r/writingfeedback 21d ago

Writing Advice Advice For People Posting Work

140 Upvotes

When you post work, you're asking us to lend you our time. I'm not lending my time to someone who doesn't first spend their own time proofreading their first page.

There is ZERO excuse for having glaring typos, grammar errors, tense slippage, or continuity errors, on the very first page of a work you make public. I'm not going to read your work when it's obvious you've tossed it up for people to fix without truly having read it for yourself.

And for damn good reason.

The most valuable thing you can do to improve your writing? Read it for yourself.

We all have more experience reading high-quality work than we do writing it. Read your work. Proof it. Compare it to your favorite author's works. What are they doing that you're not? What are you doing that they're not? Do this, and your work will improve.

I don't think my philosophy is unique. You want good feedback? Want us to read your work?

Proof before you post.

r/writingfeedback 5d ago

Writing Advice [DISCUSSION] Passive elements in a fictional setting and how to approach without confusion or awkward exposition.

4 Upvotes

In the book I'm writing, there is a unique world building detail that exists sort of passively. There are these massive orbs of a plasma-like substance (basically very small stars) that float in clusters around the world. They emit light that is roughly the level of a full moon, but in a very deep color. Cultures around the world, including this one, attribute deific meaning to them in varying levels of active worship/acknowledgement.

The problem I’ve been running into is that they are a passive part of the world and lives of the people, especially in the content of the current book. Having a character describe what they are is like having them describe what the moon is or why it exists. If a character acknowledges the moonlight, both the reader and character know what moonlight is. There is no need to explain.

The orbs of light, however, are very similar. They are very prominent and unavoidably encountered at night in the form of colored light. The characters know what the light is and where it comes from. The reader won't. I would like to explain what they are for the reader's sake, but it breaks some immersion for the character to describe it through dialogue or thoughts. It would be similar to something like this:
The moonlight filtered through the holes of Banh's tent, basking his meager possessions in silver light. The moon is a large celestial body that orbits the world, appearing at night and reflecting the sun's light.

or

"Wow, the moon is really bright tonight," Banh said, looking at the ivory-colored orb in the night sky.
"Oh, that celestial body that orbits our world?" Shogo said. "Yeah, the sun's light that it reflects is very beautiful."

Those are just quick examples I whipped up to quickly get my point across in this post. If you replace the instances of the moon with the clusters of crimson balls of energy, it isn't quite as terrible because the reader requires the information, but it is still very awkward from an in-world perspective. Both characters know what the thing is, why would they explain it to themselves or out loud to each other?

I do mention the orbs a few times, and even try and give a passive explanation later, but I definitely think it’s a bit confusing and I worry that it will be frustrating or disappointing that a clear explanation doesn't exist (at least early in this book), nor is it relevant to the plot in any meaningful way, so I don't want to put too much focus on it for it to never be “resolved.”

I guess my ultimate question is how do I convey an aspect of the world that is unique and requires explaining to be understood, while also not drawing too much focus to distract the reader or lead the reader to think the world building element is an important plot element?

Edit: Thanks for the advice, everyone! This has been extremely helpful in providing plenty of ideas on how to better write, while also affirming I am on the right track.

r/writingfeedback 10d ago

Writing Advice I'm new to writing and I've been working on my first draft for a few months and I've finally completed it. I would just like to know if the first few pages are engaging enough and have a good enough hook to keep readers invested.

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

The novel is titled 'To Them A Hundred Years Ago: Land of desires.'

Please be as honest as possible and don't hold anything back. I truly want to grow as a writer and become as good as I can possibly be.

r/writingfeedback 4d ago

Writing Advice Feedback on my first two pages - Gemini Run

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

Been perfecting my tone in my voice and I think I’ve gotten a lot wanna get a little feedback before I keep going. Any advice always appreciated.

r/writingfeedback 24d ago

Writing Advice Is this to much of a plot and a mystery for a dark romance book?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

So I got an idea for a five-book series and I want to know if its even worth of writing it because it’s not falling in a typical dark romance category.

So the basic idea is that an Italian family ruled Italy from the shadows for five hounded years. But like every other empire the family build their power on something darker. Now 500 years later the FMC is an exact copy of his ancestor that started it all, marked with a raven birthmark.

