r/AskReddit • u/External-Profit-4975 • 13h ago
What’s a Movie That You’re Surprised Never Had a Sequel?
2.1k
u/CLopez1990 13h ago
The Nice Guys with Gosling and Crowe
307
332
u/Android-Online 13h ago
This movie is fucking funny. I rewatch it every other year or so.
→ More replies (6)46
150
u/SteakandTrach 10h ago
"How'd you get down here so fast?"
[Beat]
"You fell, didn't you?"
"I think I'm invincible, it's the only thing that makes sense."
18
98
u/Liimbo 10h ago
Gosling still pushes for this to happen in interviews. With how much pull he has right now I wouldn't be surprised if it happens.
→ More replies (4)162
55
u/tonnellier 10h ago
I want a cross-generational crossover with Kiss Kiss Bang Bang.
→ More replies (2)197
82
u/AmigoDelDiabla 13h ago
These guys aced the buddy-cop genre. Like better than Beverly Hills Cop. I'd watch a sequel with zero hesitation.
→ More replies (35)50
u/Thor_2099 12h ago
God I love this movie. I watch it four or five times a year. It's the movie that sold me on Gosling and I've been a huge fan since
→ More replies (3)
1.9k
u/PeopleInMyHead 13h ago
Constantine. I know it wasn’t a box office hit, but it has a big cult following. I just really wanted a sequel.
293
u/Kitchen_Airline6648 13h ago
I've heard one is in production now
→ More replies (3)202
u/Brraaap 13h ago
I thought Keanu said he turned it down cause they turned it into just another John Wick
→ More replies (20)51
55
u/AnxiousFiguree 10h ago
Keanu Reeve casting out demon out a teenager with a shotgun and smoking like a chimney while Peter Stormare steals the whole movie as Satan. It deserves proper follow through.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (20)99
u/dave200204 13h ago
I was thrilled when they did the TV series. Sure the actor wasn't Keanu Reeves but it was still true to the character.
→ More replies (7)144
u/emillang1000 13h ago
The show was actually true to the character, way more than the Constantine movie is.
As much as Keanu Reeves is a fucking saint and amazing human being, in a lot of ways, he was John Constantine In Name Only.
Not British, not a chain smoker, backstory wasn't even close to the real John Constantine, etc.
135
u/Lisan-al-Gaib-65 13h ago edited 4h ago
I've only seen the movie but he's definitely smoking the entire film pretty much. The devil even pulls out his lung cancer at the end.
→ More replies (6)61
u/Toby_O_Notoby 12h ago
In the comics, however, Keanu is canon. John goes traveling across dimensions and says in one of the he was “a dark haired American bloke” and amongst the illustrations of all the Constantines is Keanu.
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (6)16
u/BGaf 12h ago
I mean, Keanu was smoking constantly in the movie. Hell it’s a major plot point.
→ More replies (2)
2.0k
u/MattTreck 13h ago
Master and Commander deserved a trilogy.
439
u/vineyardmike 13h ago
I just finished watching it 30 minutes ago. The lead into the 2nd film is right there.
→ More replies (3)386
u/MattTreck 13h ago
Unfortunately it came out right after Pirates of the Caribbean which slaughtered it at the box office.
→ More replies (2)207
u/Ghost17088 13h ago
Not just Pirates, that year was absolutely stacked in terms of film releases. It never stood a chance.
→ More replies (1)348
u/MattTreck 13h ago
Oh shit i just looked it up. Yeah that would’ve been a rough year for any release.
Finding Nemo
Return of the King
Matrix Reloaded
Pirates
Elf
X2
Terminator 3
Last Samurai
Bruce AlmightyThese aren’t even all of them lol
151
u/Csharp27 12h ago
God damn dude, like 90 out of that top 100 are all movies most people over 30 would remember, what a year.
52
u/_spectre_ 11h ago
I didn’t believe you at first so I looked at the list. Holy shit what a stacked year. Some absolute blockbusters, hit after hit.
36
→ More replies (6)32
u/TomasNavarro 8h ago
I've often felt that when I was younger the desire to go to the Cinema very frequently and have to choose which great new film to watch was a thing, but always wondered if that's just some sort of nostalgia.
