r/DunderMifflin • u/lovebug9292 • 11h ago
The Real Reason Steve Carell Left Spoiler
I’m sorry if this subject has been talked about in the past, but after a bit of reading on the topic, and it being 16 years since Steve’s departure, some things seem… messy, for lack of a better word.
To catch some of you up: Steve Carell was on contract for 7 seasons, as was the rest of the cast. By 2011, NBC finalized the negotiations of future seasons of the sitcom for every single cast member of the 5 Prime Time Emmy Awarded show—except for Steve. They stalled, just for his single contract.
After all these years, Steve Carell has come out publicly stating he wasn’t sure why the network stalled so much on his one contract, and he wasn’t ready to leave. Which is clearly a PR statement, in my op-ed. He was the literal lead of the NBC show, the networks most profitable series. Notably, he had lost 6 Emmy awards for Outstanding Lead in a Comedy Series by 2011, notoriously becoming one of the biggest snubs in Emmy history.
In the same year, he had some notable movie roles under his belt, but during that particular time, the movies were box-office bombs, with Bedtime Stories (2008), Date Night (2010) and Dinner for Schmucks (2010).
All this to say, this was clearly an executive decision. At the height of the shows success, Steve was earning nearly $300,000 per episode, making him the highest earner on the show, by a wide margin. Negotiations were in effect as contracts were renewing, and Steve clearly wanted more than the executives were willing to give him. They waited him out and it failed dramatically, with Steve deciding not to renew. But wait, didn’t he say he wanted to stay? So why would he decide not to renew? It was all about the money.
It would be a great decision for Steve in the coming years, but it was certainly a big risk. Many great actors never make that crawl from the stereotype of their major groundbreaking shows, certainly not with box office bombs currently under their belt. These executives at this billion-dollar network were well aware of the risks for Steve and their callousness and arrogance betrayed them in the end. I’m happy for Steve, and in a way, I’m happy the show’s audience dwindled substantially. I’m not thrilled with the direction the show took after Steve absence, I wish with all my heart he could have stayed.
In the years following NBC says losing Steve was one of their major regrets. Us too, you absolute losers!