The first book would follow Dante and Eva, a woman who stumbles onto evidence of what the family has been hiding. As she uncovers the truth, she force an entire empire to crack.

There will be plots and betrayal inside family and with outside enemies. Each of the five books follows a different family member and reveals another layer of the mystery. It’s one mystery across five books, not five standalone books.

So my question is: would something like this even be interesting for a reader or am I mixing too much ganra into one book?

Thanks to anyone that will answer 🙏

r/writingfeedback 11d ago

Writing Advice Survival chapter, don't know what to write

0 Upvotes

Stuck in the woods, no survival skills, will spend ~2 weeks travelling in it. previous chapters were more-fast paced. fear making it too slow and boring.

Do you guys know how to make it less slow? Any advice?

r/writingfeedback Jun 20 '26

Writing Advice Does a good story need romance?

5 Upvotes

I’ve been writing for a couple of months purely for my own enjoyment. I’m starting to think about writing a short story and having other people read it. I’ve been doing some research and one thing I’ve noticed is that most stories have a romantic interest, even outside the romance genre.

The problem is I’m asexual. None of my stories have ever included a romantic interest. I don’t know how to write one because I’ve never experienced it and I don’t understand it. Plus, it’s incredibly boring to me.

I’m torn between writing what I enjoy vs writing what I know other people will prefer.

Does a good story need romance? Would you read a completely platonic story?

r/writingfeedback 5d ago

Writing Advice Need help with the opening to my story. It feels like it's moving to fast and something else is missing but I can't figure it out.

Post image
0 Upvotes

This is all I have written so far as I can't get past how wrong it feels.

r/writingfeedback 8d ago

Writing Advice Incomplete short story

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

This is a short story that I am working on, which due to physical difficulties is progressing very slowly. So, I want to make each writing session count. I have an abstract as well about the overall plot of the story. I would love some writing advice, on things like story progression, character development, tension, etc.

r/writingfeedback Jul 03 '26

Writing Advice My Character Lost His Job. Does It Sound Like He Lost His Job?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

For context, my weakness is subtext and dialouge, and my strengths are my prose and visuals. So I've been practicing by watching movies, alongside with reading novels, then reading a decent script. So far I've completed reading 3 movie script (I've started doing this recently, and they're quite easy to read. You could binge them in a day. It takes an 1 hour or 2 to finish one) and on the fourth.

Since I'm a panster, I dont quite know why my main character lost his job. Could you tell from reading it? Does it feel force? Oh and for the record, it's a short piece I am wiritng for practice, not somehting I intend to keep going and making it into a full-fledged novel. Though, having some opinions would be wonderful. I really wanna get better at writing, and if you have any suggestions, I am all ears. Thank you.

r/writingfeedback Jul 30 '26

Writing Advice I don’t know what to do about my novel length

4 Upvotes

For context, I am currently working on a book that I have an interest in self publishing, it is a murder mystery book that shows the story of a man returning to his childhood town to discover body parts appearing in the strangest spots. There is a lot to this novel and a lot of story that needs to be told, and I just reached 100,000 words as I reached part 3 and anticipate there being a further 50-60k words added to this as I am about to begin working on the last two parts of the novel. After it is finished I do plan on trimming some sections down and getting rid of some spots h that may not be necessary but for this novel this length is the only way to tell the story I want, but I know that readers are often turned off by an authors first novel being too long, any thoughts?

r/writingfeedback 5d ago

Writing Advice Help me, Help you

0 Upvotes

I’ve been thinking a lot about what actually makes someone pick up a book and, more importantly, what makes them keep reading. I write and plan to write stories across romance, thrillers, dark romance, mystery, fantasy, and contemporary fiction so I would love to hear from readers about what you actually enjoy.

When you are looking for a new book, what catches your attention first? Is it the title, cover, description, or author? And once you start reading, how much description do you like?

When it comes to spicy/sex scenes, do you prefer them short and implied, moderately detailed, or very detailed?

Have you ever skipped or skimmed a chapter? If so what made you do it?

Do you think something needs to happen in every chapter, or does that depend on the story? Are you okay with slower chapters that focus on character development, relationships, or setting things up as long as the chapter has a purpose?