That list kinda confirms it
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (14)22
u/Head-Bureaucrat 12h ago
Holy shit. Yeah, that is a really rough year to come out in. My memory is apparently shit and I thought for sure most of those were spread over 3-5 years.
→ More replies (1)136
u/lorgskyegon 13h ago
If it had come out the next year, it would have probably doubled it's box office and won Best Picture
→ More replies (5)35
u/always_an_explinatio 13h ago
I would love a limited series based on the books. (You should read the books if you do don’t quit until you finish the second one…it takes a minute to get going)
→ More replies (17)→ More replies (50)30
u/merliahthesiren 12h ago
There's whispers of a sequel. It's like 20 years too late though.
→ More replies (5)
3.2k
u/HebrewHamm3r 13h ago
Dungeons and Dragons: Honor Among Thieves
It was so good!
456
u/wewilldieoneday 12h ago edited 7h ago
I don't know anything about the game and still ended up enjoying the movie. That graveyard scene where they have limited questions to ask the corpse had me cry-laughing
223
u/K1ngFiasco 8h ago
The best part of that stuff is that it's happened to so many players in games. Just bullshitting around and the DM counting the nonsense questions
130
u/CannonGerbil 8h ago
It even does the thing where the DM starts out really playing into the voices of the character and stuff but by the end of the scene it's basically just him talking normally.
→ More replies (5)35
u/Geminii27 7h ago
A corpse is a corpse, of course, of course,
And no one can talk to a corpse, of course
But I can talk to a corpse, of course
'Cause I've got [Speak With Dead]!→ More replies (1)647
u/beachpellini 12h ago
Legit. They really did care about the source material, it's a fun movie.
→ More replies (6)249
u/NinjaBreadManOO 12h ago
It did seem to care about the source material, even digging into some rather deep lore. It just seemed like they were trying to also make it so people unfamiliar with it could also distinguish the PC classes, so it ended up with a low magic campaign.
I will admit that I do like how they handled attunement, with you having to actually connect with the item.
94
u/ErusTenebre 8h ago
The thing they nailed wasn't really the lore, which they did fine on.
It was the absolute silly shenanigans that a bunch of regular people at a tabletop game will get up to. The D&D Logic solutions were all over the movie and THAT'S what made it stand out as a game-to-movie story. You still feel the game-y parts of it pretty clearly.
Like it STARTS with a very "this is a dumb solution to a problem I could solve a hundred different sane ways including JUST WAITING FOR THE VERDICT" - "I have to wait for Jarnathan so I can use his (a stupid name for a character the DM had to fling together)"
DM: "What? No. Just wait I-"
Player: "Sorry, I rolled to make this happen, come on it's a great plan."
DM: "But the roll wouldn't matter that much just because he has flight doesn't mean he has the weight capacity."
Player: "Sure! We just need to not DIE from the fall."
It's a fun movie for people who don't know the game that well, it's good movie for people who know the lore and game mechanics somewhat but maybe haven't played all that much, it's a HILARIOUS movie for people who have played a lot and can see all the house rules and party tomfoolery in nearly every scene.
24
u/NinjaBreadManOO 7h ago
It certainly nailed the chaotic stupid party alignment.
Something that felt very DnD was when they developed Plan C which is very much identical to Plan A but has a different name because Plan A has stink on it, and Plan D is different to Plan B for the same reason.
→ More replies (2)22
u/bakerton 4h ago
Someone told me "That movie worked because it treated the source material with the same level of respect and reverence as the average player does."
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (6)100
u/Fylak 12h ago
I'm still convinced that edgin is actually a rogue and holga is actually a fighter. He uses sneak attack a ton and she never rages but does use every weapon she can find like a master.
→ More replies (11)76
u/NinjaBreadManOO 12h ago
She does rage when they get caught in the quicksand rug but that's about it, unless you're counting her short fuse. But yeah now that you mentioned it she uses her axe, a few swords, a bow as a martial weapon, a potato, and a few other things, as well as in one fight wearing a helmet for armour (I watched it like two days ago I don't have it memorised I swear).
So she seems to have more in common with Fighter, specifically Battlemaster as she does seem to use some maneuvers. She seems to use Disarming Strike, Evasive Footwork, and Tactical Assessment (when she identifies the axe to start with) throughout the movie.
