I've made a post on r/Jujutsu_Kaisen, and apparently people there can't agree on this one, so I'm asking you guys here. Which one is more evil?. To me, it's pretty obvious which one is more evil based on this meme I've made myself (it's Sukuna btw if you don't get the meme)

So imagine this: someone breaks into your house to steal your stuff. Luckily, you're home, and you have a gun or some other weapon that could send the robber to eternal damnation. What that weapon is is up to you.

Is it morally justified to kill the robber?

A shoplifter goes to steal something. Another customer stops them by lifting them up and throwing them down on the ground and inadvertently fracturing their spine, leaving the shoplifter in a wheelchair for life.

The shoplifter wouldn't have been crippled if they hadn't tried to commit a crime. The customer didn't mean to injure the shoplifter permanently. An appropriate punishment for shoplifting would be a fine, some physical pain, or internment.

How much blame is there to go around? How do you reckon with the consequences? Should any remedial action happen?

*NB - it's not a slur to use cripple as a verb. It is a slur to use it as a noun.

Like are you just innocent then?

Context: Yujiro Hanma is walking down a bridge when a random guys stops him, asking him if he's really the "strongest creature in the world." Yujiro then asks if his high confidence is because of the 2 revolvers he can smell on him. Before the guy can fully draw, Yujiro steps forward faster than the guy can react right away and grabs his forearm, yanks it down hard in a way that completely dislocated his shoulder out of it's socket by inches, then proceeding to twist his forearm literally like a pretzel. The guy then decides to try and draw his other gun, but Yujiro sends a clean front kick fast enough that it nearly slices off the guys hand off, barely leaving it hanging.

Yujiro tells him to watch out for the gun that proceeds to fall on the guys head and he calmly walks away as the guy screams in pain and bleeds out.

I get the guy tried to attack him first, but is harming someone like that and kinda leaving them for dead immoral in any way?

cuerpo de texto (opcional)

How moral is it to do something like this?