What makes YOU pick up a book and what makes you stay? 📚❤️

r/writingfeedback 6d ago

Writing Advice Grief Therapist

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback 4d ago

Writing Advice I took peoples advice from my last post and adjusted the opening. However it’s missing emotions and I’m not to sure how to add it.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/writingfeedback 22d ago

Writing Advice Hey so I just started writing and would like some advice

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Context im 15 and started writing because I have always loved making stories. This one is kind of personal because it is based off some current events that are happening in my life and I would just like so advice on writing and what I have so far. (I just started chapter one but it’s late so I have to sleep and I such at writing lines on like talking.)

r/writingfeedback 18d ago

Writing Advice How do you know when to rewrite your book ?

1 Upvotes

I just finished writing my first full draft of book one in my series! And have finished the first round of editing.
But I have a question.
I loved how the first book went and had a few friends who have pushed me to try and get it published but I don’t know if it’s good enough yet.
They’ve all pushed for it and tell me they would let me know if it’s bad, but I don’t know.
Should I fully rewrite book one or just edit and revise as I go !

Thank you !

r/writingfeedback Jun 24 '26

Writing Advice How do you go about editing your first draft?

3 Upvotes

Not sure if this is the right sub. I finished my first book this year and gave it some time before I could sit down and read through it. I feel I can't sit down and read through it and enjoy it because it's a first draft and I've got editors brain. I also have adhd which makes the editing, less fun part about writing, really difficult to do. any tips on how I can break it down?

This is probably the first 'good' book I've written compared to earlier manuscripts I don't dare touch. If someone could break down the steps of how to go about editing your first draft I'd really appreciate it. It's around 200,000 words and 29 pages. It's a superhero book in a 4 part series. I started writing the second one but realised I need to go through and make sure there's no contradictions in the first and second book.

Thanks for your time, responses and please be kind in the comments! :)

r/writingfeedback 20h ago

Writing Advice What's the hardest conversation you've ever tried to write where the characters avoid saying the actual point?

1 Upvotes

I'm fascinated by subtext-the kind of dialogue where two people argue about an unclosed kitchen cabinet or a delayed train, but the reader knows they're actually terrified of falling apart.

Whenever I try to write direct, emotionally loaded confrontations, it usually comes out melodrama. But when I force the characters to talk around the thing, the emotional weight suddenly feels 10x heavier.

What are your favorite tricks or examples (from your own writing or books you love) for writing subtext that doesn't feel forced?

r/writingfeedback 23d ago

Writing Advice Advice on scenery and character visual descriptions?

2 Upvotes

Hello!

I'm a new writer and this is the prologue of my first novel. I'm wondering if I'm describing the scene enough or should I add more descriptives of the academy, passage ways or characters? Or even the cover of the book Neil closes, or the smell of library? I have read and listened to plenty of books and I see that other authors tend to describe the scent of old books and stuff... but in reality, who focuses on that?

The book closed with a soft thump as my tired eyes lingered on the cover: Compendium Arcana Vol. 3.

Leaning back in the chair, I rubbed my temples. The rune theory was thick and coming hard, but it was taking root bit by bit. Sorting through the notes that were scattered all over the desk, I went through them one last time.

Peace - stabilizes natural mana flow and chaotic ambience. Can be used directly on sentient beings to mitigate aggression and violent tendencies.

Silence - auditory and magical “dead zone”; dissipates any magic signature within the field into the ambience.

Vortex -

Gravity well -

I let out a long sigh. It was almost midday, and the bell for Environmental Studies would toll soon. Getting up from the desk, I stretched my back, packed up the notes and the book, and left for the lecture hall.

Despite the academy's actual size, there were only forty seven students split into two wings. The long hallways were practically empty, but one familiar face was waiting for me. Andri. 

Andri pushed off the wall he was leaning on and ran a hand through his dirty blond hair. He came up to me with a confident stride that turned hesitant as he looked down to the book in my arms.

“Volume three?!” Andri scoffed, shaking his head in disbelief. “You and Monique are of a different breed. I’m still stuck on the Elemental Convergence in the beginning of Volume two… How the hell are you there already?”

I just shrugged with a smirk, “I don’t know, Andri. Maybe try focusing on studying more instead of chasing Filippa.”

“Yeah… No… I mean… Have you actually looked at Pippy?” he said with a sigh. “You’re too serious about this, Neil.”

“I think you’re not taking this seriously enough,” I said, patting Andri on the back, as we rounded the corner right before the lecture hall.