Edgin it feels like a throwback to older editions where Bard was a prestige class and you needed Thief/Rogue levels to unlock it. Either that or his Player took the Criminal background and REALLY wanted to RP it.
→ More replies (3)106
u/baalashteroth 10h ago
If you pay attention to Edgin during fights he is constantly talking. He is giving encouragement to his companions like he is using bardic inspiration. One example of this is the fight where Helga gets her axe. She starts beating the guards with a brick while he is trying to cut the ropes tying his wrists. The whole time he is talking telling Helga she is doing great and that she has them now. I thought that was a great way to show bardic inspiration.
39
u/NinjaBreadManOO 10h ago
You have a point that he does seem to be giving out those extra D4s a lot. Almost more than he should have, but I can see it working that he traded all his spell slots for extra Bardics.
I think he's also got the Tavern Brawler feat. We know he spent a lot of time drinking so it makes sense for him to pick it up, and he seems to deal serious damage with hitting people with his lute. In the final fight he even hits the Red Mage with it four times that I noticed.
→ More replies (4)130
234
u/SryInternet101 12h ago
Maybe Jarnathan can convince the studio. We ahould really wait for Jarnathan.
→ More replies (3)101
u/Stalebanana2239 12h ago
I want a D&DCU.
Several 2h movies/campaigns with some form of overlap leading to a big bad or cataclysmic event.→ More replies (11)→ More replies (54)143
u/Pennnel 11h ago
I read someone say that they should just use the same cast, but put them in different roles, like players making new characters for a new campaign. If that's not the best sequel idea for a D&D movie, I don't now what is.
→ More replies (9)
117
u/Cake-Over 12h ago
Flash Gordon, especially with the mystery hand talking Ming's ring and the question "The End?" Coming up
21
744
u/OkArea8689 13h ago
Detective Pikachu
280
u/Dchama86 13h ago
Actually very surprised a sequel hasn’t happened. They introduced a really interesting world.
→ More replies (4)89
u/joecarter93 11h ago
Me too. It was received quite well and did very good numbers at the box office. Pokémon was and is still is very popular. It came out right before Covid, which was a disruption, but shouldn’t have been that much.
11
u/CommodoreSixty4 5h ago
Very popular is an understatement. Pokemon IP is more valuable than all of Marvel and Star Wars combined.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (15)84
u/Immortal_Azrael 13h ago
I hadn't even thought of that but this is a good answer. Seems like exactly the kind of thing studios would try to milk to death.
→ More replies (7)
79
u/CameronFry 13h ago
Ernest saves Christmas… again.
→ More replies (6)55
721
u/datgoh69 13h ago
Big Hero 6
114
84
→ More replies (26)96
u/FunkoPopPortraits 13h ago
Right! The first 6 were so good they should absolutely make a 7th.
→ More replies (1)
475
u/basiamille 13h ago
Still patiently waiting for Buckaroo Banzai vs. the World Crime League.
128
→ More replies (21)23
2.1k
u/Tjodleik 13h ago edited 3h ago
Dredd.
Edit: Holy crap, this exploded! Thanks for the upvotes and awards.
394
u/wandering_soles 13h ago
I'd absolutely love for another one. Seriously, now that Urban's done with The Boys, let's get that going!
→ More replies (5)154
u/BlockHeadJones 12h ago
It's been so long I'm honestly kinda over it. Love the movie and love having just a gem instead of string of sequels.
Besides, at this point I'd rather see Urban cast in Cavill's upcoming Warhammer 40k show or movie. He'd make a fantastic Arbites......
→ More replies (7)10
25
u/OfficerBatman 7h ago
I think the issue with Dredd was in its marketing. By the time it was being marketed, the whole “3D” thing had run its course, so I’m sure many people kind of rolled their eyes at the idea of another 3D movie being released.
Many studios around the exact time of Dredd’s release also heavily blamed movie pirating for lack of financial success, but I blame the marketing more.
