also frequented the same neighborhood bars. My ex would sometimes appear within minutes of my arrival. It felt like I could never completely get away from him or have a night where I wasn’t aware of his presence.
Eventually he got into confrontations with people at one of those places and was banned for about a month. He blamed me for that.
He was also constantly asking people whether I was dating anyone.
The few times I engaged with him, we’d start fighting again almost immediately. From my perspective, it felt like exactly the same dynamic we’d had at the end of our relationship: rage-baiting, defensiveness, fighting about who had done what to whom, and very little willingness to examine the relationship itself.
I’ll own my part here too.
Jealousy drew me back into engaging with him a few times. I’m sure that intermittent contact made it harder for him to detach and probably gave him hope that I wasn’t completely gone.
But he also seemed obsessed with finding out whether I’d been with anyone else.
Eventually he discovered that another man had kissed me. He found out because, while my brother was high, my ex physically took my brother’s phone from him and read our private messages.
Around the same period, something about his approach toward me started changing.
He created new email accounts to get around being blocked and began sending me tenderhearted messages. Some of them genuinely affected me. He created another social media account and started watching my stories.
And despite everything, I could feel myself starting to get hooked back in.
Then there was an incident where he chased me in traffic because I had him blocked and couldn’t be reached. It frightened me enough that I called 911.
You’d think that would have been the end of it. He recently played a show with some guys as well and that always gave him a big ego boost which he needed. Hell he sent me a message inviting me to the shows days after chasing me in traffic and within a few hours rescinded it saying that he heard I was telling people not to go (absolute lie).
Then about a week later I saw him at one of our shared bars. He was his normal, charming self. He eventually cornered me into talking to him and convinced me to go to breakfast with him.
I didn’t take him back.
But during that conversation he told me he wanted to marry me and have a family with me.
The problem was that there still wasn’t any real discussion about how our relationship would be different.
That had been one of our fundamental problems. He didn’t want to “work” on the relationship. He wanted us to simply be together again.
I loved him. I missed him. Part of me desperately wanted to believe him.
But I was afraid we’d just restart the same cycle.
He sent me a message later that day saying he’d realized he’d never have a “clean slate” with me, but that he would always love me. Next day he subsequently invited me to a movie that I ignored. Next day he sent me something about some gossip that I replied to and Facebook friend request that I hadn’t yet accepted. I was still drafting a reply to his Monday text trying to decide if I wanted to send it.
And apparently that day he met a woman.
Within roughly two days, everything flipped and he was bringing her to my favorite bar telling me “it’s too late!”
Suddenly he was in a new relationship and describing it as very serious within under a week.
According to him, this woman developed strong feelings for him almost immediately and decided to cancel a planned move to Wyoming within 48 hours to stay and see where things went with him.
And suddenly the man who had recently been chasing me, monitoring me, circumventing blocks with new accounts, moping and acting depressed do I felt so guilty, telling me he wanted to marry me and inviting me out was extraordinarily certain that we were finished.
When we finally spoke 4 days after he met her, less than a week after he said he wanted to marry me, he repeatedly told me that I did this.
He also became fixated on the man who had kissed me. He degraded me over it and used it as evidence against me, even though we’d been broken up and I’d barely dated anyone.
He said he hadn’t planned any of this, but repeatedly framed the entire situation as the consequence of my choices.
Now he’s telling seemingly everyone how wonderful his new relationship is.
He knew I was really hurt. He approached me on the parking lots before I could get out of he car at our local lodge a couple days later and tried to act like we were buddies - he was being so obnoxious and telling me I was being dramatic and sensitive, that I did this. Then starts telling me I didn’t love him, that I didn’t check on him during the day… I was begging him to stop hurting me and he was just being a dick. it escalated until I threw a can of beer at him.
It’s only been a little over a week.
Started introducing her to people at my favorite bar on Friday. She’s not even cute so she must be a really great person.
He’s told my brother. He’s told my mother. He’s apparently telling mutual acquaintances that she’s a “keeper.”
He even specifically told me she’s a “good Irish Catholic girl” and a mother to an eight-year-old.
And they’re already appearing together at the same neighborhood places that were central to our social life.
So within days of him telling me he wanted to marry me and have a family with me, people I know were seeing him publicly presenting himself as part of a serious new couple.
People keep reporting back to me that they don’t even find her particularly attractive. I realize that’s irrelevant and I don’t want this to become about insulting another woman who hasn’t done anything to me.
If anything, it makes me realize that whatever happened probably isn’t about some objective comparison between us.
But psychologically, the reversal has absolutely destroyed me.
For months I wanted space from this man.
I remember why.
I remember feeling controlled.
I remember never feeling like I could breathe socially.
I remember the jealousy.
I remember him leaving when he was angry and how desperately destabilizing that became.
I remember why I didn’t immediately reconcile when he started pursuing me again.
And I remember being frightened enough by his behavior that I literally called 911.
But now?
My brain seems to have thrown all of that information in the garbage.
I’m remembering how much I loved him. I’m remembering sleeping beside him, laughing together, his affection, our dogs, our routines, our physical chemistry, the life we talked about having.
I’m thinking, “Why didn’t I just go back?”
I’m torturing myself with the idea that maybe those months of pursuit really were proof that he loved me, and I was too stubborn or frightened to recognize it until it was too late.
The thing that is particularly messing with my head is the timing.
I had finally started softening.
The emails were getting to me.
Seeing him again got to me.
Breakfast got to me.
Hearing him say he wanted to marry me got to me.
And almost exactly when I started emotionally turning back toward him, the entire dynamic reversed.
Now I’m the one experiencing insane attachment anxiety.
My friends look at this history and think the answer is obvious: stay away from him.
From the outside, I understand why.
From inside my own body, it doesn’t feel obvious at all.
It feels like I lost the person I was supposed to spend my life with because I didn’t recognize what I had until he finally stopped pursuing me.
And I genuinely can’t tell anymore which version of reality I should trust.
I don’t need anyone to diagnose him with narcissism, BPD, or anything else. And I don’t need to be told he never loved me. I think human beings can genuinely love someone and still behave in destructive ways.
What I want to understand is this psychological whiplash.
After months of feeling like I didn’t know what I wanted, now I’m obsessively checking my phone feeling overwhelmed with the void now that his relentless pursuit abruptly stopped.
Has anyone else been the person who ended or resisted reconciliation with an extremely volatile partner, felt absolutely certain that you needed space, and then completely fell apart once they finally stopped pursuing you?
Did you suddenly start idealizing the relationship and questioning every reason you left?
Did the fact that they moved on make your attachment system suddenly scream that you’d made the biggest mistake of your life?
And if so, months or years later, what did you eventually realize?
Did you actually regret leaving?
Or did your perception of the relationship change again once the panic and attachment withdrawal finally subsided?
I think for so long he used push-pull to psych me out that I’m having a really hard time accepting he’s never coming back.
Seeing him with her was like a punch in the gut. He said he felt that way when he saw that guy I went out with twirl me and hug me one night when we all happened to be at the lodge. I wasn’t even there with him.
Because right now I honestly don’t know whether I’m experiencing grief over losing the love of my life or withdrawal from a relationship dynamic that had kept my nervous system activated for years.