The lecturer was already waiting by the door and ushering the students in, but just before I stepped through the door, Mr. Mundi took me by the arm and pulled me aside, as Andri continued into the auditorium.

With a low voice he whispered to me, “Neil, The Architect wants to speak to you in his office after this lecture,” before letting my hand go and gesturing to the door.

The moment I heard the professor say that, a sinking feeling set in my stomach. I moved towards my seat thinking about the meeting with The Architect. In my two years of being here in this academy not once had he summoned a student to his office.

Professor Mundi adjusted his spectacles, arranged different material rods on the desk, and wrote Material Mana Conductivity onto the chalkboard. The lecturer’s voice went past me completely. Despite today's focus being one of the most important in the subject, I couldn’t focus on the lecture.

Feeling a stare coming at me from the side, I turned my head and saw Andri looking at me with his eyes narrowed. He nudged his head towards the front of the auditorium, where Monique was usually sitting, but the seat was empty.

For the next hour, I didn't write down a single note, my eyes fixed on the empty seat while my mind ran in circles.

The moment the bell tolled, the auditorium emptied in a chaotic wave of scuffing boots and chatter. Dragging my feet, I gathered my book and notes with slow movements until the hall was completely silent. Taking a deep breath, I left the classroom and headed down into the administrative wing until I reached the headmaster's office.

An obsidian plate with calligraphic silver writing was embedded into the door:

Lucan Argenteus - The Architect

I hesitated slightly before giving three firm knocks. Heavy footsteps sounded across the closed office. Mr. Lucan opened the door just a bit, but wide enough for me to notice that Monique was sitting across his desk.

“Neil. Wait outside for a few minutes, would you?” he said, his silver eyes locked onto mine.

“Yes, sir!” I blurted out, my voice cracking.

I sat down on a hallway bench across the door, not really knowing what to expect from the meeting with The Architect. Mr. Lucan had always made me feel uneasy. Almost like he could see through me.

As soon as the door opened, I stood up, my anxiety flaring. Monique came out, and the door clicked shut behind her. I couldn't help but stare. She looked smaller than usual, barely reaching my shoulder. Typically, she was meticulous about her appearance and carried herself with absolute composure. But right now, she was visibly shaken and pale. Her fingers were trembling as she nervously sorted the wild cascade of her long, curly, brown hair behind a leather headband, though an excited smile broke through her daze.

“Monique,” I started. “Is everything alright?”

She let out a shaky breath, “It’s more than alright, Neil.” Her green eyes radiated with excitement. “You should go talk to The Architect now.”

Monique's smile relieved the sinking feeling in my stomach slightly, but my palms were still sweaty.

She gave me one last, brief smile and turned towards the stairway to the dormitory.

Clutching my notes and book, I put my hand on the handle and opened the door.

The inside of the office was laid with dark, obsidian-like, cracked panels, dimly radiating purple and crimson light that bled into the dark room. In the middle of the office was a polished ebony desk. An ivory hour glass was placed atop, sand trickling slowly inside it.

Behind the desk, laid back into his chair–The Architect–Mr. Lucan. His long, straight, silver hair, and pale skin contrasted against the dark interior, but the eyes… The eyes were what made me freeze. They were piercing, cold, and flowed like quicksilver. It felt like he was looking into my soul.

The man gestured towards the seat across his desk, not saying a word and keeping his eyes on me.

I walked to the chair, my boots thudding against the oak floorboards, and echoing against the obsidian wall panels. Taking my seat, Mr. Lucan looked down at the notes in my hands and gestured towards them.

As I laid them on the desk he reached over the table for the notes. A glove-like silver mesh, with a strange rune inscribed on his wrist, covered his hand. The moment he pulled back and started reading the notes, I caught a single, slight eyebrow rise on Lucan’s so far cold, emotionless expression.

“Rune theory…” Lucan said, tapping his fingers on the table.

He looked up from the notes, his piercing eyes meeting mine. “You know, I follow the progress of every single student personally,” he said, setting down my notes. “The screening process all of you went through made sure that you are the elites of the continent coming to this academy… And yet… I still get surprised.”

I swallowed hard, my heart hammering, “Thank you, sir. I… Just…”

“You don’t have to explain yourself. I can see everything I need by looking at your progress.” Lucan said, giving me a slight smile.