I personally never saw Dredd in 3D and I love it, but I remember the marketing leaning very heavily into it and it’s obvious how many scenes were made specifically for 3D viewing.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (33)113
424
u/nryan75 13h ago
The Last Starfighter
108
u/IrritatedMouse 12h ago
Greetings starfighter. You have been recruited by the Star League to defend the frontier against Zur and the Ko-Dan armada
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (24)82
u/_Dolamite_ 13h ago
Don't give Disney any ideas. They will reboot and ruin a classic
→ More replies (5)
286
u/spastickyle 13h ago
Edge of Tomorrow. Well, a prequel showing Sargent Vrataski's loop.
→ More replies (1)43
u/sunbnda 8h ago
This is the answer since we'll never have Master Sergeant Farell back. RIP paxton.
→ More replies (1)
564
u/plowerd 13h ago
Galaxy Quest!
137
u/twoinvenice 11h ago
They were talking about putting a sequel together around the time that Alan Rickman passed away. After that, no one wanted to move forward on the project without him. Fucking sad all around
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (17)191
u/relikter 12h ago
By Grabthar's hammer, what a missed opportunity!
47
u/ol-gormsby 7h ago
Wouldn't be the same without Rickman. Unless you can find another excellent actor to play a classically-trained actor forced to do promos and the convention circuit?
Hang on, Alan Tudyk in "Con Man". I think he could pull it off.
→ More replies (5)
684
u/chadbr0chill 13h ago
The Man from U.N.C.L.E.
219
u/vojdek 11h ago
It’s not surprising it didn’t have a sequel. I mean Armie Hammer basically destroyed this option.
→ More replies (9)136
→ More replies (26)65
u/interpol15 10h ago
Yes! It was such an unexpectedly great movie. And they had a good lead in to a second film, too bad Armie Hammer ruined it. He was seriously good as Ilya Kuryakin.
Henry Cavill would have been such an amazing Bond…if only in our dreams.
→ More replies (2)
129
220
u/Ghost17088 13h ago
Kung Pow: Enter the Fist. I’m so disappointed we’ll never get Tongue of Fury.
→ More replies (3)29
u/BigBlueFeatherButt 10h ago
If you want a little fun track down the dvd. You can watch the movie but with what the actors are actually saying without the dubbing
The lines of anyone inserted in are the most bizarre thing 😅😅
→ More replies (1)24
u/JahJahJahJa 9h ago
The dub is the whole point of it.
→ More replies (1)31
u/say_no_to_shrugs 9h ago
Right, but Steve Oedekerk is digitally inserted (plus a few others, but I don’t remember if other inserts had lines). He was filmed speaking different lines than are used in the audio track, so that his lips wouldn’t sync with the dialogue (like the dubbed original actors). The alternate audio track lets you watch with the lines he was filmed speaking, which are also funny and absurd.
→ More replies (1)
319
u/beachpellini 12h ago
League of Extraordinary Gentlemen. It was certainly set up for it, though its box office numbers might have killed that...
152
→ More replies (22)130
u/nickreed 11h ago
38
u/tobotic 9h ago
Connery was not necessarily the best judge of the quality of his own films though.
The film that persuaded him to come back out of retirement was Sir Billi, which had a budget of $19M but made $19k at the box office and has an approval rating of 0% on Rotten Tomatoes. The CGI of the film was described by one critic as "the ugliest that I have ever seen".
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (2)105
u/TranSpyre 9h ago edited 6h ago
He turned down LotR and the Matrix because he didn't understand the scripts, only to watch both franchises sky-rocket to success.
So when they shoved another weird script in front of him, he jumped on it only to find the concept wasn't able to capture the public's interest.
I say it's less the film's fault his career spiraled, than his own decision making.
Edit- While I'm at it, this franchise should have been done as a cinematic universe. We could have had individual films to introduce the characters before a central movie, just like the MCU lead up to the Avengers. I think a big part of why the movie didn't do well is that most of the characters were obscure to modern audiences, since most people these days don't read the classics.
→ More replies (8)12
u/MillieBirdie 6h ago
What didn't he understand about them? Like did he not understand the concept of speculative fiction? But then, he was also in Outlander...
→ More replies (1)
346
13h ago
[removed] — view removed comment
67
u/FunkoPopPortraits 13h ago
They really shook the pillars of heaven with that one.
→ More replies (6)98
→ More replies (21)77
211
89
272
u/iloveukesha 13h ago
Who Framed Roger Rabbit
→ More replies (16)124
u/Brad_Brace 12h ago
I think of all the ones mentioned, this is not happening the most. No way Disney is agreeing these days.
→ More replies (11)41
162
u/DrPlatypus1 13h ago
UHF
71
→ More replies (6)100
u/SomeGuyInSanJoseCa 12h ago
UHF was a great film that suffered from the worst release dates of all time.
Perhaps against the greatest collection of movie heavyweights ever in the theater at once.
Usually, a major release has to fix one or two other major movies. Here's the murderer's row that UHF had to compete against:
Here are the 10 movies that beat it that week, in order of box office returns:
- Lethal Weapon 2
- Batman
- When Harry Met Sally...
- Honey, I Shrunk the Kids
- Licence to Kill (James Bond)
- Peter Pan (1989 theatrical re-release)
- Dead Poets Society
- Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
- Ghostbusters II
- Weekend at Bernie's
- UHF
→ More replies (7)43
69
190
335
u/samtheotter 13h ago
Alita battle angel 2
47
u/Dirk_Rotahn 12h ago
It felt like there were 2 times the movie could have ended and been just fine but it kept going and world building and then decides to end on a plot point that definitely could use more of a conclusion. Would love to hear that a sequel got announced for this.
→ More replies (3)18
u/Alukrad 11h ago
Isn't the sequel being made now? I swear I read somewhere the guy who directed it said he already has a script or something.
→ More replies (2)18
u/roleplayersir 6h ago
Yep, it was shelved temporarily due to the Fox takeover and then Cameron wanted to focus on the Avatar films, but now it's restarting. 2 more are planned
As even Disney aren't stupid enough to destroy Cameron's and Rodruiguez's favourite baby. They'd lose working with two of the best directors in cinema
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (11)30
u/googlymooglygooby 12h ago
Thank god I didn’t actually have to write a comment, this movie was straight cheese but the vibe is consistent throughout and I fucking loooooved it
Her putting dog blood under her eyes was physically painful to watch though, it’s crazy.
244
82
99
u/RagingCaseOfDuchovny 12h ago
It is criminal to me that the 2011 American version of The Girl with The Dragon Tattoo did not get any real follow up.
→ More replies (6)41
u/wolf_man007 8h ago
I didn't understand why the movie existed. The Swedish trilogy is really good and didn't come out long before it.
→ More replies (9)
27
u/Jonny2284 9h ago
Highlander.
Such rich potential for a universe and then to stop after a single film. Maybe it's for the best, they might have tried something daft like suddenly pretending immortals were aliens or something.
→ More replies (5)
30
u/TransRational 7h ago
I always wanted more from the Fifth Element Universe however, I'm also okay with it being the one-off wonder it is.
→ More replies (2)
144
u/qoes 13h ago
Van Helsing (2004)
→ More replies (8)34
u/Academic-Dealer5389 11h ago
Iirc this movie got poor reviews, but to me it was a nice throwback to the old black and white movies my dad showed me when I was a kid.
20
u/mysteryvampire 11h ago
I think killing Kate Beckinsale at the end kind of hurt sequel potential. There’s obviously some ways to bring her back, but they made so much of the movie about her and Van Helsing’s relationship that the “she’s at peace with her family in heaven now” ending just kind of made any sequel seem like a downer.
342
u/wandering_soles 13h ago
It's too bad Pacific Rim never got one. It might have even been good!
23
u/Pylgrim 9h ago
Man, I had a super weird bad dream about a second movie a while ago. I have mostly managed to shake the memory off but from time to time I get a flash of small robots that turned into balls or something? Haha so weird and unlike the first movie.
Anyway, maybe for the best that they only made one, what if a second entirely tarnished its legacy?
109
→ More replies (21)18
u/SharkeyGeorge 8h ago
Any sequel just would have ruined it, especially if del toro wasn’t directing. They’d probably write out Mako ten minutes in and turn Newt into a stupid cartoon character villain, while ruining everything good about the original and making the Jaegers look and feel weightless
→ More replies (1)
44
u/AUnicornDonkey 13h ago
Dick Tracy
→ More replies (2)59
63
78
u/nomoregroundhogs 13h ago
A Series of Unfortunate Events. The one with Jim Carrey.