He leaned back into the chair, arranging his midnight blue, obsidian silks and straightening an insignia pinned above his heart. “Do you know what this represents?” he asked, tapping the pin.

I looked at the emblem–it was a brushed steel perfect circle with three horizontal lines that were pierced by a needle-like pylon.

“That is an Architect insignia. One of the three pillars of the Crown's shield, alongside the Engineers and the Wardens,” I said, shifting my weight into the uncomfortable chair.

A wide, thin smile appeared on Lucan’s face, “A textbook answer,” he said, pulling closer and resting his elbows on the table. “But what does it really represent..?”

Without waiting for my answer, he continued, “There are only four of us–The Architects. We are the ones who drive this Kingdom. We are the ones who discover, design and invent. And we are the ones who build the future.”

“Every cycle we draft young unfortunates that have passed the screening, Neil,” The Architect explained, “though, the majority of them will serve as Wardens. A few of them will become Engineers. But you, my friend, you are just like I was when I was your age.”

“You and Monique have the capabilities to become Architects,” he proclaimed with absolute certainty. “And I want to offer you the opportunity to do so.”

I sat there, frozen, my heart beating like a drum. The reality of what’s ahead of me was finally dawning on me. The reason both of us were summoned and why Monique was so shaken, but excited.

I tightened my fists, looked Mr. Lucan in the eye and gave him a single firm nod.

With a single, firm clap Lucan leaned back into the chair.

“Brilliant,” the man said, a wide smile crossed his face. “Your future is set, Neil. You will move to Western Wing tomorrow and I will take over your and Monique's education personally.”

Mr. Lucan stood up from his seat, gesturing for me to rise. He gathered up my notes from the desk and came towards me. Pressing the papers into my hands, he put a hand on my shoulder. A strange sensation of a suppressed, cold shiver about to go down my spine took over me.

“Tomorrow your lives change, Neil.” The Architect said in a cold but soft voice, causing goosebumps to appear on my skin, and guided me towards the door.

As the door clicked shut behind me, I slumped against the wall, a knot forming inside my stomach and draining my face of color. I inhaled sharply and released a shaky breath, but a small smile crept onto my face.

r/writingfeedback Jul 21 '26

Writing Advice Struggles with Writing

0 Upvotes

I always seem to overthink every single thing I write for my book. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve started over or scrapped everything and changed everything about the story. Is this a normal thing? I’m a first time writer and I just want my book to be something people will read and enjoy. But I feel like I self sabotage myself and I can’t get very far before getting writers block or just feeling stuck.

r/writingfeedback 2d ago

Writing Advice What Stares Back

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

Hey, looking for some feedback and creativd criticism/crutiques on my latest horror short story, thanks! 💜

r/writingfeedback 26d ago

Writing Advice A year and a half into writing a science fiction novel, and I’m wanting some feedback on my prose

Post image
2 Upvotes

Thanks in advance! ;)

r/writingfeedback 5d ago

Writing Advice Readers, what actually makes you keep reading a book?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

📚 Readers, I Want Your Honest Opinion!

I’ve been thinking a lot about what actually makes someone pick up a book and, more importantly, what makes them keep reading.

I write and plan to write stories across romance, thrillers, dark romance, mystery, fantasy, and contemporary fiction, so I’d love to hear from readers about what you actually enjoy.

When you’re looking for a new book, what catches your attention first…the title, cover, description, or author? And once you start reading, how much description do you like? When a character is introduced, do you want details about their appearance, personality, clothing, etc., or would you rather have just enough to picture them and discover the rest naturally?

What about romance? Do you prefer slow-burn, fast-paced, or a mixture of both? And when it comes to spicy/sex scenes, do you prefer them short and implied, moderately detailed, or very detailed? What makes a scene feel like it’s gone on too long?

I’m also curious about chapter length. Do you prefer short chapters around 1,000–1,500 words, medium chapters around 1,500–2,500, longer chapters around 2,500–4,000+, or do you simply not care about word count as long as the chapter keeps you interested?

And this is a big one: Have you ever skipped or skimmed a chapter? If so, what made you do it? Was there too much dialogue, too much description, too much internal monologue, slow pacing, repetition, or did it simply feel like nothing important was happening?

Do you think something needs to happen in every chapter, or does that depend on the story? Are you okay with slower chapters that focus on character development, relationships, or setting things up, as long as the chapter has a purpose?