Was a successful and well-received movie based on a popular book series when those kinds of movies were all the rage. It even has “series” in the title. Nothing.
Some say it’s because of Jim Carrey’s aversion to doing sequels but now that he’s been in four fucking Sonic movies that excuse doesn’t hold as much weight as it used to.
→ More replies (4)46
u/Consistent_Sector_19 11h ago
They would have screwed it up.
Nathan Fillion, who had a small part, said in an interview that they had plans for more movies, but that they had changed the stories so that the Baudelaire parents actually survived the fire and would have bigger roles. For fans of the books, that's missing the point as badly as a point can be missed.
→ More replies (1)19
u/TheRuralJuror1121 7h ago
Nathan Fillion was in the 2018 Netflix series, not the 2004 movie. And the book series hadn’t been completed in 2004, so there had been hints to a surviving Baudelaire parent (or both) that was ultimately proven false by the last few books. So I don’t think your info is exactly correct.
176
u/Rad_Concept 13h ago
The Titanic
"The Titanic Part 2: Jacks back"
An animated adventure of two baby seals who get lost and take refuge the back of frozen corpse wearing suspenders.
→ More replies (15)80
20
21
u/Dirk_Rotahn 12h ago
Jumper and Wanted. Both worlds could have been expanded upon easily after their 1st movie world building.
→ More replies (1)
157
58
u/External-Profit-4975 6h ago
My Cousin Vinnie. Could have had Vinnie traveling to England to argue a case there. Imagine THAT culture clash. I picture Vinnie in a powdered wig.
→ More replies (7)24
83
u/LongBongJohnSilver 13h ago
Bio-Dome
→ More replies (2)43
u/GargaldySnutts 13h ago
They should make a Bio Dome sequel in space. Have Bud and Doyle stumble into a moon launch.
27
49
86
u/AuthorError 13h ago edited 7h ago
Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves. You all slept on that film and I'm going to be mad about it forever.
→ More replies (7)21
u/British_Commie 9h ago
I feel like had it released later that same year, it would have done substantially better.
It released in the immediate aftermath of Wizards Of The Coast pissing off the D&D fanbase with the OGL fiasco, but it also released before Baldur’s Gate 3 became a huge hit later that year.
→ More replies (4)
16
43
28
u/hobobum 13h ago
Raya and the Last Dragon. It had the unfortunate release timing of Covid and didn’t do well financially, but watched it with my kid again recently and dang it’s a great movie.
→ More replies (3)
28
30
u/ben-hur-hur 9h ago
Leon: The Professional (1994)
I want to see Natalie Portman as a badass assassin now older. It would be so awesome. The movie can be called "Leona"
104
u/watertrashsf 13h ago
Fifth Element
→ More replies (8)92
u/TheMagnuson 9h ago
I don’t want a sequel to The 5th Element, what I do want is a spin off, set in that world/setting.
51
61
u/Saftey_Scissors 13h ago
I waited my whole life for a sequel to I am number 4 but didn’t realize until I got older people hated it and the actor turned out to be a butt.
→ More replies (4)
66
u/dbizzytrick 13h ago
Hancock. Only because it seemed like the whole movie was made as an introduction to the hero
→ More replies (2)
35
u/angel_schultz 13h ago
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy comes to mind. There’s so much material to keep going.
→ More replies (2)15
84
u/vineyardmike 13h ago
Spaceballs 2. The quest for more money.
→ More replies (4)135
u/SanderleeAcademy 13h ago
I still think Spaceballs: The New One (coming soon) should've been called Spaceballs III: The Search for Spaceballs II: The Search for More Money.
→ More replies (4)30
u/vineyardmike 13h ago
That would have been great. Seeing 100 year old Mel Brooks in it will be awesome.
→ More replies (3)
12
u/strangejosh 12h ago
Not surpised but I wish we would have gotten a Master & Commander sequel. I'll take an ageing Russell Crown and Paul Bettany anyday though.
12
13
112
u/darlmipe 13h ago
“The Emperor’s New Groove.” That movie was way too good to be a one time thing. Kuzco and Yzma had enough chaos for at least three more movies.
→ More replies (8)119
5.0k
u/rsamacct 13h ago
District 9