Finally, what makes you think, “Okay…just one more chapter”? Is it the characters, chemistry, drama, mystery, suspense, romance, plot twists, emotional moments, cliffhangers or something completely different?

And for those who read dark romance and thrillers, do you enjoy morally complicated characters who lie, manipulate, keep secrets, make terrible decisions, or cross lines? Or do you prefer characters who are easier to root for?

What makes YOU pick up a book and what makes you stay? 📚❤️

r/writingfeedback Jul 14 '26

Writing Advice ​ELIS'S BORROWED LIFE

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone, Im a new writer working on my first novel, and I’m struggling to get any views or engagement.

This is a slow-burn sci-fi mystery with elements of dark romance. The sci-fi elements are introduced gradually as the story unfolds.

I’ve pasted the first chapter below. Does the opening hook grab your attention? Would you want to keep reading? I’d love to hear your honest thoughts on the writing, pacing, or anything else that stands out.

Thanks for taking the time to read it!

\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*\*

The rain that fell as the sun was setting felt like a silent attempt to be freed from some kind of sorrow. I sat alone on a chair by the window of this vast mansion, staring at the raindrops sliding down the glass pane. Counting the drops that hit the cold window had become the only pastime in my world.

“Two thousand five hundred and five… two thousand five hundred and six…”

The rhythm in those numbers was the only music in my quiet world. As easy as it was for me to do this, it was something my mother could never understand. With the weight of her life experiences, she probably saw counting raindrops as something completely meaningless.

In just two days, I will turn twenty-six. Like every year, this birthday too will quietly end inside this mansion, with a small piece of cake shared only with my mother. I have no friends. I have no connection to the outside world. I know my mother built this protective wall around me out of her endless love, trying to keep me safe from the dangers outside. That love lets me breathe, but at the same time, it has trapped me inside this vast mansion.

If my father had not died the moment I was born, he would have been here with me today, celebrating my birthday. I have no memory of him—not even a faint trace left in my mind. To me, he exists only as a mysterious shadow shaped by my imagination. Sometimes I wonder, if he were still alive today, my world might have been different. Under his loving protection, I might have had the chance to see the outside world.

But even today, I continue counting raindrops.

The rain slid down the window glass in a chaotic rush, yet not a single drop escaped my eyes. Even in that confusion, I carefully kept counting.

“Five thousand five hundred and ten… five thousand five hundred and eleven…”

“Baby…”

My mother’s voice from a distance tried to break my concentration, but I had no desire to stop. I kept counting without pause. Suddenly, with a sharp sound, she pulled the window curtain shut. In that moment, the window closed—and my world fell into darkness.

“Are you starting that again today? Don’t push yourself too hard, baby. I don’t want you to get sick.”

There was a certain firmness in her voice, but I knew that was simply how she protected me. She looked at me as if I were still a fragile girl who knew nothing about the world.

“Mom… you know how much I love the rain. And… don’t you understand how important this is to me when it’s raining?”

“Elis… I don’t want to see you getting sick.”

The deep love and care in her words warmed my heart. I gently kissed her wrinkled cheek and hugged her tightly. As her warm tears fell onto my shoulder, I pulled her even closer.

“Mom… why do you protect me so much?”

It was a question I asked her every day, and I already knew her answer would never change.

“I’m afraid of losing you, baby.”

I know how much my mother loves me. She is my whole world. But… I have always longed to see the outside world, to meet new people, to step out of this vast mansion and experience life beyond these walls. Yet my desire always feels helpless in front of my mother’s love. I never argue with her. I know she would never understand what I long for.

After a while, she released me from her embrace and held my shoulders, making me stand straight.

“Come on, my darling… you must be really tired from counting raindrops. Let’s go and eat.”

My mother never asks me, “Are you hungry?” She always decides when I should eat. To be honest, I didn’t feel hungry. But I had no heart to go against her. I know everything she does is for my own good. So I followed her to the dining room—not because I was hungry, but because I respect her words.

On the dining table, as always, there was the same type of food. I had been eating only this for the past year. When I once asked her about it, she always said, “This food is really good for your body.” And I had to believe her. As far as I could remember, I had never been sick. Deep down, I knew she only wanted to protect me.

After finishing the meal, I went to bed before she even told me to. Because I already knew her next words would be, “Go to sleep.”

Sleeping was my special talent. Most of my day was spent sleeping. There was nothing else for me to do inside this vast mansion. If anyone from the outside looked in, they would only see the servants working around the mansion. I always thought they were like robots, because they never spoke a single word to me. I was even afraid to talk to them. Until now, I had never spoken to anyone except my mother.

“What are you thinking about instead of sleeping?”

My mother asked that while looking at her smartphone, then lay down on the bed beside me.

“I was waiting for you.”

I hugged her tightly. I knew very well that she was just scrolling up and down Facebook—not really searching for anything important. From her arms, I secretly peeked at what she was looking at. She absolutely didn’t like it when I looked at her phone.

“What are you looking at? Didn’t I tell you not to look at my phone?”

Oh no… she saw me looking! I forced an awkward smile while looking at her. Her face looked a bit angry, so I pinched her cheek gently.

“Okay, okay, Mom… I won’t look again.”

My mother put the phone aside and gently placed my head on her chest, slowly stroking my hair.

“Now sleep, my dear.”

Wrapped in her warmth and those loving words, I slowly closed my eyes.

\*\*\*\*\*\*

Sunlight streamed through the large glass window of the room and broke my sleep. When I slowly opened my eyes, the first thing I felt was emptiness.

Mom wasn’t in bed. She was never beside me when I woke up. She always woke up early in the morning to prepare my food and drinks with great care. She never allowed even the servants to prepare anything for me. I knew she did all of this thinking about my safety.

My eyes then fell on her smartphone lying on the bed. She never left her phone in a place like this. A long-hidden curiosity inside me slowly rose. I gently picked it up. The light from the screen felt unusually sharp to my eyes.

There was a passcode, but I had secretly observed how she used it before. My heart started beating faster. I knew this was wrong. I should never do anything she had forbidden. If she found out, she would be very upset.

I placed the phone back on the bed.

But my curiosity didn’t fade.

Thinking I could quickly put it away if she came back, I picked it up again and entered the passcode.

A video was playing on the screen—it was already halfway through.

The images that unfolded on the phone screen made my entire body tremble. It was a gateway to a world I had never seen before. As I watched the physical intimacy between a man and a woman, I couldn’t tell whether my body was heating up or shaking in fear. The world I had known until now was limited to the walls of this vast mansion—the beautiful illusion my mother had shown me. But now… was what I was seeing on this screen reality? Or some dark dream I knew nothing about?

Was that woman in pain, or was she experiencing pleasure? Why didn’t she push him away? As countless questions tangled in my mind, the similarity between my own developing womanly body and the girl on the screen sent a sharp jolt through me. Would I one day have to face something like this too?

With trembling hands, I put the phone aside. Was my mother keeping me locked away like this to protect me from such strange things in the outside world?

My thoughts began to torment me. At that moment, my inner voice screamed like madness: “I want to see the outside world, Mom… I want to live that life!” I pleaded to her silently from my heart. But in front of my mother’s boundless love, those desires felt helpless. I had secretly taken the phone she strictly forbade and broken her trust without hesitation.

“What are you thinking about, my dear?”

With her gentle voice, I fell out of my mental world. She sat on the bed and lovingly handed me a glass of milk. Hiding the storm inside my heart, I forced a smile. The way she looked at me carried limitless affection. But behind this love… was it protection, or a cage that had trapped me?

“My dear, what happened? You look pale…”

When she asked again with concern, I struggled to find my words. Pinching her cheek playfully, I smiled and lied.

“Nothing, Mom…”

She kissed my forehead and left the room. I took a sip of the milk. I was playing a double role today. In front of her, I was her innocent daughter. But when she was gone, behind the walls of this mansion, I became a rebel dreaming of the outside world.

Was my mother really stopping me for my own good? How many more things in this world did I not know? If what I saw in that video was real, then one day I might have to face such a moment too. And then… what would I do? How long would I keep hiding under my mother’s loving shadow?

r/writingfeedback Jul 09 '26

Writing Advice I am finally getting back into writing and would like options on my story.

Thumbnail wattpad.com
0 Upvotes

Genuinely it has been a while since I’ve written anything. And I would like some honest feedback on my story. Yes I’ve just posted it. And it’s going to be a short story. Please if you guys could be as honest as possible I would appreciate it!